在西方国家,为什么印度人总觉得自己是外人
Why Indians Feel Like Outsiders in Western Countries | UPSC GS1 (Society) | StudyIQ IAS
在西方国家,为什么印度人总觉得自己是外人
Why do millions of Indians living in the USA, UK, Canada and Australia still feel like outsiders, even after years of work, citizenship and success?
数百万定居在美国、英国、加拿大、澳大利亚的印度人,即便工作多年、拿到国籍、事业有成,为什么依旧觉得自己是外人?

海外印度人感到孤立,到底是外界不接纳他们,还是他们自己筑起了围墙,海外印度人在居住国感到孤立,并非单一原因造成,而是外部社会环境排斥与内部文化壁垒双向叠加的结果。
印度拥有全球规模最大的海外侨民群体,大约 3430 万印度裔生活在境外。他们收入高、侨汇贡献突出,2024-2025 年向印度汇入超 1350 亿美元,创下纪录;美国的印度裔家庭收入中位数远高于其他亚裔,不少印度裔身居跨国企业高管、欧美国家高层职位,纸面来看是非常成功的移民群体。

但光鲜背后,印度人在西方国家遭受歧视与孤立的问题十分突出。从奥克兰街头到硅谷写字楼,不少国家对印度移民的抵触越来越明显,这究竟只是外来者与本地人之间的利益摩擦,还是另有更深的根源? 调研显示近半数在美印度裔曾遭遇歧视,大部分印度裔的伴侣同样是印度裔;社交媒体上反印度内容热度暴涨,澳大利亚爆发针对印度移民的反移民游行,爱尔兰还发生过印度人遭暴力袭击的事件,使馆因此发布安全提醒。
美国发布的一份报告显示,2025年有48%的南亚裔成年人表示自己曾遭遇仇视行为。
以下是印度网友的评论:
rinzzzz
Living under racism too , good luck to Indians abroad.
还要在西方国家承受种族歧视,祝身在海外的印度人好运。
frzamigo
Living in Belgium I'm having the best time of my life. I joined a gym, learnt French, joined a local social club, Belgian friends and am working towards a cause. Opportunities are endless
我现在住在比利时,日子过得很舒心。办了健身卡、学法语、加入本地社交社团,认识了比利时朋友,还有自己想要坚持做的事,机会太多了
christianoronaldo2189
You are delusional one day reality will hit you in the face
你太理想化了,早晚现实会狠狠给你泼冷水。
niloxxx007
good, hope you never return
挺好,希望你永远别回来。
manuprasad3939
As an Indian living in Germany..I totally agree with this analysis !!
我是定居德国的印度人,这个分析我完全认同!
imran4006
Because you are an outsider only
道理很简单,你本来就是外来者。
kingarther_camealot
Because we are not united.
因为我们印度人不够团结。
UnlimitedFun-of7gd
Yes, we need to united to learn and teach basic civic sense
没错,我们要团结起来,一起学习、提供自己的公共素养。
atheist-my8vw
Civic sense ki bhi bahot badi problem hai indians me.
印度人的公共素养非常差。
menofhistory2748
Lack of civic sense is the main reason.
在西方国家,感到自己是外来人,核心原因是印度人缺乏公共素养
madhvendra2164
It's not civic sense it's racism and jealousy.
不是公共素养的问题,根源是西方民众的种族歧视和嫉妒。
ZJS12
@madhvendra2164 lol we should stop playing the victim card and learn to improve our civic sense and behavioral attitude
哈哈,别总拿受害者身份说事,我们该好好提升公共素养,规范自身言行。
MrTooEasy-i6n
Absolute nonsense
One person is uncivilized doesn't mean everyone is just like him
纯属胡扯。一个人没素质,不代表所有人都这样。
DocRanaUK
And that is everything!
这一句话就说到点子上了!
rathoremihirsinh5806
Jaise india main bihar valo ki other state main jo value hain vaisi hi india valo ki foreign main hain
就好比在印度,比哈尔人在别的邦受到的偏见,印度人在国外也是一样的处境。
Agniputrau5
To hamare desh ke log bhi dudh ke dhule hue nhi hai
我们国家的人也不是全都完美无瑕。
ShivKumar-im3pm
Even I feel outsider in my home, office everywhere. Nothing New in it
就连我,在家、在公司,到处都有局外人的感觉,这不算什么新鲜事。
Davo-l7s
I feel like outsider & lone being an Indian in India itself
身为印度人,就算待在本国,我也常常觉得格格不入、孤单无助。
HomeStay-w5m
Obviously because other country leaders are starting this and ours dous not say anything substancial.
很明显,是别国政客在煽动这种情绪,而我们这边的领导人拿不出有力表态。
AbhishekRaj-cq5yf
people from delhi feel outsider in Bengaluru... you are saying about abroad.. this is basic human rule..
we are social animal.. without social.. we are nothing..
德里人到班加罗尔都会有外来感,何况去国外?这是人的常态。人是社会性动物,脱离社交,就没有归属感。
DJVlogsHindi
As an indian in france, i totally aree with it
我是在法国生活的印度人,我完全同意这个观点。
docuking669
You should also note one other thing. The status of women. The patriarchal attitudes of some Indians is out of step with most of the world with the exception of Middle East.
还有一点不能忽略:女性地位。一部分印度人根深蒂固的大男子思想,除了中东地区,和世界大部分地区都格格不入。
Maakalkaji
Then look upto western patriarchy
那西方就没有大男子主义吗。
Agniputrau5
Abhi Indian log jabse videsh me tyoharon ko bade paimane me manane lg gye hai tabse videshi logo ke nazar me jyada aa gye hai
自从印度人开始在国外大肆庆祝本土节日之后,就更容易被外国人注意到。
deepti2117
Hmmm might be lekin hum yaha unake tyohar bhi dhum dham se manate hai
或许是吧,但我们在这边也会热热闹闹庆祝他们的节日。
khyati1229
There are opportunities to make friends from all over the world but then you have to make efforts like joining a club. Sometimes its a lot of work
有机会结交世界各地的朋友,但需要主动付出,比如参加社团。有时候要花不少心思。
8919-x8s
NE indians feel like outsiders in their own country
印度东北部的人,在自己国家都像外人。
MrTooEasy-i6n
Absolute nonsense
一派胡言。
redblue17
I think it's a good thing. Tbh.
You should see what a west teen does in his day to day life.
说实话,我觉得这种感觉未必是坏事。你可以看看西方年轻人平时都是怎么生活的。
debd1234-x7z
As a unian living in France for more than 10 years. It's 100 percent true
我在法国生活十多年了,这话一点不假。
UKpowerunleashed
Indians who wanna make India better feel the same even in India. Big deal.
一心想让印度变好的人,就算留在国内也会有这种疏离感,没什么稀奇。
gb-freethinker
A country's name becomes a brand through the reputation of its people, institutions, and products.
一个国家的口碑,靠国民、机构和产品一点点建立起来。
rishabhnair9599
I am living in Ireland, and I have been more socially active than I would have been back home. I teach guitar as a Volunteer, work part-time with many locals, and connect with others for hobbies like sketching and knitting (not very manly, I'm aware). You get rejected by some, you get accepted by some, and you find some who eventually see you as no different from themselves. They teach you their ways and their point of view, and are open to learn the same from you.
我住在爱尔兰,社交比在国内活跃得多。我志愿教吉他,和很多本地人一起做兼职,还因为素描、编织这些爱好结识朋友(我知道编织不算很男性化的爱好)。有人排斥你,有人接纳你,也有人慢慢把你当成自己人。他们会跟你分享当地的习惯和想法,也愿意了解我们的文化。
JhilmilBasu
Ireland is the most friendly country in the west. Come to germany and ul nt last a week
爱尔兰是西方最友善的国家。你去德国试试,可能一周都熬不住。
Prevail-R-07
Casteism and lack of civic sense is the problem
问题出在种姓思想和公共素养缺失。
SJ-x3ug
They can return to viswaguru and have their company of people.
他们大可以回到“世界导师”印度,和同胞待在一起。
AmanDas-b1c
Lack of our Civic sense, racism
一方面是我们自身公共素养不足,另一方面是种族歧视。
tauruspices
ur vry right indians are calm quite submissive people, they just hesitate to be social like westerners in other countries,,,they have to bring openess in them
你说得很对。印度人性格温和内敛,在国外不像西方人那样擅长社交,需要学着放开自己。
unplannedlife-z1i
I had amazing experience in New Orleans and California hope never to face this.
我在新奥尔良和加州的经历都很好,希望永远不会遇到这种排挤。
brascoperryjoe6425
New Orleans is great place.
新奥尔良是个好地方。
saiprakash5145
The one & only reason is one-upmanship amongst our on people instead of reaching out to help one another!
唯一的原因:我们同胞之间总爱互相攀比较劲,而不是互帮互助!
Inquisitivo-l2k
This assumption is totally wrong. You need to to compare how Americans or Europeans feel about other ethnic groups. People even fear living next door to many other ethnic groups. However, like the Jews before, Indians are successful and some people resent their success. That doesn't mean they dislike you as people.
这个观点本身就不对。你看看欧美本地人对其他族群的态度,很多人甚至不愿意和别的族群做邻居。印度人像以前的犹太人一样,取得了不错的成就,引来一部分人的嫉妒,但这不代表他们讨厌你这个人。
KapilKumar-gg1ok
When society ( World ) senses your helplessness...it becomes predatory and sadistic and keeps bullying you for no reason...that is what happening here
当外界察觉到你软弱无助,就会变得充满恶意,无缘无故欺负你,现在的情况就是这样。
arjunjassal929
It was not as prevalent in past years as it has grown to be nowadays. This is especially true since videos, reels, and shorts depicting Indian street food and living conditions have gone viral on platforms like Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram. Because of such content, individuals who are largely anti-India have normalized the act of hating Indians.Furthermore, the primary issue lies with Indians themselves, who, when confronted with racism, often choose not to resist; instead, they simply smile and overlook such incidents. This behavior is interpreted by racists as an invitation to escalate their discriminatory actions. So many cases of racism and violence, but no one from India protests.
这种情况以前没这么严重,近些年越来越突出。推特、油管、脸书、Ins上大量关于印度街边小吃、生活环境的短视频传开之后,很多反印人士开始把仇视印度人当成常态。另外一部分问题在我们自己身上:很多印度人遭遇种族歧视时不会反抗,只是一笑而过。歧视者就会觉得可以变本加厉。这么多歧视和暴力事件,却很少有印度人站出来抗议。
2026good-u7i
Our politicians are not vocal against anything...if wrong things are happening still politicians keep mum...they want to keep trade relations irrespective of self respect of country and people...all they want is remittance and tax...what happens to people they are least bothered.
我们的政客从来不会强硬发声。就算不公的事发生,他们也保持沉默。为了维持贸易往来,可以不顾国家和国民的尊严,眼里只看重侨汇和税收,普通人的遭遇他们根本不在乎。
HappyPlumSorbet
I have friends and relatives in their 40s and 50s in Europe, every single one of them had a good time, became citizens fairly quickly in their early to mid-30s, did stunningly well in their careers and had good settled family life and mixed groups of Europeans and Indians as friends. And are still happy there.
So am not able to understand if Europeans have changed now or the people from India who are going have changed?!
我有不少四五十岁的亲友在欧洲,他们当年过得都很好,三十出头就顺利拿到国籍,事业顺利、家庭安稳,欧洲朋友和印度朋友都有,到现在过得很舒心。我搞不懂,是欧洲人变了,还是现在出国的印度人和以前不一样了?
peacekeeper9840
Why is the biggest diaspora not Chinese?
Oh, they have jobs and a better living standard.
Humare IIT karte hi flight, doctors udanchoo. Aur jo peeche reh gaye they will be proud that Indian diaspora is the largest.
为什么海外华人规模比不上印度侨民?因为中国人在自己国家就能找到工作、过上不错的日子。我们这边名牌大学印度理工学院(IIT)的毕业生、医生一毕业就想出国。留在国内的人,还会为印度拥有全球最大侨民群体而自豪。
romeofoodandtravel2023
Indian Hindus are very much respect in Britain.
There was a quote on indian Hindus in Britain " Hindus are smart, rich and well behaviour "
在英国,印度教徒很受尊重。当地有句话评价他们:印度教徒聪明、有钱、举止得体。
Hispeedtortoiz
India does not have much brand value globally. On top of it we are not the most healthy or good looking, the average health is far behind world average. So no one bothers much.
印度在全球的品牌影响力偏弱。另外国民平均健康水平也远低于世界均值,所以很难获得重视。
HS-cg7zg
NDN ka social circle sirf NDN tak simit rehta hai kyonki local log accept hi nahi krte hai. TV serials me NDNs ko majak banakr show kiya jata hai to usse NDNs ko neeche darje se dekha jata hai to usi tarah ka brtaw kiya jata hai, tab fir NDNs apasme hi rehte hain.
印度人的社交圈只局限在同胞之间,因为本地人不愿意接纳他们。电视剧里总拿印度人开玩笑,大家就带着偏见看待我们,久而久之,印度人就只和同胞来往。
声明: 三泰虎 原创译文,此文由三泰虎网编辑,禁止转载,否则追求法律责任!
