印度中型战机AMCA和中国歼20，谁更强，印网民热议

India AMCA Chinese J-20 Mighty Dragon

印度的先进中型战机 vs 中国的歼-20

The Chengdu J-20 is a single-seat, multi-role stealth fighter that serves as a symbol of China’s growing air power as the plane has been featured prominently in military parades and air shows across the country.

歼-20是一款单座多用途隐形战斗机，是中国日益增长的空军力量的象征，在全国各地的军事阅兵和空中表演中，它一直占据重要位置。

Last year, the J-20 reportedly entered mass production after replacing the Russian AL-31F Turbofan engine with a domestically built WS-10. According to Chinese plans, the current WS-10C engine is further to be replaced by the latest and more advanced WS-15.

据报道，去年歼-20在用国产WS-10取代俄罗斯的AL-31F涡扇发动机后进入量产。根据中国的计划，目前的WS-10C发动机将进一步被最新和更先进的WS-15取代。

Chinese jets have traditionally been powered by Russian-made engines. China has long sought to develop its own engine and gain maxmum flexbility, freeing itself from the constraints imposed by Russian engines. The successful integration of WS-15 on J-20s could be the next big breakthrough in self-sufficiency for China.

中国喷气式飞机传统上使用俄罗斯制造的发动机。长期以来，中国一直寻求自主研发发动机，获得最大的灵活性，摆脱俄罗斯发动机施加的限制。歼-20成功集成WS-15可能是中国在自给自足方面的下一个重大突破。

China’s next-generation turbofan engine, the WS-15, which is to dramatically boost the performance of the J-20 stealth fighter jet, has completed rigorous testing.

中国下一代涡扇发动机WS-15已经完成了严格的测试，该发动机将显著提高歼-20隐形战斗机的性能。

According to reports, the Indian Air Force has committed to 40 AMCA Mk-1 fighters, as well as at least 100 Mk-2 variants and some unmanned aircraft. Like the Chinese J-20, the stealthy AMCA is also going to have ‘super cruise’ capabilities.

据报道，印度空军已经承诺购买40架AMCA（先进中型战机） Mk-1战斗机，以及至少100架Mk-2和一些无人机。与中国的歼-20一样，隐形AMCA也将拥有“超级巡航”能力。

With AMCA, India will enter the exclusive club of countries with fifth-generation stealth planes. So far, the US (F-35 and F-22 Raptors), Russia (Su-57), and China (J-20) have built such fighters.

有了AMCA，印度将加入拥有第五代隐形战机的国家俱乐部。到目前为止，美国(F-35和F-22猛禽)、俄罗斯(苏-57)和中国(歼-20)都是该级别的战斗机。

According to Aeronautical Development Agency chief Girish Deodhare, the AMCA will be available in stealth and non-stealth variants and will be produced in two stages: an AMCA MK1 with an exsting GE414 afterburning turbofan engine that powers the LCA Tejas, and an AMCA Mk2 with a new, more powerful engine that will be developed in collaboration with a foreign player.

据航空发展局局长Girish Deodhare称，AMCA将分为隐形和非隐形两种型号，分两个阶段生产：AMCA MK1搭载现有的GE414加力涡扇发动机，LCA光辉战机也是用这款发动机；AMCA Mk2搭载新的、更强大的发动机，将与一家外国公司合作开发。

以下是Youtube上网民的评论：

JAY TRIVEDI

We need to boost our Airforce drastically...... We are using so old aircrafts .....we need to finish up AMCA, Tejas mk2 as soon as possible and make at least 100-200 off them before 2030 to be in the game ... Otherwise no matter how talented out pilots are we will be short handed due to lack of equipments....

我们空军的实力需要大力提升

我们使用的飞机太旧了，应该尽快完成AMCA和光辉mk2的研制，并在2030年之前至少生产100-200架光辉mk2。否则，无论多么有天赋的飞行员，我们都将因缺乏装备而落后挨打....

pinkman-gaming

Finger crosss hope hal don't disappoint us

祈祷印度斯坦航空公司不会让我们失望

Tufail Hanji 06

Sorry to say but when we will have Develope AMCA completely China may have developed 6th generation fighter at that time They have also tested their hypersonic fighter jet

很遗憾地说，我们的AMCA研发出来后，中国可能已经开发出第六代战机了，

他们的高超音速战斗机完成测试了

Pradeep saral

China has Air superiority due to 450 J10 and X number of J20.

India has only one fighter(Raffael) which can counter J10 a 4.5 generation plane.

But we have only 36 Raffaels.Can this meager number counter 450 J10?

中国拥有450架歼10，很多架歼20，具有空中优势。

印度只有一款阵风战机可以对抗4.5代的歼-10，我们只有36架“阵风”，打得过450架歼10吗?

Sudhendu Gupte

AMCA's first 5.5 gen fighter first prototype thanks.

AMCA是5.5代战斗机的第一个原型机。

the Great Guy

Indian jets rank No. 1 in the whole world love from JP!

印度战机在全世界排名第一!

kiran sethy

Japan, southkorea, sweden has there own program for 5th generation fighter..why are you saying india will be the 4th such countries

日本、韩国、瑞典都有自己的第五代战斗机项目，为什么说印度会成为第四个拥有自主研发第五代战机的国家呢？

Zakiul Rifat

Also Turkey

还有土耳其呢

Royal Yadav

Amca

Jai hind

AMCA印度必胜！

Half Hermit

Jab tak hamara AMCA production ready hoga, China would have inducted 400 J-20 in its airforce. We urgently need to procure 114 Rafale M4 under MRFA. Pata nahi Modi jee kya so rahe hai... they are just slightly better than UPA but no where close to expectation.

等AMCA生产就绪，中国空军中已经服役400架歼-20了。我们急需采购114架阵风-M4战机。莫迪他们只是略好于国大党，但与我们的预期相差甚远。

Mani Kumar

Amca will be better than f 35

AMCA会比F-35更好

You Expert

Modi govt have to fund more for AMCA

莫迪政府必须为AMCA提供更多资金

You Expert

india will made AMCA which will time to time upgrade upto 5.5 gen

印度将制造AMCA，到时候会升级到5.5代

You Expert

are bhai sach bataye to 100% stealth kuch nhi hota

All are detectable to some extent

F-22 can also be detectable through high tech radars

战机能100%隐形吗？在某种程度上都是可以检测到的

通过高科技雷达也能探测到F-22

Rishab Jain

We don't reverse engineer like China. We made on our research and hard work

我们不像中国那样进行逆向工程，我们付出了努力，进行了研究

Shock trap

F 22 raptor is past

j 20 , su 57 , F 35 is present and

Amca is future

F-22猛禽是过去式了，歼-20, 苏- 57, F-35是现在式，未来是AMCA的天下

arjun

Does canard wings reduce stealthiness?

鸭翼会降低隐身性？

zahid shah

No recently USA awacs can't detect j20 in South China Sea even f35 fail to detect it

最近美国的预警机在南中国海侦测不到歼-20，F-35也侦测不到歼20

mohan rajawat

How can a fifth generation fighter have close canard wings

第五代战机怎么可能是近距鸭翼？

GAMING WITH SIMAR

AMCA will be 5.5+ gen fighter with 6th gen capabilities

AMCA将是具有第6代战机性能的5.5代战斗机

Humpy Dumpy

@GAMING WITH SIMAR Nice joke. Where is engine for 5.5 + generation AMCA? Which country will provide 150+ kn thrust vectorial engine to India? India started designing of AMCA since 2009. It took 12 years in designing and will take another 25 years in development.

笑话。5.5代AMCA的引擎在哪里？哪个国家会向印度提供150+ kn推力的矢量发动机？印度从2009年开始设计AMCA，花了12年设计，将再花25年研发。

Humpy Dumpy

China is develo more advance variable cycle engine for 6 th generation fighter. India has no engine for it's AMCA.

中国正在为第6代战机开发更先进的可变循环发动机。印度没有匹配AMCA的发动机。

gaming lover

J20 is not stealth

歼-20不是隐形战机

Rambhakt Vegeta

But More stealth than SU 57

但比苏- 57更隐形

joydeb biswas

Chinese Air Defence System could not shoot down Brahmos in Pakistan. Just imagine the quality of Chinese weapons