Why Nobel Laureate Economist Joseph Stiglitz Thinks India Should Worry About AI Taking Jobs

诺贝尔经济学奖得主约瑟夫·斯蒂格利茨为何认为,印度应当警惕人工智能抢饭碗

Nobel laureate economist Joseph Stiglitz recently spoke at the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit 2026 in New Delhi, warning that the artificial intelligence boom resembles a bubble that could disrupt India's services sector. He also outlined steps for India to sustain growth and addressed global fiscal and economic shifts.

诺贝尔经济学奖得主斯蒂格利茨(Joseph E. Stiglitz)近期在新德里举办的2026年《印度斯坦时报》领袖峰会上警告,人工智能背后的投资热潮是注定要破裂的泡沫,印度面临的风险高于大多数国家,因为这项技术最先冲击的,正是支撑印度服务出口繁荣的岗位。

斯蒂格利茨在新德里举办的2026年《印度斯坦时报》领袖峰会上表示,事实已经证明,AI最擅长处理的工作,刚好是印度海外服务贸易的根基:文字撰写和代码编写。

他直接对现场的印度听众说:“我很不愿意这么说,但我认为你们应该感到担忧。”他指出:“看看AI对美国劳动力造成的影响就知道,它擅长什么?擅长文字、擅长代码。AI非常容易替代程序员,这些就是它会抢走的工作。”

曾担任世界银行首席经济学家、克林顿政府经济顾问委员会主席的斯蒂格利茨说,这种产业依赖,让印度陷入一个棘手的战略困境。他提出疑问:“印度的服务出口奇迹,恰恰建立在这类特定岗位之上。所以问题在于,你们该如何转型?未来要往哪个方向发展?”

以下是各国网友的评论:

Johny-Walker
As non- Indian I always wondered why India fell so behind China (the average Chinese is 7x richer than the average Indian). The people are hard working, educated and connected to global businesses, the problem is a governance and management issue. India is probably the country with biggest unmet potential in the world this century. Its a mystery from the outside.

我不是印度人,一直想不通印度为什么和中国差距这么大(中国人均收入是印度的七倍)。印度民众勤劳、有文化,还深度对接全球生意,病根在治理和管理。印度或许是本世纪潜力最难以释放的国家。在外人眼里,这很让人费解。

 

bluebay0
A myriad of problems are the reason for India's failures... but a big part of China's rise is strict capital controls, something India does not have much of. India is sadly always willing to bend over backwards to please the global finance lords sitting in New York and London.

印度发展滞后,是一大堆问题叠加造成的。中国能崛起,很大程度靠严格的资本管制,而印度基本没有这类管控。很遗憾,印度总是一味讨好纽约、伦敦的金融大佬。

 

MarkDkar
it's the culture of obeying and not asking questions that are dragging india behind.. Society is sick due to castism, social approvals and giving less importance to individuals.

这种一味顺从、不提出质疑的文化拖累了印度。种姓制度、看重他人眼光、轻视个体价值,让整个社会积重难返。

 

avinashacademy019
sir no one will care about this practical and useful conversion about AI impact on India.

先生,没人会认真听这场关于人工智能对印度影响的讨论的。

 

vinaykumar-ld3yi
India is always worried about population decline. Only 33 crore population have full time job in India but Govt encourages population growth through freebies and 4 crore houses

印度总担心人口减少。印度只有3.3亿人拥有全职工作,可政府还靠各种福利、修建4000万套住房鼓励生育。

 

now2307
India already is a big mess. It is adding 23 million every year on top of 1500 million population. Politics is terrible. There is no control over corruption. Overall picture is gloomy.

印度现在已经一团糟。总人口15亿,每年还要新增2300万人。政坛乱象丛生,腐败管不住,整体前景一片灰暗。

 

partha1819
So as per you farmers and traders who form about 80% of population including their family is idling whereas so called salaried outside government is hardly 100+ years old thanks early factory who needs trained people to operate machine and Henry Ford. Please come out from disillusioned world.

按你的说法,占总人口八成、包含家属在内的农民和商人都算是无业?私营领薪水的工作模式,从早期工厂、亨利·福特时代算起,也就一百多年历史。别活在自己的幻想里了。

 

aham-mumukshu-asmi
4 crore houses are the rights of Indian citizens. Even the poor pay indirect taxes.

4000万套住房是印度公民应得的权益。就算穷人,也一直在缴纳间接税。

 

Dharmicaction
Well. India's strength is its population if you look at it as a market. Domestic consumption (75%) economy is the reason why India is able to sustain its growth despite exporting just 25%.

这么说吧。把人口当成市场来看,这就是印度的优势。印度经济七成靠内需,出口只占两成五,所以就算出口不多,也能稳住增长。

 

sparkextrugen7997
18 years ago Joseph stiglitz was a prominent economist today after seeing him I am surprised to see him get so old i have admired him a lot during my college days

18年前,约瑟夫·斯蒂格利茨是风头很盛的经济学家。今天再见到他,没想到他已经这么老了。我上学的时候非常敬佩他。

 

ash9x9
time spares no one.

岁月从不饶人。

 

jimwilson5202
China's economy it seemed to be growing and the use of an AI Hospital today it showed that money is not the main motivation.

中国经济一直在增长,现在还有人工智能医院

 

sharadrough
thanks for showing us the mirror. we do not stand anywhere unless we get rid of our fundamental problems--pollution, corruption, out of the box strategies, better governance, good policing, good healthcare, good education and last but not the least good and efficient judiciary. so basically full overhaul of the current system

谢谢你点醒我们。不解决根本问题,我们印度很难有起色:污染、腐败、创新思路、治理水平、治安、医疗、教育,还有高效的司法体系。说白了,整套体系都需要彻底改革。

 

basantabera1396
So so so so,jis desh k pass jamin nahi hai,samunder nahi hai, technology nahi hai bo desh ko sabse najdik bada desh ke sath merge ho jana chahiye

所以,一个没有土地、没有出海口、没有技术的国家,就该并入离它最近的大国。

 

mandip896
Not should be....we are worried

不是“应该担心”,我们本来就很担心。

 

jaychandran854
Thank you for sharing . We must take advice from the wise.

感谢分享。智者的建议,我们应当听取。

 

tomcheria8126
look how all of the so called experts will say there will be no jobs and need UBI or Tax AI companies but WILL NEVER SAY STOP IMMIGRATION. .SAD.

你看这些所谓专家,嘴上说岗位会消失、要全民基本收入、要向AI企业征税,却绝口不提限制移民。真让人无奈。

 

chotiaulim8677
Historically, some countries always lead But most have to be led....such as India.

纵观历史,总有少数国家领跑,大多数国家只能跟着走,印度就是这样。

 

Nanuneenu123
Now someone is talking sense.. !!!! even AI is impact major tech sector.. but other service sector's customer are tech people.. tech bring money from outside... Same thing for manufacture sector do for china.. to increase GDP, money should come from outside.. just internal consumption will not accelerator it.

终于有人说到点子上了!AI会冲击科技行业,而其他服务业的客户,很多就是科技从业者。科技行业从海外赚钱,就像制造业帮中国赚钱一样。想要拉高GDP,必须赚外面的钱,只靠内需拉动是不够的。

 

Dharmicaction
and there is no money "outside" (since America and Europe are bankrupt due to the accumulation of huge debt) and AI threat is just a smokescreen to distract from the impending currency reset or shall we say AI threat will be used to do the currency reset (fiat to digital currency)

海外已经没有多余的钱了,欧美债务高企,近乎破产。所谓AI带来就业危机,只是烟雾弹,用来转移大家对货币重置的注意力,甚至可以借着AI的名头,把法币换成数字货币。

 

aham-mumukshu-asmi
This is not failure of Govt but failure of Indian entreprenuers and big IT companies like Wipro, Infosys. Such a shame that these billion dollar companies have enough money to buy smaller countries, but still have not done 1% innovation and contributed to India?
its entrepreneurs like Sam Altman who help US soar high but Indian entrepreneurs stand in line to copy+paste. Shameless.

这不是政府的失败,而是印度企业家、维普罗、印孚瑟斯这类大型IT公司的失败。这些市值百亿的企业,钱多到能买下小国,却几乎没有原创创新,没给印度带来多少价值。
像萨姆·奥尔特曼这样的创业者推着美国往上走,印度的创业者却只会照搬抄袭,实在丢人。

 

makedredd299
The whole world needs to worry about AI taking jobs.

全世界都该警惕人工智能抢走工作岗位。

 

challenger13_31
I'm startled why people aren't realising yet that India being service based economy will take very hard hit from AI

我很意外,很多人还没意识到:印度是服务业为主的经济体,会被AI重创。

 

YourGuide-s2m8m
People are in denial as only few million people work in IT in a country of 1500 million. So average Indian thinks it's not his problem. What people are missing is the huge business these few million bring for housing, credit card, retail, taxs, etc. So say 10 million jobs lost to AI will mean 100 million jobs lost in other sectors once IT money starts evaporating.

大家不愿意承认。15亿人口里,只有几百万人在IT行业上班,普通人就觉得这事和自己无关。他们忽略了,这几百万人带动了住房、消费、零售、打车一大堆生意。如果AI挤掉一千万个IT岗位,IT行业的收入萎缩,连带其他行业会丢掉上亿个岗位。

 

nj0079
Why do you think avg american and chinese won't be affected by AI? It's a disruption for entire world, when you replace machine with machine, ever wondered who will consume your product, having the AI is not holy grain of success

凭什么觉得普通美国人、中国人不会受AI影响?这是全球性冲击。机器取代机器,你想过还有谁来消费商品吗?AI并不是成功的万能钥匙。

 

ScaryYokai
We are still 5 to 10 years away from that happening, although it is progressing towards that end, but nobody knows for sure how AI will or will not mature over the years

距离大规模失业还有5到10年。虽然趋势是往这个方向走,但没人能确定AI后续会怎么发展。

 

huntrz
Please don't lie. Modi ji has said "sab changa si" so everything is fine

别瞎说了。莫迪说了“一切安好”,那就说明什么事没有。

 

aham-mumukshu-asmi
Modi Govt including FM and other leaders already alerted about issues. This is failure of big IT companies like Wipro, Infosys. Such a shame that these billion dollar companies have enough money to buy smaller countries, but still have not done 1% innovation and contributed to India?
its entrepreneurs like Sam Altman who help US soar high but Indian entrepreneurs stand in line to copy+paste. Shameless.

莫迪政府,包括财政部长和其他高层,早就察觉到这个问题。责任在维普罗、印孚瑟斯这些大型IT企业。这些企业巨头的资金雄厚,却几乎没有创新,没为印度创造价值。
萨姆·奥尔特曼这类创业者助力美国腾飞,印度创业者却只会跟风抄袭,实在丢人。

ranjitkumargouda8970
@aham-mumukshu-asmi Why do you keep blaming the IT companies when you know that the govt. is the main problem. if someone wants to implement something the govt. has all of these non-sense rules and regulations which is drivinig all of the intelligent people outside india.

 明明知道根源在印度政府,你为什么一直怪IT公司?企业想落地新项目,政府一堆繁琐不合理的规定,逼得大量人才离开印度。

 

now2307
India already is a big mess. It is adding 23 million every year on top of 1500 million population. Politics is terrible. There is no control over corruption. Overall picture is gloomy.

印度现在已经一团糟。总人口15亿,每年还要新增2300万人。政坛乱象丛生,整体前景一片灰暗。

 

kiNhO-PoM
Superpower INDIA has nothing to worry about. Jai Hind.

超级大国印度无需担心。印度万岁。

 

GururajShivramakrishnan
This goes like this, so AI is mostly in India. You get the cheapest Labour so always the work goes to place where the cheapest work cheapest cost to work can happen. If a can be leverage by India. All the US companies will try to open offices in India to get their work done because they can pay less year than in US so India will create more jobs than US with AI and AI will go to new frontiers and all these frontiers. You will see in coming days like manufacturing or automobiles, all this parts will start be even including home appliances. You’ll see AI applications and it will be designed and developed by Indians

道理是这样的,AI相关业务很多放在印度。这里劳动力成本最低,业务自然流向成本洼地。如果印度用好这个优势,美国企业会来印度开设办公室,用工成本比他们国内低很多。依托AI,印度新增岗位会比美国更多,AI还会拓展到新领域。之后制造业、汽车零部件、家电行业,都会出现由印度人设计开发的AI应用。