Israel’s Arrow-3 vs China’s DF-41 — A Fact-Based Comparison

以色列“箭-3”与中国东风-41的对比

Arrow-3 is Israel’s high-altitude interceptor designed to neutralize ballistic threats, while DF-41 is China’s long-range intercontinental ballistic missile equipped with multiple nuclear warheads.

“箭-3”是以色列的高空拦截弹，旨在拦截弹道导弹威胁；而东风-41是中国的远程洲际弹道导弹，配备多枚核弹头。

以下是各国网友的评论：

IsraelMilitaryChannel
China's air defence has not been combat tested.

中国的防空系统还没经过实战检验。

MJTUEN
You can be the first to test it. LOL LOL LOL

那你可以当第一个去试试啊。哈哈

nnostrodoms
@MJTUEN You should ask the Iranians how many Tofu systems were destroyed, including Russian ones.

你该问问伊朗人，有多少“豆腐渣”防空系统被打烂了，包括俄罗斯的那些。

gabrieljoseph6310
@nnostrodoms 5 SAM 300 systems were destroyed by Israeli fighter jets

有5套S-300防空系统被以色列战机摧毁了。

wiiliskaako5875
Like arrow 3 is tested and failed miserably, to the point they had to get THAAD to fill the gap and still couldn't stop irans hypersonics. China hypersonic will always pass thru any srael defence system

就说“箭-3”吧，测试时败得一塌糊涂，逼得他们只能用萨德来补窟窿，结果还是拦不住伊朗的高超音速导弹。中国的高超音速武器，以色列的任何防御系统都拦不住。

IsraelMilitaryChannel
@wiiliskaako5875 Arrow 3 has 85-90% interception rate. It passed with flying colours, this is world-class. Besides THAAD, there is SPYDER, Barak MX, David's Sling. They are multi layer defence and has nothing to do with failure. China has never intercepted a single ballistic missile in real time combat in its entire exstence. I suggest you sit and be quiet until China finally shoots something real down.

“箭-3”的拦截率有85%到90%。测试成绩优异，是世界级水平。除了萨德，还有“Spyder”“巴拉克MX”“大卫投石索”。这些是多层防御系统，跟失败一点关系都没有。中国从来没在实战中拦截过任何弹道导弹。我劝你还是闭嘴等着，等中国真能打下点什么再说。

gabrieljoseph6310
@wiiliskaako5875 During the 12-Day War, an estimated 80 Arrow-3 interceptors were launched, and based on a 201-316 interception rate, a significant number of them were successful. THAAD system 150 intercepts.Arrow 2 intercepted 9 missiles only 36 hits in populated areas.

12天战争期间，估计发射了80枚“箭-3”拦截弹。按201-316的拦截率算，成功的数量不少。萨德系统拦截了150次。“箭-2”拦截了9枚导弹。最终只有36枚命中人口密集区。

preachingflamesthepreacher3894
@nnostrodoms you can as well ask Israel how hard Iran can hit and how miserable the "iron doomed" is when Iran is hitting.

你也可以问问以色列，伊朗的打击有多狠，还有伊朗攻击时，“铁穹”有多惨。

preachingflamesthepreacher3894
@IsraelMilitaryChannel I'm sure that the 85 - 90% rate was against the Hamas and Hezbollah. Iran has long since lowered that bar to 5 - 7%. This fact is by judging the reality on the ground.

我敢肯定，那85%到90%的拦截率是针对哈马斯和真 主党的。面对伊朗，这比例早就降到5%到7%了。这是看实际情况得出的事实。

IsraelMilitaryChannel
@preachingflamesthepreacher3894 Iran launched 462 ballistic missiles, and only 43 impacted. Calculation: Total missiles fired: 462 Missiles that got through: 43 Missiles intercepted: 462 - 43 = 419 Interception rate: (Missiles intercepted / Total missiles fired) * 100% = (419 / 462) * 100% = 90.6%

伊朗发射了462枚弹道导弹，只有43枚命中。计算一下：发射总数462枚，突破拦截的43枚，拦截成功的462减43等于419枚。拦截率就是（419除以462）乘以100%，等于90.6%。

prastagus3
@gabrieljoseph6310 how many hypersonics were intercepted?

拦截了多少枚高超音速导弹？

gabrieljoseph6310
@prastagus3 Only 38 missiles hit Israel, do you know how many hypersonic missiles were launched? Do you know that Iran has hypersonic missiles? Just like Iran has a stealth fighter jet Qaher 313.Many Iranian missiles disintegrated in the air or fell in Jordan and Saudi Arabia .Damage caused by Iranian missiles 32 dead, 3,508 injured Destruction of dozens of buildings, damage to military bases and institutions including a public hospital

只有38枚导弹击中以色列。你知道发射了多少枚高超音速导弹吗？你知道伊朗有高超音速导弹吗？就像伊朗有“征服者313”隐形战机一样不靠谱。很多伊朗导弹在空中就解体了，要么落在约旦和沙特。伊朗导弹造成32人死亡，3508人受伤，数十栋建筑被毁，包括一座公立医院在内的军事基地和机构都受了损。

adinoyiadinoyi9604
@IsraelMilitaryChannel Good to know that the US worships, France, US airbases in Iraq, Jordan, Turkey, UK worships, Arrow 3, iron dome, David sling still can intercept the Iran missiles and Drone.

很高兴看到，美国、法国（还有在伊拉克、约旦、土耳其的美军基地）、英国，以及“箭-3”“铁穹”“大卫投石索”，都能拦截伊朗的导弹和无人机。

IsraelMilitaryChannel
@adinoyiadinoyi9604 Israel has intercepted more projectiles than the US, UK, France and Jordan combined in their entire lifetime. Hardly any difference whether they help or not. They need help from Israel's expertise on air defence.

以色列拦截的弹药数量，比美国、英国、法国和约旦加起来一辈子拦截的都多。他们帮不帮忙，差别不大。他们还需要以色列的防空技术经验呢。

IsraelMilitaryChannel
@adinoyiadinoyi9604 Israel has intercepted more projectiles than the US, UK, France and Jordan combined in their entire exstence. They are learning from Israel.

以色列拦截的弹药数量，比美国、英国、法国和约旦加起来一辈子拦截的都多。他们都在向以色列学习呢。

IsraelMilitaryChannel
@adinoyiadinoyi9604 Turkey has never shot down a single ballistic missile in its entire exstence in real time combat. We laugh at Turkey's air defence capability.

土耳其从来就没在实战中击落过任何一枚弹道导弹。我们都嘲笑土耳其的防空能力。

nnostrodoms
As a senior employee at Elbit Systems, the Chinese have no understanding of what we build. TOFU's systems have no chance.

作为埃尔比特系统公司的资深员工，我可以说中国人根本不懂我们造的东西。那些“豆腐渣”系统毫无胜算。

MJTUEN
The Secretary of War already talked to the Chinese counterpart that US does not want to seek conflict with a so-called "tofu" system. How low can your boss stoop? Get real. LOL LOL LOL

美国国防部长已经跟中国方面谈过了，说美国不想跟所谓的“豆腐渣”系统发生冲突。你们老板的底线能有多低？清醒点吧。哈哈哈

Kastady
@MJTUEN we the spectators have seen what Israel defense system can do. china defense systems are not combat tested

我们这些旁观者都见识过以色列防御系统的实力。中国的防御系统可没经过实战检验。

gabrieljoseph6310
@MJTUEN What are you smoking? Probably something very strong.

你抽什么了？估计是劲儿特别大的东西吧。

johnlewis314
If your system cannot handle Iran missiles you think a country with so much money and power as China making crap, you are stupid. I’m delusional and narcissistic.

要是你们的系统连伊朗导弹都对付不了，却觉得中国这样有钱有实力的国家只会造破烂，那你真是蠢。我看你是又妄想又自恋。

precipice65
@Kastady if israeli defence is so good then why need help from the west and neighbouring countries?

要是以色列的防御系统真那么厉害，为什么还需要西方和邻国帮忙？

anondonakrek5267
China defense system is baby toys for Israel.

中国的防御系统对以色列来说，就是小孩玩具。

endermankiller8567
@ebrimafaye1773 first its destroyed. And also the only place i see truly destroyed is gaza

首先，导弹确实被拦截了。而且我看到唯一真正被摧毁的地方是加沙。

ebrimafaye1773
@endermankiller8567 STOP THE GENOCIDE THE WORLD IS WATCHING ISREAL BRUTAL GENOCIDE

停止种族灭绝！全世界都在看着以色列的残酷种族灭绝！

ashlonfernandes5008
@ebrimafaye1773 i know they are soo bad at committing a genocide

我知道，他们搞种族灭绝的本事也太差劲了

gabrieljoseph6310
You are confusing Arrow Speed 2 with Arrow Speed 3 Range 2400 km Altitude over 150 km speed classified Arrow 3 intercepted 86% of the missiles launched by Iran and 100% of the Houthi missiles launched, compared to the Chinese system that did not intercept the Macro Comet.The Arrow 3 system has the ability to intercept satellites

你把“箭-2”和“箭-3”搞混了。“箭-3”射程2400公里，射高超过150公里，速度保密。“箭-3”拦截了86%的伊朗发射导弹，以及100%的胡塞武装发射导弹。而中国的系统连“宏彗星”导弹都没拦截过。“箭-3”系统还有拦截卫星的能力。

PeterSese-g3b
We will proven it in the real combat.

我们会在实战中证明这一点。

FredrickOchieng-f2y
Arrow 3 kills dongfeng,before re-entry face

“箭-3”能在东风导弹再入大气层前就把它摧毁。

gabrieljoseph6310
What about the Chinese surveillance radar in Iraq that Israeli fighter jets neutralized before neutralizing Iranian anti-aircraft systems?

那以色列战机在摧毁伊朗防空系统之前，先摧毁了伊拉克的中国警戒雷达，这事怎么说？

ESENECHRISTIAN
u should hav compare it with jerrico 1 of isreal

你们本该拿它和以色列的“杰里科-1”导弹比的。

prastagus3
China has DF61 now

中国现在有东风-61了。

mathiuduanggonmei4428
Arrow is much better than chinese missile

“箭”式导弹比中国导弹好多了。

wiiliskaako5875
Irans fatah 1 and 2 made easy work on those srael arrow 3 interceptors .df41 is not even for srael but to be used against thier dad US . So dont compare global power with bby killers

伊朗的“法塔赫-1”和“法塔赫-2”对付以色列的“箭-3”拦截弹简直轻而易举。东风-41根本不是针对以色列的，而是用来对付他们“爹”美国的。所以别拿全球大国和屠杀婴儿的凶手比。

mauricecohen3830
Easy work? over 90% were intercepted. Nothing is 100%. While the IAF has complete air surpemacy over Iran.

轻而易举？90%以上的导弹都被拦截了。没有什么是100%的。而且以色列空军在伊朗上空拥有完全的制空权。

dahlak3739
China air defence not tested so how can compare with israel succesfull arrow

中国的防空系统都没经过检验，怎么能和以色列成功的“箭”式系统比？

GAVINEREVINO-z9n
Chinese products are of Quantity but very counterfeat and can't last long.

中国产品就是数量多，但全是仿冒货，还不耐用。

nguliongkwong688
Beyong argument, of course Israel missles is far better than China rubbish missles

毋庸置疑，以色列的导弹肯定比中国的破烂导弹好得多。

mauricecohen3830
Why compare an offensive missile with an anti-missile system. The Jericho 3 and soon 4 would be a better comparison to DF-41. China has nothing like Israel's missile defense systems. Furthermore Israels has be proven in combat.

为什么要拿进攻性导弹和反导系统比？“杰里科-3”以及即将问世的“杰里科-4”，才更适合和东风-41比。中国根本没有能和以色列反导系统相比的东西。而且以色列的系统已经经过实战验证了。

ejbaenasibaenasi3325
China was good in entertainment..proves in chinese product including foods etc.. chinese df 41 wasn't in real combat.

中国也就娱乐方面还行。从中国产品，包括食品之类的就能看出来，中国的东风-41可没经过实战。

jayc2886
DF41 (ICBM) carries 10 unclear war heads with speed Mach 20-25 and any real combat tested, it means a whole tiny Israel will be destroyed.

东风-41洲际弹道导弹携带10枚核弹头，速度达20-25马赫。哪怕它没经过实战检验，要摧毁以色列这么个小国也绰绰有余。

lebzhau1401
Israel must donate Arrow 3 to Ukraine

以色列必须向乌克兰捐赠“箭-3”系统。

winstonseecharan6321
China will fully depend on mask production they know fully well there weapons is no match to israel however they probably has 20 times more in a war this could decide a chinse victory

中国会完全依赖口罩生产，他们很清楚自己的武器比不上以色列。但如果开战，中国的武器数量可能是以色列的20倍，这或许能让中国获胜。

llewesallin
China armaments and army no experience in combat how ever the israelis are well combat tested and army are elite in urban and warfare.missile are combat tested and precise

中国的武器和军队都没实战经验，但以色列人经过了充分的实战检验，其军队在城市作战中堪称精英。以色列的导弹也经过实战验证，精度很高。

ebrimafaye1773
STOP LAYING USA AND ISREAL MISSILE NOT ONLY ISREAL THEY HELP BY USA STOP THIS NONSENCE LAIE

别再吹嘘美国和以色列的导弹了！以色列不是靠自己，是有美国帮忙！别再胡说八道、撒谎了！

223322user
Comparison should be between similar weapons. Arrow 3 it is an anti-missile system. So, we are waiting for a fact -base comparison with HQ-19

对比就该在同类武器之间进行。“箭-3”是反导系统，所以我们期待看到它和红旗-19的基于事实的对比。

adinoyiadinoyi9604
Arrow 3 is only efficient against flying pipes from Gaza. The World saw how porous Israel is against Iran. If Arrow 3 was that efficient, why would they request for the Patriots systems from US.

“箭-3”只对加沙那些“飞行铁管”有效。全世界都看到了，以色列在伊朗面前的防御漏洞有多大多。要是“箭-3”真那么管用，他们为什么还要向美国求购“爱国者”系统？

eorgeng9252
THE PROVEN REAL TOY MISSILES ARE ACTUALLY THOSE FROM THE ISRAEL/USA AS THEY CAN'T EVEN DEFEND YEMEN/ IRANIAN DRONES WHAT MORE MISSILES. IF IRAN CONTINUE TO STRIKE BEYOND THE 12 DAYS IN THE RECENT WAR, ISRAEL WILL BE ERASED COMPLETELY!

事实证明，真正的玩具导弹其实是以色列和美国的。它们连也门和伊朗的无人机都防不住，更别说导弹了。要是伊朗在最近那场12天的战争后继续打击，以色列会被彻底消灭！

继续阅读：导弹   以色列   东风41

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 资讯 » 以色列“箭-3”与中国东风-41的对比