印度专家“一针见血”谈中印经济体量和教育投入：印度是4万亿经济体，教育投入仅120亿美元，中国是20万亿经济体，教育投入8000亿美元，完全没有可比性

India is a $4T economy. China is $20T.

India spends $12B on education, China spends $800B.

There's simply no comparison.
Powerful insight by Vijay Kedia ji.

印度是4万亿美元经济体，中国是20万亿美元。

印度教育投入120亿美元，中国是8000亿美元。

两者根本没有可比性。

维贾伊·凯迪亚先生的这番见解一针见血。

以下是印度网友的评论：

Vivek
India needs to build world class universities.

印度得建世界级的大学。

Balu Gorade
True. Our spending on education is minimal. In fact we spend more on elections and freebies.

没错。我们的教育投入少得可怜，事实上花在选举和免费福利上的钱都比这多。

Madhu
Where to get fools like you guys.

哪来的你们这帮蠢货。

cErsqkgOHpp57fL
Are you from whatsapp university ?

你是从瓦茨普谣言大学来的吧？

Amit Deshpande
Schools sir, world class schools at affordable prices.

先生，先建学校吧，建人人都上得起的世界级中小学。

Investors Cafe
May be next time when God might create the world again. Our schools' , universities are design to suck parents' hard-earned money and deliver skilled labor, nothing else.

怕是得等上帝重新造世界才有可能。我们的中小学、大学，说白了就是榨干父母的血汗钱，只教出技术工人而已，别的什么也不是。

Investdunia
Govt is inviting foreign universities to open campuses in India. Let's see if that fills the requirement or not.

政府正在邀请外国大学来印度建分校，看看这能不能满足需求吧。

md rafeek
Hamesha University hospital pe pade rehte yaar log.
Employment to bad nahi rahi kyaa karte padai karke. Hum statues banayenge berozgar ko rozi milegei 2-3 k crores ka business hoga Haan agar paise bache to hospital bhi banayenge

大伙总想着建大学、建医院。

读书出来就业形势不是一直不好吗？我们去建雕像吧，给失业的人找口饭吃，这能做成上千亿的生意。对了，要是还有钱剩，再建点医院就行。

VendettaInvest
Who will own the real estate and the universities? You miss the incentives and exsting sweet position that doesn't need any change due to large population + mindset of spending on useless education / degrees

这些地皮和大学最后归谁？你根本没看到背后的利益点，还有当下的既得利益格局——人口多，大家又愿意为没用的教育、文凭花钱，这格局根本没必要变。

The Great Gupta
Yeah and put reservations there...right?

行啊，那大学里也搞预留配额是吧？

Kumar Dhanapal
Sanghis who are preaching that gomothra cures cancer, wont create world class institutions.

那些鼓吹牛尿能治癌症的印度教激进分子，根本建不出世界级的学府。

J Singh
No schools

连学校都建不好。

Rajiv Sharma
World class universities are coming to India to build those

世界级的大学自己会来印度建的。

Zeus
India needs to build a lot of things. Unfortunately our leaders keep gloating about being the fastest growing economy. China grew in double digits for a whole decade. Thats the comparison our leaders need to do

印度该建的东西多了去了。可我们的领导人总沾沾自喜，说自己是增长最快的经济体。中国可是整整十年都保持两位数增长，这才是领导人该拿来对比的。

TPasuparthy
we did build world class institutions... over time they have been run down to non entities

我们其实建过世界级的学府，只是慢慢被糟蹋得名存实亡了。

Taurean
No need for Universities when -40 marks is cutoff for PG NEET. Those who learnt nothing in MBBS, don't need infra for studying MD

考研医考及格线都是负40分了，要大学有什么用？本科医学生什么都没学到，读硕士要再好的硬件设施也白搭。

Gyanu Kislay
First they will build temples and statues on every corner, then distribute money after that they will build some mid university by spending peanuts

他们先在各个角落建寺庙、立雕像，再发点福利钱，最后才花点小钱建几所不入流的大学。

Moviegasm
First choose an educated leader. Not some chaiwala chu

先选个有文化的领导人吧，别选那个卖茶的蠢货。

nse bse mani
India: $4T economy, $12B education (0.3% GDP)
China: $20T economy, $800B education (4% GDP)
We spend more on elections than educating next generation. They spend 4% GDP on human capital.
Then we celebrate “jugaad” and wonder why we can’t manufacture semiconductors.
Education deficit = economic ceiling.

印度：4万亿经济体，教育投入120亿美元，占GDP0.3%

中国：20万亿经济体，教育投入8000亿美元，占GDP4%

我们花在选举上的钱，比培养下一代的教育投入还多。他们把4%的GDP花在人力资本上。

我们还沾沾自喜于那些“凑活的办法”，却纳闷为什么造不出半导体。

教育的短板，就是经济的天花板。

Balu Gorade
We seriously need some changes.

我们真的得做出改变了。

KDXB2000
Chinese are high IQ. While almost Half of India is technically classified as retarded in the US (IQ lower than 75).

中国人智商高，而在美国的标准里，印度几乎一半的人都算弱智，智商低于75。

Madhu
First understand the foundational issues. Have you done any manufacturing? Don't blabber nonsense here

先搞懂根本问题再说。你搞过制造业吗？别在这胡说八道。

karna_indian
Bro it's dumb.
India Centre+State expenditure on Education is $ 184 Billion which is 4.6% of GDP.
China invests 4% of its GDP on education which is $890 Billion.
Central Govt. invests $18 Billion on education.

兄弟，这数据太扯了。

印度中央加各邦的教育投入是1840亿美元，占GDP4.6%。

中国教育投入占GDP4%，折合8900亿美元。

印度中央政府的教育投入才180亿美元。

Lens
Easier said than done. We visit these numbers like our Blood Sucking Companies Quarterly Results. But brain drain & intellectual bankruptcy in those analysts who keep silent despite these devastating numbers, what best can be expected when many uneducated rule us

说起来容易做起来难。我们看这些数据，就像看那些吸金公司的季度财报一样。人才在流失，那些分析师看着这些触目惊心的数据却一言不发，脑子都空了。一群没文化的人在掌权，还能指望有什么好结果。

Madhu
First learn d path all economies have grown. Don't compare apple with oranges

先去学学所有经济体的发展路径，别拿苹果和橘子瞎对比。

RK
Ya I didn't expect kevadia will not do this simple math

是啊，真没想到居然有人连这么简单的算数都不会。

Madhu
You brainless..even China doesn't have technology to manufacture semiconductors required in d current market.

你没脑子吧，中国现在也造不出市场需要的半导体技术。

vlai
India spends nearly $100b on education(federal+state combined). In gdp percentage its same as china.

印度教育投入快1000亿美元了，中央加各邦的总和。按GDP占比算，和中国一样。

Stock Surgeon
This puts the gap into sharp perspective. GDP numbers often dominate headlines, but long-term power is built through investment in human capital. A $4T economy spending $12B on education versus a $20T economy spending $800B explains a lot about productivity, innovation and execution capacity.
Vijay Kedia ji’s insight highlights a hard truth: growth without deep investment in education limits future potential. Nations don’t just compete on size, they compete on the quality and scale of what they invest in.

这组数据把差距说得明明白白。GDP数字总霸占头条，但国家的长期实力，是靠人力资本投资堆出来的。4万亿经济体投120亿教育，20万亿经济体投8000亿，这就解释了两国在生产力、创新力和执行力上的差距。

维贾伊·凯迪亚的见解点出了一个残酷的事实：不大力投资教育的增长，会限制未来的潜力。国家竞争，拼的不只是体量，更是投资的质量和规模。

Balu Gorade
This is why china is way ahead

这就是中国遥遥领先的原因。

Chit
Caste based reservation can only create third grade citizens with no merit.
China is decades ahead and will stay behind at least for the next 100 years

基于种姓的预留配额，只能培养出没本事的三流国民。

中国已经领先几十年了，印度至少未来100年都追不上。

Chit
EWS should stay and only for 1st generation. One parents get it none in family should get it. EWS reservation must be revised to tighten all loopholes.
All other caste & religion based reservations must be removed.

经济弱势群体的配额可以保留，但只能给第一代人。父母享受到了，家里其他人就不能再享。这项政策得修订，把所有漏洞都堵上。
其他所有基于种姓和宗教的配额，都该废除。

ArWaZ
For the development of countries, education is most important

国家要发展，教育是重中之重。

HealthyandWise
China and India are never a fair comparison . In India a politician cannot survive without spending on freebies , playing vote bank politics , ignore some corruption and by being silent on many issues just to maintain balance. China doesn't have any of these problems.

中印根本没有可比性。在印度，政客想活下去，就得发免费福利、玩票仓政治、纵容贪腐、对很多事视而不见，只为维持平衡。这些问题中国一个都没有。

Balu Gorade
we have serious problem

我们的问题真的很严重。

Nitin Sinha
Unless we bump up the spending on education and research exponentially, we have no chance to compete with China and the USA. Our education infrastructure is third world and we rely solely on expensive private institutions for quality education which is unaffordable for the masses.

除非把教育和科研投入呈指数级提高，否则我们根本没机会和中美竞争。我们的教育基础设施就是第三世界水平，优质教育全靠昂贵的私立机构，普通人根本上不起。

Nishant Kumar Rai
Our capitalists shell out more on political parties than on R&D. And that makes all the difference.

我们的资本家，花在政党身上的钱比研发还多，这就是关键差距。

paul chinnasamy
We Need To Spend More On R&D And Education! Our Education Institutions Need To Aquire Global Leadership!

我们得在研发和教育上多花钱！我们的教育机构要成为全球领军者！

Balu Gorade
yes, but we are spending on Freebies and elections

是啊，可我们的钱都花在免费福利和选举上了。

BULL OF ALL STREETS
India can only be compared with Pakistan, Bangladesh or African nations like Kenya.

印度也就配和巴基斯坦、孟加拉，还有肯尼亚这类非洲国家比。

harikaa04
India needs to spend atleast $200B at this given scale

以印度现在的体量，教育投入至少得2000亿美元。

Balu Gorade
hope they get this

希望他们能明白这一点。

Exposing Hypocrite
Chinese give fake data ..no body knows the real number

中国人的数据都是造假的，没人知道真实数字。

WebbedRanger
Looking at the technical research and advancements from their universities, they are clearly doing far better than what we are doing

看看中国大学的技术研究和成果，他们做得明显比我们好太多了。

SP
You can’t build deep tech, semiconductors, or AI at scale without massive investment in human capital.

不大力投资人力资本，就搞不成高端科技、半导体，也做不了规模化的人工智能。

Samar Singh
Vijay Kedia should just sing flippy songs. There is comparison, comparison comes from PPP equivalence becaue the expenditures this moron is talking about are domestic. So much for macroeconomic sense

维贾伊·凯迪亚还是去唱唱小曲吧。要比也得按购买力平价来比，这蠢货说的这些支出都是国内支出。一点宏观经济常识都没有。

Dr G
Ladli behen yojna is a kind of education

少女福利计划也算一种教育投入。

SibySibs
3.6 trillion.
about $5 billion is spent on R&D, some of which is gone to research cowdung, exstence of pushpak viman, curing of cancer by cow urine...etc etc...
China spends about $750 billion and US about $950 billion, to create breakthrough technologies and innovations, to better lives...

印度GDP也就3.6万亿。

研发投入大概50亿美元，其中一部分还拿去研究牛粪、传说中的飞天战车、牛尿治癌症这些东西。

中国研发投7500亿，美国投9500亿，都是为了搞突破性技术和创新，改善民生。

Aryan Singh
If you want a $20T economy, you fund minds like you mean it.

想成为20万亿的经济体，就得真心实意地投资人才。

cosmichaos
With increased IQ via education people can figure out ways to employ themselves with creative ideas and research but ye apni government ko batayega kon. That's why superpower countries give so much importance to education and IQ. Vidya bina kuch nahi. Laxmi ko agar stable rakhna hai toh Saraswati jo vidya ki devi hai aur ganeshji jo sabse hoshiyar mane jate hai. Unki energy ka hona jaruri hai. Aur wo energy sirf aur sirf high quality free education se hi create hogi. Otherwise we'll be a poor country forever.

教育能提高智商，人们就能靠创意和研究自己找工作，可谁去跟政府说这些呢？这就是超级大国都重视教育和智商的原因。没文化，一事无成。想守住财富，就得靠知识女神和智慧之神的加持。这种力量，只有靠优质的免费教育才能培养出来。不然，我们永远都是穷国。

hariniv2505
Wow, those numbers really put things into perspective! Education is so important for growth. Hope India steps up its game soon!

哇，这些数据太直观了！教育对发展太重要了，希望印度赶紧迎头赶上。

Random Update
He is correct , India is no where close to China in terms of education and development
People there know how to talk , walk and have driving sense unless our India where from top to bottom people are corrupt
We need to learn some civic sense

他说得对，印度的教育和发展，跟中国差远了。

中国人懂礼貌、有素养、开车守规矩，反观印度，从上到下全是贪官。

我们真该学学基本的公民素养。

LostSanity
But India spends so much money on Ladli Behna, Chulbuli Chachi and Natkhat Nanand. What does China do? Bolo bolo...

可印度花了大把钱在少女福利、邻家阿姨、调皮小姑这些福利计划上啊。中国又做了什么？倒是说说啊。

dr.ravi chowdary
Chinese accounting is special…trace its GDP BEFORE COVID ABD AFTER COVID… they just doubled….their GDP is definitely above 8-9 Trillion….

中国的会计核算很“特别”，看看新冠前后的GDP，直接翻倍了。他们的真实GDP肯定也就8到9万亿。

Sury
Indians are proud that India has more Monasteries. Religion has become a business in India. Fake religious gurus are everywhere

印度人还为寺庙多而骄傲，宗教在印度都成生意了，假的宗教大师遍地都是。

A k Satpute
This gap explains a lot. In India, too much money leaks into dirty politics and poor management instead of real nation-building. Education should be free and high-quality for every student who genuinely wants to learn and build skills for the future.
Without fixng this, we’ll keep falling behind. When you compare outcomes across technology, manufacturing, and research, it’s clear why China is ahead. Talent exsts here, but the system isn’t built to let it win.

这差距说明了一切。在印度，本该用来建设国家的钱，太多都流进了肮脏的政治和低效的管理里。教育应该免费且优质，给每一个真心想学、想练就未来技能的学生。
不解决这个问题，我们只会一直落后。对比两国的科技、制造和研究成果，就知道中国为什么领先了。印度有人才，只是制度没给人才发光的机会。

Leviathan Rai
Mr. Kedia has included the budgets of every tier of government in China but has included only the Union Government’s budget for India. If we also include state government budgets, the total comes to about 4.1% of our GDP, which is comparable to China

凯迪亚先生把中国各级政府的预算都算上了，却只算了印度中央政府的。如果把各邦的也加上，我们的教育投入占GDP约4.1%，和中国差不多。

Gautam Agarwal
Amount of money India spends on education and medical half of it is lost in corruption
Today #Delhi only has a budget of ₹40000 cr for education & health but the condition of schools,clinics & hospitals is below par
This is the condition of national capital.

印度花在教育和医疗上的钱，一半都被贪腐吞了。如今德里的教育和医疗预算只有4000亿卢比，可学校、诊所、医院的条件都差得离谱。这可是首都的现状啊。

Rigged Ayodhya EVM
There is no choice for now. India had been ignored for decades. It had to spend money building toilets and tap water, homes. Once these basics are done, it can move money into the next things

现在也没别的办法。印度被忽视了几十年，必须先花钱建厕所、装自来水、盖房子。这些基础民生搞定了，才能把钱投到其他领域。

Aagantuk
Education in India is not only a matter of government expenditure, it's also a matter of curriculum .........
Only when there is a single nationwide education board with a single curriculum, along with some state specific subjects , education will remain a divider in India..... The day curriculum is standardized, the astronomical fee at present care schools will crash.... more ordinary people will get opportunity for better jobs that are currently a monopoly of the ones educated from private schools

印度的教育问题，不只是政府投入的事，还有课程体系的问题。

除非全国统一教育委员会、统一课程，只加一点各邦的特色科目，否则教育永远是印度的分裂因素。课程一旦标准化，现在私立学校漫天要价的学费就会暴跌，更多普通人能得到好工作的机会——而这些工作现在都被私立学校毕业的人垄断了。

the anonymous
It means China spends 4% of their economy on education. If we follow their example we should spend 160 billion dollars on education which is 4% of 4T economy.

也就是说中国把4%的经济体量投给了教育。我们要是学他们，4万亿的经济体，教育投入就该有1600亿美元，也就是4%的GDP。

Pintoo Ganguly
All is fine but how much do they spend on statues as 20T USD economy we are so much ahead of them and we have more grand plans Chandrababu Naidu the great is planning a NTR statue and then Hanuman statues in so many places Kediasir is probably not aware of it, our achievements

说这些都没用，人家20万亿经济体，花多少钱建雕像？我们在这方面可比他们领先多了，还有更多宏伟计划。伟大的钱德拉巴布·奈杜要建NTR雕像，还要在好多地方建哈努曼雕像。凯迪亚先生怕是不知道我们这些成就吧。

Souvik Jana
Biggest problem is India don't have good infrastructure for Primary Education. On top of it, privatization of primary education has lower the quality of education in govt schools as the ministers and beaureaucrats don't need to send their children there. This needs to change

最大的问题是，印度的基础教育基础设施太差了。更何况基础教育私有化后，公立学校的教学质量越来越差，因为部长和官员根本不用送自己的孩子去那上学。这一点必须改。

Abhishek
With that ratio India should spend 125 billion something but all goes in the political people to fill their generational wallets.

按那个比例，印度的教育投入该有1250亿美元左右，可这些钱全进了政客的腰包，够他们几代人花了。

Parag Kothari
In India, reservations and freebies have created a culture of entitlements and privileges. We have devalued merit and performance. This has caused huge damage to society and will be difficult to rectify

在印度，预留配额和免费福利养出了一种理所当然的特权文化。我们不把能力和业绩当回事，这给社会造成了巨大伤害，而且很难纠正。

ephPrasad
First Indians should start valuing Teaching Profession. It's one of the most underestimated professions in India. First start rewarding teachers for their acumen , then India will surely start to fly.

印度人首先得重视教师这个职业，它在印度被低估得太厉害了。先奖励那些有能力的老师，印度才能真正腾飞。

Teja
China also encourage students to pursue stem degrees.

中国还鼓励学生攻读理工医科类学位。

Name
Education is on the concurrent list. Center + State spending on education is $120billion, still way behind China, but not as small as indicated

教育是中央和各邦的共同管辖事务，中央加各邦的教育投入有1200亿美元，虽然还是远落后于中国，但也没像数据显示的那么少。