为什么印度无法成为中国或美国那样的超级大国

Why India can NEVER be a SUPERPOWER | Abhi and Niyu

为什么印度永远成不了超级大国

why India cannot be a superpower like China or America. Despite India being an economic bright spot and the 4th largest economy in the world - India faces a lot of challenges.

为什么印度无法成为中国或美国那样的超级大国？尽管印度是全球经济的亮点，也是世界第四大经济体，但它面临着诸多挑战

以下是印度网友的评论：

smg_369
That's kind of topic every indian should talk about

这哥话题每个印度人都该坐下来好好聊聊。

sunshine-ms6wk
We have quantity but not quality we are made by currupted system, how can we develop even if we have huge young population but for sarkari curruption system. We don't have discipline parents or children they are busy in increasing population in bihari to make their child a labour.

我们只有数量，没有质量，这都是腐败体制造成的。就算有庞大的年轻人口，可印度政府系统这么腐败，怎么发展得起来？家长和孩子都没规矩，比哈尔人一门心思多生孩子，结果就是让孩子去当劳工。

akpatel3585
1% i want to see india as a superpower

哪怕只进步1%也好，我想看到印度成为超级大国。

Kimchi_
Only one way it’s possible , when other countries stop being superpower . Coz we aren’t moving upwards others are moving down. As an Indian I don’t feel like a 4th economy , I feel like Japan isn’t doing better that’s why it fell and we overcame them.

只有一种可能，就是其他国家不再当超级大国。我们自己没在往上走，只能等别人往下掉。作为印度人，我完全没觉得我们是第四大经济体，倒像是日本没以前好了、掉下去了，我们才超过它的。

AdarshYadav-g8c5z
Superpower in gobar technology

当“牛粪技术”领域的超级大国还差不多。

Maverickraze
Nope we don't need to superpower we just need to be a developed country where atleast PPL have money to eat food and spend

不，我们不需要成为超级大国，只需要成为发达国家，至少让人们有钱吃饭、有钱消费就行。

sangbritkundu8222
The truth is, that time British ruled India because Indians betrayed each other. Even now, politics is corrupt, systems are broken, and so many other problem in between people shout “proud of India” . The harsh truth: India is poor, failing, and that’s why people run to other countries.

事实上，当年英国人能统治印度，就是因为印度人互相背叛。就算现在，政治腐败、体制崩坏，还有一堆其他问题，可人们还在喊“为印度骄傲”。残酷的真相是：印度很穷，正在衰败，所以人们才跑到其他国家去。

MrBank-hc1jg
India is not poor anymore and isn't failing. It's you who is failing at personal level and projecting on entire india. Compare where were we before 2014 and today. Miles ahead.

印度不再穷了，也没有衰败。是你自己过得不如意，才以为全国人民都和你一样。看看2014年以前和现在，我们已经进步太多了。

SrutiSam
India is not POOR.. India is a middle income country.. We are moving ahead.

印度不穷，我们是中等收入国家，我们正在前进。

BhanuPartapSingh-be4mc
@SrutiSam In a recent survey,100crore out of 140crore can't spend on needy items, that's how India is moving ahead

最近一项调查显示，14亿人里有10亿人买不起必需品，这就是印度所谓的“正在前进”。

rohansharma
Dude I’m trying to start by own business I have all documentation and everything I’m not getting a license because I’m not ready to pay money to a specific government employee so god bless this country

兄弟，我想自己创业，手续什么的都齐了，可就是拿不到许可证，就因为我不愿意给某个政府职员塞钱。愿上帝保佑这个国家吧。

Lalit_Raikwar
this is the most annoying in starting a buisness

创业时遇到这样的事情，最让人烦。

shyamunadkat
What type of business are you starting?

你想做什么类型的生意？

Mk-zp9yy
We have a manufacturing unit in Pune. Plastic injection mold manufacturing and Plastic part production. Last month we faced major electricity crisis due to transformer was unable to handle the load and it blew. MSEB took 8 days to fix issue and that lead to line loss , man power cost paid out of our pocket , unhappy customers. Every time we complained we only received one answer we are doing whatever is possible from our side. Not a single responsible person that is answerable to our complains. But we cannot delay electricity bill by single day or else electricity will be cut same day.
About infrastructure every morning I leave at 9 and the road condition worsens everyday stuck in traffic early morning for more than 45 min and after spending hours at factory while we leave for home again stuck in traffic but this time for 1.5-2 hours. This is very frustrating and makes us think what are we even doing.
I’m waiting for a day some other nation approaches us and offers us to start a business in their country I would be more than happy to be there instead of being in India.

我们在浦那有个生产厂，做塑料注塑模具和塑料零件。上个月遇到大停电，因为变压器负荷不够烧了。马哈拉施特拉邦电力局花了8天才修好，导致我们生产线停工、白付人工费，客户也不满意。每次投诉，他们都只说“我们在尽力了”，没有一个人出来负责。可我们电费晚交一天都不行，当天就会断电。

说到基础设施，我每天早上9点出门，路况一天比一天差，早高峰堵45分钟以上；在工厂忙一天后回家，又得堵1.5到2小时。这太让人沮丧了，都不知道自己这么干到底图什么。
我就等着哪天有其他国家来邀请我们去创业，我肯定乐意去，再也不想待在印度了。

kevinmarolia5067
Scary fact , when EU sanctioned Indian energy company (Nayara Energy) that lost access to Microsoft 365 services including Cloud storage/computing, Emails and Office documents all of a sudden to which Microsoft restored access after court intervention...Imagine if we lose access to email or internet services for an arbitrary reason should US/China decide to hurt India and cripple our digtal infrastructure. We need indigenous research and development of defense and intellectual property be it tangible or intangible like Soft power. We lag in information warfare and lack civic sense. We do not even respect our culture and most importantly middle class is struggling who is responsible for prop up the economy.

可怕的是，欧盟制裁印度能源公司（纳亚拉能源）时，该公司突然无法使用微软365服务，包括云存储、云计算、邮件和办公文档，后来法院介入微软才恢复服务。试想一下，如果美国或中国随便找个理由断了我们的邮件或网络服务，想打击印度、瘫痪我们的数字基础设施，那怎么办？我们需要自主研发国防和知识产权，不管是有形的还是无形的软实力。我们在信息战方面落后，还缺乏公民意识。我们甚至不尊重自己的文化，最重要的是，支撑经济的印度中产阶级过得很艰难。

nileshbhujbal7489
I have 12 years of IT experience as full stack developer and architecture. I can make a social media site and apps with my engineering friends. But not sure who will use it. How can I take my app to all people of india. Will our Indians shift to other social media.?
I don't have answer for these questions

我有12年IT经验，是全栈开发和架构师。我和工程师朋友能做社交媒体网站和应用，可不知道谁会用。怎么才能让印度全国人民都用我的 app？印度人会转用其他社交媒体吗？这些问题我都没有答案。

felix7yt97
It's a very challenging part to shift all Indian social media users from exsting to new one. To make it happen our government has to ban all social media apps made by foreign countries just like china ,so that they can shift towards alternative options.
And also quality matters,we have seen previously a game launched named FAU-G ,but no one played not hit in the market like other games like BGMI , because it lacks that quality..

要让所有印度社交媒体用户从现有平台转到新平台，这太难了。要实现这一点，政府得像中国那样禁掉所有外国社交媒体 app，这样大家才会用自己国产的社交媒体，而且质量很重要，之前有个叫 FAU-G 的游戏上线，没人玩，不像 BGMI 那样火，就是因为质量不行。

proteanguy3411
I would say everything is because of corruption and the bad side of system .
I am engineer if I want I can create Indian's own Social media but there are hidden loopholes by government that stops, because they will never let you grow. Because of the same reason is didn't start my own business . Feel like going out of India is my first priority now. Cause india me na Insaan ki keemat hai na Jaan ki or na struggle ki .

我觉得一切都是因为腐败和体制的弊端。我是工程师，想做的话能做出印度自己的社交媒体，可政府有各种暗箱操作阻挠，他们根本不想让你发展。就因为这个，我没创业。现在我只想离开印度，这是头等大事。因为在印度，人的价值、生命和努力都一文不值。

souradeep_pal
India needs proper infrastructure building. Not for social media PR.
Need to increase the R&D budget a lot.

印度需要完善基础设施建设，不是搞社交媒体公关。研发预算得大幅增加。

LaughingWithMBP24
Indian Corruption is main reason for all.. And this is dark truth

印度的腐败是所有问题的根源，这是残酷的真相。

Badlywoke
We just don't need a social media ecosystem we need to build entire digital ecosystem from scratch. Indians can make their own ecosystem within one year if government stand strong with Indian startups which are coming from villages aur any cities.

我们需要从零开始构建整个数字生态系统。如果政府坚定支持乡村或城市的印度初创企业，印度人一年内就能做出自己的生态系统。

hlkumar6766
जापान में तो भारत जितने भी नेचुरल रिसोर्सेस नहीं है फिर भी जापान बहुत ही विकसित और समृद्ध देश है ऐसा क्यों है इसके बारे में वीडियो बनाए ताकि हम लोग भी कुछ सीख सके

日本的自然资源远不如印度，可日本依然是高度发达和富裕的国家。

baaaalkama
For every occupation from clerk to high rank officer, Exams are needed. Only to enter politics, no qualification or exams are needed. And POLITICIANS are making laws in India by passing Bills in Parliament. THIS IS THE MOST DISGUSTING THINGS IN INDIA

从职员到高级官员，每个职业都需要考试。只有进入政界，不需要任何资格或考试。可就是这些政客在议会通过法案、制定法律。这是印度最恶心的事。

prakashjain4503
Our 100% e commerce,80% fintech,90% electronics, 100% social media, 100% cloud services, and most of the software industry is dominated by american and chinese companies. We dont make our own jet engines,semiconductors,ai,advanced medical devices,machinery,ships,batteries, video games, search engines,devices, operating systems, aircrafts. We fully rely on china for our all pharma ingridients,electronic components, rare earths, speciality chemicals. Every major economy is self dependent in most of the above things. The main problem is that both our govt and private sector ignore r&d spending, consumers dont support local companies like southkoreans japanese citizens, our education system is based on rote learning and theoretical knowledge and doesnt teach innovation and entrepreneurship

我们100%的电子商务、80%的金融科技、90%的电子产品、100%的社交媒体、100%的云服务，还有大部分软件产业，都被中美企业主导。我们没有自己的喷气发动机、半导体、人工智能、高端医疗设备、机械、船舶、电池、视频游戏、搜索引擎、设备、操作系统和飞机。我们的制药原料、电子元件、稀土、特种化学品全靠中国。其他主要经济体在这些领域大多能自给自足。主要问题是，印度政府和私营部门都忽视研发投入，印度消费者不像韩国人、日本人那样支持本土企业，我们的教育体系以死记硬背和理论知识为主，不倡导创新和创业。

Alive_Enternal
1 percent!
Bharat maatha ki jai!

We need to spread this awareness to every corner of india

哪怕1%也好！印度母亲必胜！我们要把这种意识传播到印度的每个角落。

instructorbgmigaming3844
It is because people leaving India and Work for other countries

这是因为人才都离开印度，去其他国家工作了。

Kingof21stcentury
Why can’t govt start making ev battery in India ? I am youth I have time, energy and passion to do something for the country, but where is government supporting? I don’t have any platform where I can get support from government. Government can design small plants and sell to entrepreneurs where they can continue and grow business.
Many people don’t have capital and they don’t want to take risk of taking loan, but government can make such small setups and handover to youth with minimum control over the units.
Only they are busy collecting taxes

政府为什么不在印度生产电动汽车得电池？我是年轻人，有时间、有精力、有热情为国家做事，可政府怎么不支持？我找不到能获得政府支持的平台。政府可以设计小型工厂，卖给企业家，让他们经营发展。很多人没资金，也不想冒险贷款，可政府可以建这样的小型设施，交给年轻人，少干预运营。可他们只忙着收税。

TheXzhostdGarage
Bro what about Rare earth materials found in China?? Whole world is dependent on China for EV batteries.

兄弟，中国掌控着稀土资源？全世界的电动汽车电池都依赖中国啊。

dddave0
Mother India, make me more capable to make better India

印度母亲，让我更有能力建设更美好的印度吧。

Namit-b9n
We should focus on seaweed biofuel for oil problem. it forms closed carbon cycle. net zero carbon emitted. Also, we have a very long coastline which can make production of oil possible

我们应该关注海藻生物燃料，解决石油问题。它形成封闭碳循环，净碳排放为零。而且我们有很长的海岸线，能实现石油生产。

sbmore21
100% true .This is reality of India.India must take action on priority on action shared in this video.Thanks Abhi & Niyu for such Nationalist retrospection

100%正确。这就是印度的现实。印度必须优先采取措施。感谢阿比和尼尤的这种爱国反思。

costructivecritic-o3c
Again, you are aiming for the moon when you cannot even reach the next city. It is very wrong to directly push for autonomy in software and hardware like China when the basics such as roads, infrastructure, drainage, cleanliness, schools, hospitals, and universities are still lacking.
Many developed countries rely on U.S. software, yet they are not suffering from corruption, pothole-ridden roads, overflowing drains, or poor public services. You are asking people to dream big when we still struggle to build proper toilets in many parts of India.
First, ask the government to reduce corruption, improve infrastructure, build better roads, schools, universities, and hospitals. Only after achieving these fundamentals should we aim for autonomy in software, hardware, and advanced technologies.
Why not ask the current ruling government to take strict action against corruption if you truly have the courage? Don’t jump directly to blaming bureaucracy—remember, it is the elected rulers who must be held accountable for ensuring development and stop the flow of black money.

再说一次，你连下一个城市都到不了，却想着登月。在道路、基础设施、排水、卫生、学校、医院、大学这些基础都还缺少的时候，就想学中国搞软硬件自主，这大错特错。很多发达国家也依赖美国软件，但他们没有腐败、没有坑坑洼洼的道路、没有污水横流的排水沟，公共服务也不差。在印度很多地方连像样的厕所都建不起来的时候，你却号召人们做远大的梦。

首先该要求印度政府减少腐败、改善基础设施、修路、建学校、大学和医院。只有打好这些基础，才能追求软硬件和先进技术的自主。

如果真有勇气，为什么不要求印度政府严厉打击腐败？别直接就怪官僚机构——记住，确保发展、阻止黑钱流动，责任在民选的统治者身上。