Why France’s Uncontrolled Rafale Sales May Hurt India

为何法国失控的“阵风”战机销售可能损害印度利益

France’s aggressive push to export Rafale fighter jets—particularly to Gulf nations such as Qatar and the UAE—is raising significant concerns for India’s strategic interests. Under President Emmanuel Macron, the rapid expansion of Rafale sales risks turning a once-exclusive platform into a widely distributed asset, diminishing its strategic value. India’s acquisition of Rafales was positioned as a transformative upgrade for the Indian Air Force (IAF), offering cutting-edge avionics, stealth capabilities, and deep-strike potential. However, France’s expanding defense partnerships in the Middle East are eroding India’s technological edge. The proliferation of Rafales in geopolitically sensitive regions could compromise operational secrecy and reduce India’s deterrence posture. France’s export strategy may inadvertently strengthen rival air forces, including those aligned with Pakistan. The concern extends beyond hardware parity—it touches on the erosion of psychological and tactical superiority that India once held. As India considers further Rafale procurement under the “Make in India” initiative, the broader question emerges: is France sacrificing long-term strategic credibility for short-term commercial gain?

法国大力推动“阵风”战斗机出口——尤其是向卡塔尔、阿联酋等海湾国家出口——这引发了关于印度战略利益受损的重大担忧。在马克龙总统任内，“阵风”战机出口的快速扩张，可能会让这款曾具备“专属属性”的装备变成广泛扩散的资产，战略价值大打折扣。

印度采购“阵风”战机时，将其定位为印度空军的“转型性升级装备”，认为它能提供尖端航电系统、隐身能力和纵深打击潜力。但如今法国在中东拓展防务合作的举动，正不断削弱印度的技术优势。

“阵风”战机在地缘政治敏感地区的扩散，可能会危及印度的作战保密性，同时降低威慑力。法国的出口策略还可能在无意间增强敌方空军实力，包括那些与巴基斯坦结盟的空军。

这种担忧不仅限于“装备对等”层面——更涉及印度曾拥有的心理优势和战术优势的丧失。眼下印度正考虑在“印度制造”计划下进一步采购“阵风”战机，一个更核心的问题随之浮现：法国是否在为了短期商业利益，牺牲长期战略可信度？

以下是印度网友的评论：
pavishan1
In that case we need to have special version of Raffale which is different from France supplying other nations

这样的话，我们得要“阵风”的特殊版本才行，得跟法国卖给其他国家的不一样。

rt1761
For that u have to be Israel. They Modified F35 according to their indigenous tech. Now F35 of Israel can outfox what the Americans manufacture

要做到这一点，你得先有以色列那本事。他们用自己的本土技术改造了F-35，现在以色列的F-35比美国原厂造的还厉害，能玩得更溜。

zeroshah9303
Ganja mara hai kia

你是吸大麻吸糊涂了吧

bamaaan
Don’t know why we need to worry on social media. The military establishment such as Airforce and other experts would know about this

真搞不懂为什么要在社交媒体上瞎操心。印度空军这类军方机构，还有其他专家，肯定都清楚这事。

Valuable_vivek
And they may be worried too

说不定他们（军方和专家）也在担心呢。

enlightnedsoul4124
This is very important. We need to take this cautiously

这很关键，我们得谨慎对待。

gbabhijithclt
Qatar,UAE may transfer technology to Pak

卡塔尔、阿联酋可能会把阵风的技术传给巴基斯坦。

ccjuertao
As the third most powerful air force in the world, India has played a very effective role in supporting the Rafale fighter jets. Today, even American fighter jets were shot down in the South China Sea. I think the Indian Air Force should be ranked number one in the world. There's no doubt about it! Praise India

作为全球第三强的空军，印度在运用“阵风”战机方面发挥得很出色。如今连美国战机都在南海被击落了，我觉得印度空军应该排世界第一，这毫无疑问！为印度喝彩！

ninersnation3298
These punks don’t even have rare earth metals. Those AMCA are trash without rare earth

这帮家伙连稀土都没有。没有稀土，（印度国产先进中型战斗机项目）AMCA就是一堆垃圾。

dabany-c1c
wow very delusional.

哇，真是太妄想了。

antonyjames4441
This happens when we don't have our own advanced jets

谁让我们没有自己的先进战机呢，才会出这种事。

fearlessnoob47
Yeah I mean with citizens like you it's a surprise we have even reached this far.

是啊，有你这种国民，我们国家还能发展到现在，真是够意外的。

Thatwasawesome07
Only cow based religion in india.

印度就只有以牛为信仰的宗教

bamaaan
I don’t think its that easy. If that is the case then F 16s have also been sold to nations which are adversaries of each other like Greece and turkey. There would be some technological barrier to prevent other nations from sharing such information

我觉得没那么简单。要是真能随便传技术，那F-16也卖给希腊和土耳其这种敌对国家了。肯定有技术限制，防止这些信息被共享。

bamaaan
Defense sales come in with a lot of conditions. If that is the case then these countries can reengineer the product.

军火销售附带很多条件的。要是没这些条件，那些国家早就逆向破解武器了。

Vipul0077
So, it's easy. Make your own godamnn planes. But this HAL is incompetent.

所以啊，多简单的事——自己造飞机不就行了。可印度斯坦航空有限公司就是没本事。

prathmeshsagole4325
Looks like you are incompetent in comprehending the technology required for this to be produced it's not like HAL can't manufacture the aircraft see for tejas but the core lies in kaveri engine which is develo stage and is not easy to make by any country. Research before you speak

看来你根本不懂造飞机需要啥技术。不是HAL造不出飞机，你看“光辉”战机（Tejas）不就是他们造的吗？问题核心在“卡佛里”发动机，这发动机还在研发阶段，而且任何国家造起来都不容易。说话前先做点功课吧。

ittakes2-2tango
So France forgot to put all these awesome features into those Indian Rafale planes that got shot down by Pakistan.

这么说，法国是忘了把那些厉害功能装到印度的“阵风”上了？不然怎么会被巴基斯坦击落呢。

magneshp6060
You think you are buying items for a flan recipe

你以为这是在买做焦糖布丁的材料呢（想怎么挑就怎么挑）？

kannanzmundackal
India can conducts military drills with Russia's enemy Britain, so that Britain can understand the working of Russian sukhoi fighters. Opportunists have no value in this world

印度能和俄罗斯的敌人英国搞联合军演，让英国摸清俄罗斯苏霍伊战机的底细。机会主义者在这世上毫无价值。

AmazingVibes1000
Its hard time for india to have indigenous 6th gen fighter

印度现在该下苦功搞国产第六代战机了。

Don_com_cq
India cannot even make indigenous jet engine

印度连国产喷气发动机都造不出来。

xali860
lol India cant even make a 4.5 gen aircraft most of the components are from west engines from America and electronics from Pisrael and thinking India will make 1 6th generation Aircraft. You making an average for 4 Hal Tejas a year at this rate the amount you need that have been order 15 years by then they will be obsolete.

哈哈，印度连4.5代战机都造不出来——大部分零件靠西方，发动机来自美国，电子设备来自以色列（原文“Pisrael”含贬义），还想着造第六代战机？你们HAL平均一年才造4架“光辉”，照这速度，要完成已订购的数量得花15年，到时候这些飞机早就过时了。

FayazHussainJakhro
Indian jokers living in their own hallow world

印度这帮蠢货活在自己的虚幻世界里。

SahilKumar-nb5yw
These so called jokers broke your country into 2 pieces with 93k pant removed

就是这些所谓的“蠢货”，把你们国家分成了两块，还俘虏了9.3万人

ganeshj7430
Rafael company not allowed for software update if they allow then it would be more powerful for Indian Airforce

“阵风”公司不允许给（印度的“阵风”）做软件升级。要是允许升级，印度空军的战力肯定会更强。

RahulKumar-my2nb
Any one here from aand force

这里有人是空军的吗？

srv9067
Rafale fighters are over priced and over hyped

“阵风”战机又贵又被吹得太厉害。

vinayakcc
A valid concern but also the one we have to live with as the same applies to any technology. Besides USA, Russia, France, etc. defence equipment manufacturers too might feel the same when India conducts joint exercises with their perceived opponents.

这个担忧确实有道理，但我们也只能接受——任何技术都存在这个问题。而且，当印度和美国、俄罗斯、法国等国眼中的“对手”搞联合军演时，这些国家的军火商恐怕也会有同样的顾虑。

Sim_Fifa23-24
That's why we need to have our own.

所以我们才需要有自己的战机啊。

Fuq-b8h
7 got shot down by the Pakistan air defence.

有7架印度战机被巴基斯坦防空系统击落了。

imamyousomtimes
why the hell did UAE buys French fighters when they can buy American upgraded by Israel technology

阿联酋明明能买经以色列升级的美国战机，为什么偏偏要买法国的？

imranhasan2856
It's their choice Do they have to get permission from India ?

这是他们（阿联酋）的选择，难道还得经过印度同意吗？

vijithvij
Qatar and UAE Rafale has been flown by retired Pakistani Airforce Pilots!

卡塔尔和阿联酋的“阵风”战机，都是由巴基斯坦空军退役飞行员驾驶的！

rexsingh3330
India must build tejas mk2 asap

印度必须尽快造出“光辉”MK2。

Thesaten12
Instead of rafales india should consider other options like typhoon or grippen or the Japanese F2

印度不该买“阵风”，该考虑其他选择，比如欧洲“台风”战机、瑞典“鹰狮”战机或者日本的F-2战机。

hitzrocks4225
Russia is only the best friend of India next to Israel We should only go with Russian weapons if we are importing Jai Hind

俄罗斯是印度仅次于以色列的最好朋友。要是进口武器，我们就该只买俄罗斯的。印度必胜！

NOTHINGO0FFICIAL
India is the only country using Rafael for real Combat. Others countries are using for their purchasing power.

印度是唯一把“阵风”用于实战的国家，其他国家买它不过是为了彰显购买力。

MadhavJoshi-g7b
India has made big mistake of not ordering more Rafale. Now still unable to get act together. SU57 will come under CAATSA

印度当初没多订“阵风”，真是犯了大错。现在还是没理清头绪，而苏-57（俄罗斯战机）又会受美国《以制裁反击美国敌人法案》（CAATSA）限制（无法采购）。

tydf229
Well, India can buy the “most expensive” foreign aircrafts in the market, someone might have more money to spend on the same things. Why worry about it?

反正印度能买得起市场上“最贵”的外国战机，说不定还有人愿意花更多钱买同款呢，有什么好担心的？

jitmick
This goes on to say that AMCA is the only way forward

这说明，（印度国产先进中型战斗机项目）AMCA才是唯一的出路。

vachan7069
Rafale is slower than HAL in production. They both are sloths in delivery of customer orders.

“阵风”的生产速度比HAL还慢，两者在交付客户订单方面都慢得像树懒。

ranjanbehera7488
If they prepared it they have all weights to sale it.If India feels unsafe don't buy it.

法国既然造出了“阵风”，就有权利卖。印度要是觉得不安全，别买就行了。

jliang70
China is not interested in Rafael because in BVR battle it could not even beat a J10CE. RAFAEL's electronic warfare system does not work against PL15

中国对“阵风”没兴趣，因为在超视距作战中，它连歼-10CE都打不过，而且“阵风”的电子战系统防不住霹雳-15导弹。

paradiseconstructionsoluti9288
ये फ्रांस अपने देश के म्यूजियम का एंटीक हिरा का 800 करोड़ का 3 चोर से 10 बजे दिन में बचा नहीं पाया,, और भारत को अपना जेट बेचकर सुरक्षा दे रहा है

法国连自己国家博物馆里价值80亿卢比的古董钻石，都在白天10点被3个小偷偷走了，还想靠卖战机给印度来提供“安全保障”？

salmaniumair1240
Indian should buy the whole rafale company, it's possible?

印度应该把整个“阵风”公司买下来，这有可能吗？

kgmuralidharan07
Do India have any other option. Best option would be to go for indigenous fighters like Tejas.

印度还有别的选择吗？最好的选择还是发展“光辉”这类国产战机。

arashh23
Delusion is creating your own happiness I guess

我觉得，妄想就是自己给自己制造快乐吧。

primepatriotone2443
Looks like you are exposing the vital infos to the world, are you not?

你这像是在把重要信息泄露给全世界，不是吗？

Leo-c4g
Well India once again was asleep, why could they not invest in RND to focus on these technology or collaborate with partners to achieve this.

印度又一次反应迟钝了。他们为什么不投资研发、专注于这些技术，或者和合作伙伴联手搞呢？

srikant-w9p
It means we cant buy any aircraft or fighter jet

照这么说，我们印度什么飞机、战机都不能买了？

rivaholdings4070
Indian pilots don't know how to drive car. Then how they fly fighter jets. South Indians are not joining Indian military

印度飞行员连车都不会开，还怎么开战机？而且南方印度人都不参军。

lesliecheung1478
China is working on gen 6 fighters, while the Rafale is only 4.5 gen and got taken out by the PL-15 with ease. As usual more Indian BS

中国都在搞第六代战机了，而“阵风”只是4.5代，还能被霹雳-15轻松击落。印度还是老样子，净说废话。

Pain-zd5uo
China's 6 gen fighter jets are equivalent to 4.5 gen fighter jets. This is why IAF is ranked higher than PLAAF in the recent Air Power statistics.

中国的第六代战机也就相当于4.5代水平，这就是为啥在最近的空中力量排名里，印度空军（IAF）比中国人民解放军空军（PLAAF）排名高。

rajeshkumarm6441
Rafale is a failure. They are selling left , right and centre before countries learn about rafale useless

“阵风”就是个失败品。法国在各国发现“阵风”没用之前，赶紧到处抛售。

verdi2310
You still very naive as a nation. You should be more concerned about americans telling France to stop selling you sensible Rafale tech at any moment than about China. When are you going to understand the americans are your strategic adversary, not China?

你们国家还是太天真了。比起中国，你们更该担心美国随时让法国停止向你们出售关键的“阵风”技术。你们到底要到什么时候才明白，美国才是你们的战略对手，不是中国？

继续阅读：海湾国家   法国   阵风战机

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 资讯 » 法国向海湾国家大力推销阵风战机，印度战略利益或受损