历史上首次出现这样的情况:越南国土面积仅为印度的八分之一,全球出口份额却和印度持平
For the first time in history, Vietnam despite being one-eighth the size of India has matched India's share of world exports.
历史上首次出现这样的情况:越南国土面积仅为印度的八分之一,但其全球出口份额已经和印度持平。

以下是各国网友的评论:
ar98k762mm
Indias consumption on goods and services produced are largely domestic (~60% of the GDP, which is $4T). Where as vietnam has far less domestic consumption compared to India so the money making idea for them is exports.
印度国内自产商品、服务的消费主要靠本土内需支撑,内需占GDP比重约60%,印度GDP总量4万亿美元。越南本土消费市场规模远比不上印度,所以越南只能靠出口创收。
krishna teja
Vietnamese households consume 30% more
越南家庭的消费能力比印度高出三成。
JjxWood
In per capital consumption, vietnam is larger than India since their gdp per capita is higher.
越南人均GDP更高,所以人均消费额也超过印度。
Neenadarul
Ab toh sharm karlo kab tak churan becho ge
这下该觉得丢人了,还要靠吹嘘自欺欺人到什么时候。
icopesoi
"goods exports"... thier service exports is 30 billion ours is 421 billion.. context is important yk
人家说的只是商品出口,越南服务出口仅300亿美元,我们有4210亿美元,看数据不能断章取义。
raan
Again this joker!
又是这个跳梁小丑!

GUTS
also our merch exports are rising at 16% yoy.. so dont worry... we are entering electronics and semiconductors too.. its just gonna increase
我们商品出口同比涨幅16%,完全不用焦虑。我们也在布局电子、半导体产业,出口额只会持续上涨。
Rahul
You are factually wrong you only showed the global merchandise export data for India and Vietnam. India still exports more than Vietnam in total exports Vietnam has only matched India's merchandise exports it not export or matched India's share of world export.
你给出的信息存在事实错误,只拿两国商品出口数据对比。算上全部出口,印度出口总额依旧高于越南,越南只是商品出口规模追上印度,并非整体出口、全球出口份额持平。
dfdfdf123654
India is just like Pakistan; it runs a massive surplus in services trade. This is primarily driven by people working overseas remitting their earnings back to India. Do you consider this something to be proud of?
印度和巴基斯坦情况类似,服务贸易顺差规模很大。这份顺差主要靠海外务工人员汇款回国支撑,这有什么值得夸耀的?
Rahul
India’s services surplus isn’t driven by overseas remittances—remittances count as transfers not services trade.
The real driver High-value knowledge exports like IT, software, engineering, and Global Capability Centers based inside India. It’s a massive domestic engine to be proud of
印度服务贸易顺差和海外汇款无关,汇款属于资金转移,不算服务贸易。
真正拉动顺差的是高附加值知识出口,比如信息技术、软件、工程服务,还有国内各地的全球服务中心,这是实打实的本土经济动力,值得自豪。
VivaaPalestine
How is he factually wrong when Its clearly mentioned Merchandise Exports !! He would have been wrong had he said only exports. World over in trade and economics, its only the merchandise exports they talk of, goods produced by a country. In services nothing is produced.
原文明确写了商品出口,哪里存在事实错误?如果他说的是全部出口,才算说错。全球经贸领域讨论出口,默认指实体商品,服务业并不产出实物产品。
shok_jainaj
It might be Chinese goods is being exported through Vietnam
越南的出口里,有不少是中国货物借道外销。
johnblissnow
Most export companies in Vietnam are owned by China.
越南大部分出口企业都由中方控股。
volklub
Hum kya export karein yaar? Har cheez mein to China ke imported maal ne backbone tod hi manufacturing ki.
我们还能出口什么?各行各业的本土制造业,都被中国进口货冲垮了。
Bhuvan
Hum politicians ko export kar sakte hain kya, that will give good forex as well. Waise bhi yahan politicians apni country se jyada bahar hi rehte hai
要不干脆把政客出口换外汇得了,这群人本来也常年待在国外。
Anurag Singh
There's this Mr. DYI store I saw last year in a mall in Noida.
It's flooded with very cheap 3rd class Chinese daily household stuff. The shop smells like cheap plastic and rubber.
Half of that stuff will fail a real quality test.
Blew my mind!
去年我在诺伊达商场看到一家DIY杂货店,店里摆满廉价劣质的中国日用杂货,一进门全是劣质塑料、橡胶的刺鼻气味。
一半商品过不了正规质检,实在离谱。
Perplexed
This was not the case till UPA I era.
UPA 2 starting and more so from Modi 1.0 era, everything was china import. Till the last nut and bolt.
12 years of majority govt and we never did labour reforms !
国大党第一届执政时期还不是这样。从第二届国大党政府,再到莫迪第一任期,大小商品全都依赖中国进口,小到螺丝螺母都不例外。
执政党掌权十二年,劳工改革始终没有落地。
Chase
Bhai khatam hai Yeh desh
Faaltu me itne freedom fighters ne azaadi ke liye Jaan dedi
Congress 10x bekaar thi BJP 1000x bekaar hai
这个国家算是没救了。
当年无数独立志士白白牺牲,国大党已经够没用,人民党更是差上千倍。
Mephistopheles
Vietnam imports cotton from India, and exports finished textiles all over the world.
越南从印度进口棉花,加工成成品布料后销往全球。
Dark Knight
Sir ji, Ethanol export karenge hum
放心,我们以后靠出口乙醇撑场面。
meepmeep
Does Vietnam has Ladlibehen yojana? Free busses for women? Reservation for minorities? And nunerous other schemes, people leech on? Where does innovation comes from when people can live like Kings&Queeens without working
越南有女性免费公交、少数群体就业预留这类福利政策吗?一大堆福利让民众不用干活也能过得舒服,这样怎么发展创新?
Akhilesh Khandelwal
India's total export with ITES is $900b, while Vietnam total is $425b
We are almost touching trillion dollars.
算上信息技术服务出口,印度总出口额9000亿美元,越南仅有4250亿。我们马上就能突破万亿大关。
Ramadhir Singh
The only thing India is great at exporting are it’s educated people and labourers
印度最擅长出口的,只有受过教育的人才和底层劳工。
Dr Nilima Srivastava
When he was commerce minister he said trade agreements with ASEAN countries is silly because they are China’s B team
Today
India’s imports from China soar to $80 billion in first half of 2026,
India's finished steel imports from China have surged to all time high
他当年担任商务部长时,还说和东盟签贸易协定毫无意义,东盟就是中国的二线附庸。
可如今2026上半年,印度对华进口额暴涨至800亿美元,从中国进口成品钢材的规模更是创下历史新高。
baghiHum
Let’s begin with the Vietnam boycott campaign. As a nation, we have ceased introspection to comprehend our mistakes.
我们该发起抵制越南商品的行动。整个国家都不肯反思自身问题。
MTweets
What a shame!! Neta heads should roll in Delhi
太丢人了,德里的官员该引咎下台。
Abhishek Shrivastava
Is it total export? Or a trade specific? Stop fooling ppl with half truth
对比的是全部出口,还是单一品类出口?别拿片面数据误导大众。
Jaimalphatta
All smart folks know that this is China's export in the the name of Vietnam.
明眼人都清楚,这些出口额本质是中国借越南的名头外销。
J Woodey
India and Vietnam are the same, both are China+1, but Vietnam is wng.
印度和越南都在推行中国加一供应链策略,但越南做得更成功。
BigDawg
Aye, India's exports did not fall.
Vietnam's exports has risen.
印度出口并没有下滑,只是越南出口增长太快。
nikhil kamani
If there exports reduce now let’s say 0.1 % from current , media will say master stroke !!! India beat Vietnam in exports
只要越南出口小幅回落0.1%,媒体立马大肆宣扬,说我们出口反超越南、政策大获成功。
Karthick TN
PVN Rao reforms & then Vajpayee govt created spike in Indian exports
But the 10 years of Sonia Gandhi UPA trashed India's economy who's effect still lasts till today
Now Under PM Modi in the past 12 yrs
India's exports have almost doubled
from 466 to 866 billion USD
拉奥改革、瓦杰帕伊执政时期,印度出口迎来暴涨。
索尼娅领导的国大党十年执政把经济搞得一团糟,负面影响延续至今。
莫迪总理执政十二年,出口规模近乎翻倍,从4660亿涨到8660亿美元。
Arun Khanna
1947 to 2014, Britain 1/16th of India has exported more than us. Japan .. long list .. what type of BS comparisons are this
1947到2014年,面积仅印度十六分之一的英国,出口都常年高于我们,日本等国更是数不胜数,这种对比毫无意义。
MangoMan
Godi Media
They will come up with some kind of Matchup or They will not put this news on AIR.
御用媒体要么找别的数据平衡舆论,要么直接压下这条新闻不播报。
Mehmaan
Before 2014 we were even BEHIND sub Sahara African countries,ye kaum btayega bhadwe khangressi dalle
2014年之前,我们出口甚至比不上撒哈拉以南非洲国家,全是国大党当年留下的烂摊子。
Aniruddha
This is only merchandise exports, our country has heavily invested in IT/ services exports, if we consider that, our exports are more than double of Vietnam!
这仅仅是实体商品出口,我们大力发展信息技术服务出口,两项加总,出口总额是越南两倍以上。
Divyanayanfin
Stop spreading fake lies , india is number 1 in the world . America and Vietnam is nothing in front of us . India’s currency is strongest in the world and all world trades happen in rupees .
别散播虚假消息,印度全球第一,美国、越南根本不值一提。卢比是全球最强货币,国际贸易都在用卢比结算。
AnamjemWAK
The real factor is that Vietnam is long war torn country not India!
核心原因是越南常年饱受战乱,发展环境和印度完全不一样。
31Pacifist
See the graph properly, India is rising
仔细看图表,印度出口整体处于上升通道。
4_5741
I have tweeted in past I was told by one shoe shop owner when I asked why show collection are so less in H'bad, he said leather from India goes to Vietnam and returns in form of shoes,chappals and % of return is very less compared to leather sent. chappal also from Vietman
我之前发过推文,海德拉巴一家鞋店老板跟我说,本地皮革原料运往越南加工,再做成鞋子、拖鞋运回印度,成品回流的数量远不及出口的原料,市面上拖鞋全是越南产。
Bimal
That's why you are an gem sitting on this graph and many like you. So what's the size will do here.
你看得倒是通透,可国土面积大又能改变什么?
Romeo
Well to be fair SEA is superior to SA
客观来讲,东南亚整体发展水平远超南亚。
SmalWorld3
And Indian people still neck deep in social media instead of doing productive work. Shame on destructive Indians.
很多印度人整天泡在社交媒体,不做实业,实在丢人。
JetRay
One other reason why vietnam is exporting more is bcos lot more chinese companies have their presence in vietnam. Exports from vietnam get preferential treatment compared to exports from china.
越南出口规模大涨的另一个关键:大量中国企业在当地建厂,越南出口商品相比中国,能享受关税优惠。
lwsindia
Hutiya aadmi that is due to petroleum products.. non sense talk is ideology of these chamchas
纯属胡扯,我们出口高是靠石油制品,这些吹捧越南的人只会说空话。
surajitray
LOL , only solution is 100% reservation in private and public sector , we are not doing it fast enough
哈哈,唯一解决办法就是公私单位全部岗位预留名额,我们推进速度太慢了。
Vidhita Pande
Srilanka and Philippines too. They moved to upper middle income country. And here we are struggling with what not.
斯里兰卡、菲律宾都迈入中高收入国家行列,只有我们各种难题缠身。
StudyAgora
With the current education system and corruption we are going nowhere
现行教育体系加上遍地贪腐,国家发展毫无出路。
Rafi
If it wasn't for @albd1971
and their kleptocracy over the past 2 decades. Bangladesh would've replaced Vietnam. It's a shame and misfortune for our tiny yet big nation to be surrounded by a jealous, toxc neighbour. They will remain in the gutter while not letting us out either.
过去二十年孟加拉当局贪腐横行,不然孟加拉出口早就赶超越南。我们国家体量不小,却被心胸狭隘、充满敌意的邻国包围,对方自己发展停滞,还处处打压我们。
Harshal_Dhanawade
Post GST & Demonitisation MSMEs have collapsed. All currently are just white labeling from China No manufacturing. Heck even made in India coming printed from China.
实施商品服务税、废钞令之后,中小微制造业彻底垮台。现在市面上全是贴牌中国货,本土没有完整生产线,就连印着印度制造的标签,都是中国生产。
可以申请信息公开,查2017年后新增进口商数量和注册地址就清楚了。
gaurav018
piyush G like: ma xchudaye india ka share world export bass mera cut time pe aajane ko hona
皮尤什·戈亚尔心里只惦记自己的利益,根本不在乎印度全球出口份额。
Rohit Kumar
We are World No. 1 in Gobar Exports! No one can beat it!
我们牛粪出口全球第一,没人能超越!
Rag
That's because China is using Vietnam as a proxy, saar.
先生,这都是中国借越南当跳板出口商品。
Ashok S
Vietnam is Mostly a coastal nation unless massive hinterland of India plus uniform people .
越南国土多沿海,印度拥有广阔内陆,国民人口基数更大。
X_Kela11
So new Show in the evening From Godi anchors benifits of lower exports than small countries
御用媒体晚间新闻又要开始洗地,解释我们出口不如小国的各种理由。
SarkariParasite
Bangladesh ahead in per capita income & Vietnam ahead in exports.
How much more glory Bishwaguru gotta shine in Amritkaal
孟加拉人均收入超过我们,越南出口规模赶超我们,所谓世界导师,独立周年纪念年还有什么高光可言?
Manwa Be Parwah
Because majority of Chinese companies have manufacturing and export hub in Vietnam, this is to avoid tarriff... Wake up
大量中国企业把生产、出口中心设在越南,只为规避关税,大家清醒一点。
Sharad
This is only merchandise exports, we should compare both merchandise and services exports
对比只算了实体商品出口,应当把商品、服务出口合并统计再比较。
rightinthemiddle
This is wrong data to defame viswaguru. If you take into account how many slaves we export , Vietnam won’t even come close
拿片面数据抹黑我们这个世界导师,要是算上输出海外的务工人员,越南根本比不上。
NormalPerson
Yet the bootlickers will say we are emerging economies
还是会有一群吹捧者,坚称我们是高速发展新兴经济体。
iamSra
Why have the gujjus send baniyas, marwaris of India failed in this field
擅长经商的古吉拉特、马尔瓦里商人,怎么在出口赛道落了下风。
Jhakaas Jungli
Take some vietnam minister and compare with Gadbadkari wealth. That's aapke to apple comparison.
拿越南官员和国内贪腐政客的资产对比,这才是对等比较。
Arjun
We are busy in more important things like cows, gobbar, temples etc..
我们忙着更重要的事:养牛、收集牛粪、修建寺庙。
Omnimon
It's kind of easy when your exports are mainly chinese companies evading tariffs by exporting through you.
越南出口好看很正常,大半都是中国企业借道避关税的货物。
声明: 三泰虎 原创译文,此文由三泰虎网编辑,禁止转载,否则追求法律责任!
