Chinese Parents Are Paying to Send Their Kids to 'Hardship Camps'. Here's why| The Palki Sharma Show

帕尔基：中国家长花钱送孩子参加“吃苦夏令营”，背后原因揭秘

What do you do when your child complains about homework, chores or screen time? In China, some parents are taking a rather extreme approach - sending their children to “hardship camps” where they dig potatoes, feed pigs, peel bark and sometimes give up their phones. The idea is to teach gratitude and resilience. But there’s a catch: does a child need to suffer to learn how to handle hardship? Palki Sharma tells you more on the show.

当孩子抱怨作业、家务，或是总想着玩手机时，你会怎么做？在中国，部分家长选择了一种相当极端的方式——把孩子送去“吃苦夏令营”。

在夏令营里，孩子们挖土豆、喂猪、剥树皮，有时还要交出手机。举办这类营地的初衷，是教会孩子懂得感恩、磨炼抗挫能力。

但问题随之而来：孩子真的要靠吃苦，才能学会直面困境吗？

今年暑假，“吃苦夏令营”悄然走红。记者调查发现，四川、云南、贵州等地都有类似营地。一些家长花费上万元，将孩子送往偏远农村，在封闭管理下砍柴、喂猪、挖土豆，甚至靠“工分”换取物资，累到哭闹也不能停止。机构声称此举能矫正孩子沉迷手机、不懂感恩等陋习，甚至有家长采用“先骗后送”的方式。如何看待“吃苦夏令营”？如何培养孩子吃苦耐劳的品格

以下是印度网友的评论：

PuneetChhikara
This is the way. Many adult kids roaming around without growing up fully. Hardships makes strength possible.

就得这么办。现在不少人已经成年，心智却还没成熟。历经磨难，才能练就强大的内心。

 

charmaine8512
Come to Oz! The elders are like teenagers! Gamers, having babies and caring a hoot.

来澳大利亚瞧瞧，这边的长辈活得跟年轻人一样！打游戏、生儿育女，凡事都看得很开。

 

emeukut7194
Do you see or hear the elite class send their children to such a school?

你见过上层社会的人会把自家孩子送去这类营地吗？

 

Yakshapan
Please highlight the Chinese ai issue. I mean Chinese ai dubbed anime and short drama spreading over internet and you tube. they are dubbing these in hindi and are spreading culture of mistrust among fellow Indian and reducing viewer share of main stream you tubers . Then there is the issue of Chinese bot firms spreading anti India content in the internet . which is meticulously planned to get children addicted thus degrading mental health.

希望讲讲中国AI相关的问题。网上和油管上到处是中国AI配音的动漫和短剧。这些内容配成印地语，在印度民众之间散播猜忌，挤压本土主流油管博主的流量。还有中国水军机构在网络散布反印内容，精心设计套路让印度孩子沉迷，损害他们的心理健康。

 

SathwikBheemavarapu‑f8k3m
Modern problems need ancient solutions

现代社会的难题，要用老办法来解决。

 

ashwinnema06
My parents also used to teach me that we face hardships in life. I promised myself when I was in 9th class I will never raise children and will never get married. It has been around 14 years since and I still think.the same

我父母以前也总跟我说人生要吃苦。我上九年级的时候就暗下决心，以后绝不结婚生子。一晃14年过去，我还是坚持这个想法。

 

the_1999_kid
No wonder their kids are the smartest and the bravest

难怪他们中国的孩子既聪慧又勇敢。

 

Poltik
India has a ancient problem of parents pampering their child ,and overlooking the faults of their own and their child

印度长期存在一个问题：家长溺爱孩子，对自己和孩子身上的问题视而不见。

 

aparnagandhi8044
Excellent! Our kids and some parents too need this training!

太棒了！我们印度的孩子，还有部分印度家长，都需要这种历练！

 

dtmt502
Indian middle class kids needs this they are out of shape and soft

印度中产家庭的孩子很需要这个锻炼，现在的印度孩子身体素质差，吃不了苦啊。

 

superphi
It’s a great idea, some kids need this

这个想法很不错，一部分印度孩子确实需要这样的锻炼。

 

nar5718
Most need it

大多数印度孩子都需要这样的锻炼。

 

alexeilesukov6624
My Daddy used to say: Hard work, pain, and suffering will make a man out of any boy.

我父亲以前常说：辛劳、挫折与磨难，能把男孩历练成真正的男子汉。

 

ghg27689fg
I do not blame the parents. Some of these children are really spoilt and need to experience tough lives. Good job Chinese parents.

我不怪这些中国家长。有些孩子实在被宠坏了，该体验下艰苦的生活。中国家长做得好。

 

varshachandrashekar7057
Correct way of raising the children... Hardships make kids stronger and that is what helps them further.

这才是正确的育儿方式。磨难会让孩子变得强大，对他们往后的人生大有裨益。

 

RajTravelogues
Very much needed in India.. will have healthy kids

印度太需要这种夏令营了，能培养出身心健康的孩子。

 

sumitpal‑e
Yss that's why chinese kids has good skill set in every field

没错，所以中国孩子在各个领域都本领过硬。

 

Satyam_Shivam_Sundaram‑l2u
More than skill.... Hard working habit which is very important.... So physical stress is important for growing kids.

不止是本领，吃苦耐劳的习惯才最为关键。成长中的孩子，很有必要适当经受身体上的磨砺。

 

TellaTrix
this is good example set by China. we should appreciate there decision .

中国做出了很好的示范，我们应当认可他们对孩子的培养做法

 

sandipanaich
Kudos to China to make a genuine attempt to break a dangerous loop.
Hard times make Tough men.
Tough men make Easy times.
Easy times make Soft men.
Soft men make Hard times.
If we want to break this loop, simulate Hardship during Easy times. I think this is a good idea and Indian parents should seriously consider this.

为中国点赞，真心想要打破危险的循环。

乱世出硬汉。

硬汉造盛世。

盛世养懦夫。

懦夫生乱世。

想要打破这个轮回，就要在安逸的时代主动体验苦难。我觉得中国家长的这个主意很好，印度家长该认真考虑。

 

jola8663
Kids in China today have it way too good — they take everything for granted and think all kids around the world live like them. We really need to help them appreciate what they have and understand that you can’t just have things without working for them.

现在中国的孩子生活条件太优越，把一切当成理所当然，以为全世界的孩子都过着和他们一样的美好日子。很有必要教会他们珍惜拥有的一切，一分耕耘一分收获！

 

extemporebypriyanka7616
Much much needed in every country

每个国家都非常需要这种中国式的教育。

 

obertng2398
That's how to instil discipline in these kids. They will grow up mentally stronger.. This is how they will win the future.

这就是给孩子建立规矩的方式。他们心智会变得更强大，凭这样才能赢得未来。

 

4‑SeasonNature
It's called discipline.
That's what the military does to new recruits who are barely adults.

这就叫磨炼意志。军队对待刚成年新兵用的就是这套办法。

 

antoniochoa7131
Indian media n some politicians should send to the country side to learn hardship so that they can learned how to behave not lazy talkative !

印度媒体人和部分政客该送去乡下体会艰苦生活，学会好好做人，别只会空谈偷懒。

 

chrislee5685
How many parent facing child that throw chair and destroy thing when confiscating their phone wish they got such camp in their places.

不少家长没收手机，孩子就摔椅子砸东西，多少家长都希望我们印度也有这种吃苦的夏令营。

 

handwerp
It's a brave for Palki Show to show this story; while what these kids went through in a summer camp, is called LIFE for the Indian children of lower caste

帕尔基节目敢于报道这件事很有勇气。中国这些孩子夏令营体验的苦，却是印度低种姓孩子的日常。

 

neha9773
Meanwhile our parents just vote for the party and make all our generations suffer.

反观我们印度这边，父母只顾投票给政党，害得一代代人跟着受苦。

 

keirenle
You need to know poverty to respect wealth. It s a good thing that you earn that experience early.

体会过贫穷，才懂得敬畏财富。早早拥有这份经历是件好事。

 

harrychu650
Sending people to the commune to reconnect with nature is a old tradition in China

把人送去亲近大自然，是中国由来已久的传统。

 

ApexPredator‑AP
Come india we have indore training academy

来印度吧，我们有印多尔训练营。

 

dashong8912
Many adults need to be sent to such camps too.

很多成年人也该送去这类营地。

 

ingmo2210
In real society, no one will spoil your child.

步入真实社会，没人会惯着你的孩子。

 

joedoe7140
Lol I like this sending my kids now

哈哈，我挺认同，真想现在就把自家孩子送过去。

 

swatichats6629
I think we should also send some Adults for such Camps.

我觉得部分成年人也该参加这类营地。

 

donkeykong516
China pays for hardship training, while India just has hardships due poverty

中国花钱主动吃苦受训，印度的苦难却是与生俱来的贫穷带来的。

 

fread4945
This is the best.. now adays kids.. for a game they kill themselves.. if we say something strongly, they kill themselves.. its crazy..
These kind of camps are a necessity. Atleast it will help their future

这个办法再好不过。现在的孩子，会因为游戏轻生，大人语气重一点也会走极端，实在离谱。这类夏令营必不可少，至少能对他们的成长有所帮助。

 

cooper1819
Its experiential learning, learning through direct, hands‑on experience followed by critical reflection. Instead of passively listening to a lecture. That's how to build very strong next generations in very comfortable life.

这属于体验式教育，亲身动手实践，再加以反思，而不是被动听大道理。身处安逸时代，就要靠这种方式培养强大的下一代。

 

ouravKumar‑d3f
In India we call it Gurukul , children uptil the age 25 should stay there, where everything is taught

在印度我们叫古鲁库尔古学堂，孩子最好待到25岁，在那里学习各类知识。