Is India’s $4 Trillion GDP Actually a Trap? | Economic Case Study

印度4万亿美元GDP真的是个陷阱吗？ 经济案例研究

India just hit the $4 trillion GDP mark !!! We've raced past the United Kingdom, we have beaten Japan, and we are now the world's 4th largest economy!!!!

So the Indian economic miracle is here, right!!!

NO NO NO!!!

Guys!! Come on, it's okay to be happy with 4 trillion dollars, but do you realise, India looks nothing like Japan, UK or France!!

印度刚刚突破4万亿美元GDP大关！我们已经超越英国，击败日本，现在成为世界第四大经济体！

所以，印度经济奇迹真的来了，对吗？不不不！

各位！说实话，为4万亿美元感到高兴无可厚非，但你们有没有意识到，印度看起来根本不像日本、英国或法国！！

The Poor and impact montages
And don't get me wrong—it's a milestone.
But here’s the thing about milestones:
Sometimes they’re signs of progress. Sometimes they’re tombstones with better lighting.
Because behind the $4 trillion flex
is a silent, cree danger
that has already crushed Malaysia, Brazil, South Africa, and Thailand.
And I am not saying, this the world fucking bank itself is saying this!!!
It’s called the Middle-Income Trap.

贫困与现实的蒙太奇

别误会——这确实是一个里程碑。 但关于里程碑，有一点需要注意： 有时它们是进步的标志，有时则是墓碑。 因为在4万亿美元的炫耀背后， 隐藏着一种悄然蔓延的危险， 这种危险已经击垮了马来西亚、巴西、南非和泰国。 而且这不是我说的，是世界银行自己说的！！ 它被称为“中等收入陷阱”。

So before we light more fireworks over GDP,
India is already getting divided!!
While one India is celebrating $4 trillion...
The other India is wondering how to stretch ₹400 till the end of the month.
One India is building startups...
The other India is still building toilets.
One India is flying to Bali for offsites...
The other India is walking 5 km for clean water.
And both these Indias are real.
They exst on the same street.
Sometimes... even in the same house.

所以，在我们为GDP燃放烟花之前， 印度已经开始分裂！ 当一个印度在庆祝4万亿美元时…… 另一个印度在琢磨如何用400卢比撑到月底。 一个印度在创建初创企业…… 另一个印度还在修建厕所。 一个印度人飞往巴厘岛开异地会议…… 另一个印度人步行5公里寻找清洁水源。 这两个印度都是真实存在的。 它们存在于同一条街上， 有时甚至存在于同一屋檐下。

But the truth is—a $4 trillion economy with two Indias...
is not a success story.
It’s an incomplete one.

但事实是——拥有两个“印度”的4万亿美元经济体…… 不是一个成功的故事， 而是一个不完整的故事。

以下是印度网友的评论：

karthikeyank7467
Corruption bro.... We Indians eternally trapped at corruption.

兄弟，腐败啊。我们印度人永远困在腐败里了。

ajeoa102
India needs a massive cultural change and education change towards innovation and against copy-paste rote learning. Unless this changes, it is hopeless. Rebel against the idiot old people who are stuck in their stupid ways. Times have changed

印度需要大规模的文化变革和教育变革，大力推进创新，反对死记硬背的填鸭式教学。除非改变这一点，否则没希望。反抗那些固守愚蠢方式的老古董吧，时代已经变了。

pratiksrivastav2655
And a stricter more fair judicial system

还需要更严格、更公平的司法体系。

karthikeyank7467
@pratiksrivastav2655 yes a corrupted politician who plundered crores can still win in next election and verdict for a simple land dispute over ownership can be delivered as fast as three decades

没错，贪了几千万的腐败政客还能在下次选举中获胜，一个简单的土地所有权纠纷判决可能快则三十年才能下来。

dummy9517
@ajeoa102 this. The first two points particularly.
A massive CULTURAL & EDUCATIONAL change that touches on creating ideas, finding problems and solutions, being smart, addressing civic sense and prioritizing real growth by building, creating, exporting, addressing, servicing, curing &

就是这个，尤其是前两点。需要大规模的文化和教育变革，包括创造想法、发现问题和解决办法、培养智慧、提升公民意识，还要通过建设、创造、出口、处理问题、提供服务、治愈社会等方式，把真正的增长放在首位。

riteshpatel5569
Corruption exsts everywhere. I’m 30 years in US and have seen it in personal, corporate and government.

腐败到处都有。我在美国待了30年，在个人层面、企业里和政府中都见过腐败。

sayendeepmahanty8141
And who are supporting that and who are doing it.

那到底是谁在支持腐败，又是谁在搞腐败呢？

prithviraj1080
This is it. Starting and running a business is a herculean task.

就是这样。创办和经营企业简直是艰巨无比的任务。

chinmoynagarkar7680
Japan’s 12.5 crore people -> $4.186T GDP
India’s 140 crore people -> $4.187T GDP

日本1.25亿人口——GDP 4.186万亿美元。印度14亿人口——GDP 4.187万亿美元

erp_ambidoi
Yeah @chinmoynagarkar7680 what abt US 34 crores but number 1 wrt GDP.. population alone doesn't contribute to GDP
You should look at India's GDP performance in the last decade and can easily project the future... but obviously we won't have to

没错，美国3.4亿人口却稳居GDP第一呢。单靠人口根本拉动不了GDP。你应该看看印度过去十年的GDP表现，很容易就能预测未来。

Annadatasukhibhavah
"I started my first job in the BPO sector back in 2011 with a salary of ₹11,000 per month. Today, in 2025, my friend's younger brother has joined the same industry in a similar entry-level position, and he's earning just ₹10,000. In the last 15 years, inflation has gone up by nearly 100%, but the basic salary for such jobs has either stagnated or even declined. If this is the reality, can we truly say our country is progressing — or are we silently slip backwards?"

“我2011年第一份工作在业务流程外包（BPO）行业，月薪1.1万卢比。到了2025年的今天，我朋友的弟弟进入同一行业，做类似的入门级岗位，月薪却只有1万卢比。15年来，通胀率几乎涨了100%，但这类工作的基本工资要么停滞不前，甚至还下降了。如果这就是现实，我们真的能说国家在进步吗？还是说我们在默默倒退？”

Debsiskar
More literacy means more competition. More competition for job means more opportunity for companies to limit wages.

识字率提高意味着竞争更激烈。就业竞争越激烈，公司就越有机会压低工资。

rajmalik7558
That's why we need labour laws.
Private companies are not increasing the salary of their employees on the other hand their CEO's are earning crores.

所以我们需要劳动法。私营公司不给员工涨工资，可他们的CEO却能赚几千万。

fs203tusharchandaliya4
That's the truth CEO's are earning more money while squeezing the income of the middle class...They have kept the salaries stagnant....

这就是事实，CEO们赚得盆满钵满，却在挤压中产阶级的收入。他们让工资一直原地踏步

ajaysingh-lo4xf
It depends on the company my starting salary was 15500 so please don't post a bunch of crap

这得看公司，我起薪是15500卢比，所以别发一堆废话了。

FaithOnMeGuys
Start thinking creatively and take initiative to build something of your own—it's the key to real growth. The world has changed, but many of us haven’t adapted, and that’s the real challenge.
Chasing a degree just to land a job and repeat the same cycle isn’t the only path anymore. We need to shift this mindset—not just in India, but globally. The issue isn’t location; it’s how we think.
It’s time to break free from old patterns and embrace new ways of creating value. Let’s be the change.

开始创造性地思考，主动去打造属于自己的事业——这是关键。世界已经变了，我们很多人还没适应，这才是真正的挑战。如今，只为找份工作而追学位，已经不是唯一的路了。我们需要转变心态——不仅是在印度，全球都需要。问题不在于地点，而在于我们的思维方式。是时候打破旧模式，拥抱创造价值的新方式了。让我们成为改变的力量。

chandrasekharmukherjee2794
It's an outright lie. You are shameless.

这完全是谎言，你太无耻了。

TheDihedral
Dude... the problem is you and your relative has not moved up the value chain. BPO is done and dusted. Upskill yourself.
This Podcaster is waaay out of line. There is significant innovation happening. South Korea does not have the same baggage as India, where political parties are continuously pulling down the one party that is actually trying to make a difference.

老兄……问题在于你和你亲戚没爬上价值链。业务流程外包（BPO）已经过时了，提升自己的技能吧。

印度明明在进行重大创新。韩国可没有印度这样的包袱——印度的政党一直在拖后腿，哪怕有一个党真心想做出改变，其他党也在不断打压。

ankkkit
That's the problem 98 percent of the population in india pointing out the flaws and doing nothing

问题就在于，印度98%的人光说不做

Global_affairs4india
They don't really want to do anything that's the harsh reality
Whoever wants to do something they are grabbing the opportunity

残酷的现实是，他们根本不想做事。

想做事的人，早就抓住机会了。

AdityaDsouza-s1r
Leaving India thats done

那就离开印度，就这么简单。

binskee677
It‘s called education. Be glad people are pointing out flaws! What are you doing against it?

这就叫教育。有人指出问题应该高兴！你有做什么来改变现状呢？

AnthonyPascal-f3t
Even if India reach 15 or 20 trillion, the country will still have this problem

就算印度GDP达到15万亿或20万亿美元，这个国家依然会有这些问题。

Beginner-y4u
It's because of over population

这是因为人口过剩。

hemantrao-d2d
Because of lack of education, inequality of income, corruption, pathetic taxation policy, quota system or reservation and over population

因为缺乏教育、收入不平等、腐败、糟糕的税收政策、配额制（预留制度）和人口过剩。

aved6095
yes because we will be poor that time too because other countries will also grow their economy when india reached 20 trillion dollar china america already had 100 trillion dollar economy

没错，到时候我们还是会很穷——当印度GDP达到20万亿美元时，中国和美国的经济早就达到100万亿美元了。

riyasawant7173
@hemantrao-d2d Inequality is not bad thing.

 不平等并非坏事。

baritheexanxs7986
Proof that only GDP is not enough to attain economic growth and development of an economy.

这证明了仅靠GDP不足以实现一个经济体的经济增长和发展。

rawheadshot
India needs 500 trillion GDP to actually feel it.

印度需要500万亿美元GDP才能真正有富裕的感觉。

RohitChandel-nc1gm
Than what your view on China . China is almost same populated as india . But this country is not like India . In every aspect.

你对中国怎么看？中国人口和印度差不多，但这个国家在各个方面都比印度更强

Anandhumadhu5678
@Beginner-y4u no bro our population is our strength

兄弟，我们的人口是我们的优势。

kishan802
Yup , Every coin has two side and one should consider both side , seeing only the good side of coin often make people delusional

没错，每枚硬币都有两面，应该兼顾两面看问题。只看好处往往会让人产生错觉。

Beginner-y4u
@RohitChandel-nc1gm Have you ever been to China? How can you say

 你去过中国吗？怎么能这么说？

dishant986
Understand this concept of income disparity. You’ll understand the problem

理解收入差距这个概念，你就会明白问题所在了。

catalystgang586
The only solution is per capita, not high gdp

唯一的解决办法是人均（GDP），而不是高GDP。

sushantkadam3975
For innovation we need mindset patience funds,
Startups in India only has glamour, trading mentality only figures

要创新，我们需要有正确的心态、耐心和资金。印度的初创企业只有光鲜的外表，满脑子都是交易心态和数字游戏。

adityachaudhary1610
How many countries haveade it to 4 trillion dollars GDP ?
China also did it some years back, and people in same west looked down upon them
Is its a BIG milestone, We have a very long way to go
And if you want rapid change and constant growth
Give 2 decades to Capitalist and see the magic,
South Korea, Vietnam, China are prime example for it

有多少国家GDP达到4万亿美元？中国几年前也做到了，当时西方国家的人看不起他们。这确实是个重要的里程碑，但我们还有很长的路要走。如果你想要快速变革和持续增长，那就让资 本主义统治二十年，看看会有什么奇迹，

韩国、越南、中国都是最好的例子。

vinayak6685
High time to realise GDP of country is NOT the right measure to evaluate country's situation

是时候意识到，GDP并不是评估国家状况的正确标准了。

nike9971
That is where China won. They did nt just depend on cheap labour alone. They innovated, reverse engineered, improved, and created their own products to be their own master.

这就是中国的成功之处。他们不单纯依赖廉价劳动力，而是创新、逆向工程、改进，创造出自己的产品，成为自己的主人。

hrushikeshavachat900
What you are talking about is a genuine issue. But I think India is still in lower middle income. We need to first achieve higher middle income country and then think about the middle income trap. However, I agree that we need to be worried about this trap and need to find ways to avoid the middle income trap.

你说的确实是个实实在在的问题。但我觉得印度目前还处于中低收入阶段，需要先成为中高收入国家，再考虑中等收入陷阱的问题。不过，我同意我们需要警惕这个陷阱，想办法避开它。

继续阅读：印度经济   印度GDP   经济体

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 资讯 » 经济奇迹真的来了，印度4万亿美元GDP是个陷阱吗，看起来根本不像日本、英国或法国