三泰虎

为何印度车企马鲁蒂与马恒达采用比亚迪电池

Why Maruti & Mahindra Use BYD Batteries ?

马鲁蒂与马恒达为何采用比亚迪电池?

you will explore the strategic dependence of India’s automotive giants, revealing how the highly anticipated Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra’s electric fleet are powered by the silent dominance of Chinese battery technology.

印度汽车巨头的战略依赖现状,揭秘备受市场期待的马鲁蒂铃木与马恒达电动车阵容,背后实则由占据隐形主导地位的中国电池技术提供动力。

Maruti Suzuki’s first electric SUV E-Vitara and Mahindra’s premium electric SUVs like BE6 and XEV9 both rely on BYD battery cells and packs for their core power systems.

There are two mainstream lithium-ion battery chemistries for EVs: NMC and LFP. NMC batteries offer higher energy density but depend on costly, geopolitically unstable raw materials like cobalt and nickel, and carry high risks of thermal runaway and fire—especially unsafe in India’s extreme summer heat. In contrast, LFP (Lithium Iron Phosphate) batteries are cheaper, made from abundant raw materials, longer-lasting, more thermally stable, and far better suited to India’s climate and budget-friendly mass EV market.

China dominates the global LFP sector with a 98% market share, led by giants BYD and CATL, which together hold over half the global market. Decades of state subsidies, dedicated R&D, massive patent portfolios, full global supply chain control, and early industrial scale have given China an unbreakable monopoly in LFP technology. No automaker worldwide can build affordable, safe mass-market EVs without Chinese LFP tech.

马鲁蒂铃木首款电动 SUV 维特拉电动版,以及马恒达 BE6、XEV9 等高端纯电 SUV,其核心动力系统均采用比亚迪电池电芯与电池包。

目前电动汽车主流有两类锂电技术路线:三元锂电池(NMC) 与磷酸铁锂电池(LFP)。三元锂电池能量密度更高,但依赖钴、镍等价格高昂、地缘政治供应不稳定的原材料,且热失控起火风险较高,在印度夏季极端高温环境下安全隐患尤为突出。相比之下,磷酸铁锂电池(LFP) 成本更低、原材料储量充足、循环寿命更长、热稳定性更强,更适配印度的气候条件与大众化平价电动车市场需求。

全球磷酸铁锂市场被中国牢牢掌控,市场占有率高达98%。行业巨头比亚迪与宁德时代合计占据全球过半市场份额。

依托数十年国家政策补贴、持续研发投入、海量专利布局、完整的全球供应链掌控以及先期形成的产业规模,中国在磷酸铁锂领域形成了难以撼动的垄断地位。如今全球车企想要打造平价、安全的大众量产电动车,都离不开中国的磷酸铁锂技术。

在电动化转型进程中,印度在电动车底盘研发、车载软件、机械工程、整车组装领域已具备不俗实力。但印度所有电动车型,在电池核心化学体系、结构设计、专利技术上均依赖中国企业。印度车企此举是理性的短期选择,为快速入局市场,优先抢占时机而非追求技术自主可控。

但这种短期依赖,很可能演变为长期发展陷阱。按照当前趋势,若印度如期实现 2030 年电动车渗透率 30% 的目标,近三成上路车辆都将绑定中国电池供应链。未来一旦遭遇地缘政治冲突或供应链限制,将直接威胁印度的能源安全与交通产业自主权,这也是印度电动化转型中极少被公开讨论的潜在风险。

以下是印度网友的评论:

defaulterjangid5975
Indian Private sector is not investing in R&D they are busy in storing money. So much money but still selling substandard cars with tech copied from foreign brands

印度私营企业根本不愿投入研发,只一味囤积资金。手里坐拥巨额财富,造出来的车品质却很普通,核心技术全是照搬抄袭海外品牌。

 

lifles2
No support by govt in rnd for big companies.

政府并没有给大企业的研发项目提供任何扶持。

nobody4u77
@lifles2 rnd is basic responsibility it isn't government responsibility, government has cut corporate taxes, invest on reverse engineering and r&d instead of begging government and Indian tax payer for everything whil failing at your basic responsibility

研发本来就是企业自身的本职,不是政府该包揽的事。政府已经给企业降了税,企业本该自己投入资金做逆向工程和技术研发,连自己分内的事都做不好,反倒事事依赖政府救济、靠印度纳税人买单,这根本说不过去。

 

Jai_Corporate
Ola mai lakh burai hogi but apni khud ki battery manufacturing plant banai hai

就算奥罗拉有再多争议和缺点,但它好歹是印度为数不多自建电池生产工厂的企业。

 

ronitmcu
Honestly, they are not doing things, sustain, they might spend money, but spending doesn’t create patterns. How many patterns does they have on batteries? In the same way, Tata also trying reliance also tried. There are many companies who are trying in India, but Ola is not one of them, The founder is just burning money.

说实话他们根本没有做长期可持续的布局,就算砸了钱也没形成成熟的技术体系,在电池领域也没拿出多少自研专利。塔塔、信实这些企业都在认真布局电池产业,印度有不少公司都在踏实尝试,唯独奥罗拉不算,创始人纯粹就是在烧钱挥霍。

 

lovenagpal.6504
Han even isne ignore Kiya kitnaa harMi banda hai means ola m dum hai or sab fear paida kar rhe hai

是啊,人家根本不在意这些非议,奥罗拉本身是有实力的,反倒让同行都感到忌惮。

 

poopkljok8342
China has a 100% monopoly on electrode graphite, separators, production line equipment... Without the Chinese supply chain, the world cannot produce even a single lithium battery.

中国在电池电极石墨、隔膜、生产线设备上几乎形成全盘垄断。离开中国的供应链,全世界一块锂电池都造不出来。

 

SiamKhan-j1f
That's why they catch fire like a matchbox.

所以才会动不动就起火,跟火柴一样一点就着。

sjshdhehbesjks
@SiamKhan-j1f jisme aag lagi usme lg ki battery lagi hai

会起火的,本来就是用了劣质电池的缘故。

 

jitendratak914
Hindi chini bhai bhai
Chini ki banayi Battery layi
India ki gaadi main humne lagyi

中印本是兄弟,买来中国造的电池,装在印度自家的车上用。

 

harkritsingh1896
Ola wale ko duniya bhar ki gaali de do par only company to have cell manufacturing in India what are our big multi billion dollar business houses doing just sitting on heaps of cash no research and development

就算大家再怎么吐槽奥罗拉,它也是印度唯一自建电芯制造厂的企业。反观印度那些身价百亿的大企业,只会坐拥堆积如山的现金,压根不做任何研发投入。

 

exception_72
Saari cheez R&D par aakar atak jaati hai
India have talent but lack of funding and support

所有产业发展都卡在研发这一环。印度不缺专业人才,缺的是资金投入和政策扶持。

 

defaulterjangid5975
Private players bhi R&D kr sakte hai. Har chiz govt anguli pakad kr nhi karwayegi. ChatGPT US govt ne nhi banaya tha

私营企业完全可以自己搞研发,不能什么事都等着政府手把手扶持。像ChatGPT,也不是美国政府包办做出来的。

BernanrdMontgomery2
@defaulterjangid5975 acha to private Componies R&D kyu nahi kar rahi? Kon rok raha he unhe opposition

 那请问私企为什么不肯做研发?又没人拦着他们。

Snek-rz3bo
@defaulterjangid5975 govt hi indirectly private player ko rok raha he foreign players ko tax marke

其实是政府在间接限制私企,还对外国企业乱收税。

 

WeAreVishwaguru
The best university in India, the Indian Institute of Technology, only ranks 123rd on the QS list. So, what kind of talents does India have?

印度顶尖学府印度理工学院,在QS世界大学排名里只排到123位,就这样还能指望培养出什么顶尖人才?

 

rajanacharya1135
The first problem Indians have is that they think China is their competitor & enemy. No, China is not their enemy. And regarding competition, China is in a league of its own, now slowly surpassing Western tech in every field with each passing day. The narrow mindset Indians have that China & Pakistan is their enemy is the primary thing that's holding India back.

印度人最大的误区,就是把中国当成竞争对手和敌人。其实中国并不是印度的对手,而且中国科技早已自成一档,如今各领域都在稳步赶超西方。印度人狭隘地把中国和巴基斯坦视作敌人,这种心态才是拖累印度发展的根源。

 

Sparsh_Ahuja
India software aur hardware dono me piche hai gaadi yoka ECU ka software bhi BOSCH control karta hai ABS electronics bhi foreign brand ke upar nirbhar hai.

印度软件硬件全都落后,汽车的ECU控制系统由博世把控,ABS电子系统也完全依赖海外品牌。

 

hanushbc5396
OLA is the only one having cell mufacturing

奥罗拉是印度唯一一家拥有电芯制造能力的企业。

 

ifles2
Shayad isko koi buyout krlegi badi company, apne aap battery bnane ke liye

说不定之后会有大公司把它收购,用来布局自家的电池生产业务。

 

FAYDO-deals
Hope you will cover Sodium Ion cells and how Reliance acquired a promising company only to kill it.

希望你能做一期钠离子电池的内容,讲讲信实集团收购了一家潜力公司,最后却把它荒废搁置的事。

 

shubhamshettyk564
Tata will use their own battery in next year... they are setting up 40 gwh plant in sanand gujarat and 40gwh plant in united kingdom... they have seprately invested 400 million dollor in r and d in collabration with iisc bengaluru and oxford

塔塔明年就会用上自研自产电池,他们在古吉拉特邦萨南德和英国各建一座40吉瓦时的电池工厂,还单独投入4亿美元,和班加罗尔印度科学学院、牛津大学合作开展研发。

 

WeAreVishwaguru
A day without boasting is a wasted day. Even Tesla is using batteries from China. Do you think Elon Musk's research and development capabilities are inferior to Tata's?

整天就知道吹嘘,简直毫无意义。就连特斯拉都在用中国电池,难道你觉得埃隆·马斯克的研发实力还不如塔塔?

 

CAPARTH89
Tata motors is a useless company. They even failed to modify an ice engine properly of Fiat as per their requirement even after getting rights from Stallantis and made a disastrous NA engine for Sierra. So please dont expect Tata to do anything ground breaking. They can use money on marketing only.

塔塔汽车根本没什么实力。就算从斯泰兰蒂斯拿到菲亚特燃油发动机授权,都没法按自身需求好好改造,还给塞拉车型造出了一款彻底失败的自吸发动机。别指望塔塔能搞出什么颠覆性技术,他们只会把钱砸在营销宣传上。

 

gamba4605
BS comment. Tata will not going to use their own battery extensively. Mark my word. No traditional automotive maker ever develop and use their own battery. Indian auto maker isn't going to be different. It just that indian automotive maker is so good at media conference talk thus they gave people like you an optimism. But hard reality will punching at you in not so long future

纯属空谈,塔塔根本不会大规模用上自研电池,等着看就知道。传统车企从来没有几家能自研自产电池并全面普及,印度车企也不会例外。印度车企最擅长在发布会上画大饼,给人营造希望,用不了多久,残酷的现实就会打脸。

MasterShubhanshu
@gamba4605 I think Tata Motors might not develop their own battery but Cannot say the same about Tata chemicals. This Lithium battery revolution gives Tata chemicals massive opportunity to churn money. And it will be foolish of them not to capitalise on the same. And Tata motor might take this vertical integration benefit and start using The batteries made by their sister concern.

我觉得塔塔汽车或许不会自研电池,但塔塔化工未必如此。锂电池浪潮给了塔塔化工绝佳的赚钱机遇,错过就太可惜了。后续塔塔汽车很可能借助产业整合,直接采用自家兄弟公司生产的电池。

 

SMMane
CATL Batteries also used by several companies including Tesla

包括特斯拉在内,很多车企都在使用宁德时代的电池。

 

shakuntalamishra-f8d
ola and Amara Raja ........ creating LFP batteries ....

奥罗拉和阿玛尔拉贾都在生产磷酸铁锂电池。

 

ajatdani619
No only ola makes its own cells Amara Raja Will Licence tech from gotion or other Chinese Company'.

并不是只有奥罗拉能自产电芯,阿玛尔拉贾只是打算从国轩高科等中国企业引进技术授权。

 

shakuntalamishra-f8d
@rajatdani619 ..... i wonder why ..... the ecosystem hates ola ...... with 1% faulty scooters

我很不理解行业为什么处处针对奥罗拉,它的电动踏板车故障率也就只有1%而已。

 

niranjanprabhu
LFP is NOT Chinese electrochemistry. It was picked from UK by Chinese players as there was NO Intellectual Property issues associated with it. Then they improved on it.

磷酸铁锂并不是中国独创的电化学技术。中国企业只是从英国接手了这项无专利壁垒的技术,之后再进行改良升级而已。

 

gamba4605
Of course. Just like how Japanese researcher improve the LI ion battery technology invented by James Goodenough

本来就是这样,就像日本研究者也改良了古迪纳夫发明的锂电池技术一样。

 

arnabghosh2544
What are you smoking? Blade battery is a property battery developed by BYD company. Currently CATL and BYD has hegemonic control of EV battery in the world.

你在胡说什么?刀片电池是比亚迪独家研发的专利电池。目前宁德时代和比亚迪,已经在全球动力电池领域形成绝对霸主地位。

 

rajatdani619
Also just like LFP The Sodium batteries(popularly known as Salt batteries) is also The future of mobility.... Reliance/Jio Bought UK based ferradion energy. Also Tata is also working on its own cells .. And Hate it or love it But OLA is Leading the market.

和磷酸铁锂一样,钠离子电池也会是未来出行的主流方向。印度信实集团旗下的吉奥公司已经收购了英国法拉第能源,塔塔也在自研电芯。不管大家喜不喜欢,奥罗拉如今确实处在市场领先位置。

 

BernanrdMontgomery2
Because of lower R&D spending and Politicians ko apna jeb bhi to bharna he

究其原因就是研发投入太少,而且政客们都只顾着中饱私囊。

 

shyampsunder2003
Mahindra's BEVs also charge faster and better than BYD's own cars in India. BYD cars like seal has a lower peak charging rate and also thermally derates often while DC charging but Mahindra goes upto 190 kW with excellent battery cooling.

马恒达的电动车充电速度和表现,比比亚迪在印度售卖的车型还要好。比亚迪海豹这类车型峰值充电功率不高,直流快充时还容易因为高温降功率;而马恒达峰值充电功率能达到190千瓦,电池散热温控做得十分出色。

 

WeAreVishwaguru
The batteries, motors and electronic control systems of all Indian car brands are all sourced from China. They could be from BYD, or CATL, or other brands. Because India lacks technological reserves and the ability to invest hundreds of billions of dollars to build large-scale battery factories

印度所有本土汽车品牌,电池、电机、电控系统全都依赖中国供应,要么是比亚迪、要么是宁德时代或是其他中国品牌。根本原因就是印度技术储备不足,也拿不出千亿级资金去大规模建电池工厂。

 

WeAreVishwaguru
China monopolizes all the green energy batteries, wind power generation and solar panels in the world.

中国在全球动力电池、风电设备、光伏面板领域都处于垄断地位。

 

Iamrealputin
Well if even one chinese ev enters indian market there is not even a single company VFM

只要有任何一款中国电动车正式进入印度市场,本土车企没有一家能比得过性价比。

 

lifles2
If we really want to be self sufficient in today's world, we must work on battery tech and chip manufacturing. Also, we should work on Li and other rare earth elements recycling. Currently, most kharab lithium batteries go to waste. If we efficiently extract lithium, we will be lithium self sufficient in 10-15 years+ low cost of battery

如今想要实现产业自给自足,就必须攻坚电池技术和芯片制造,还要做好锂等稀土元素的回收再利用。现在大量废旧锂电池都被白白浪费,如果能高效提炼锂资源,10到15年就能实现锂资源自给,还能大幅降低电池成本。

 

WeAreVishwaguru
You are a typical Indian person because you always keep talking. I bet that once you put down your phone, you will definitely go to eat and sleep

你就是典型的印度空谈派,嘴上说得头头是道,我敢打赌放下手机就只顾着吃喝睡觉,根本不做实事。

 

nil_Dikshit
Topic : why is china selling EV batteries to rising indian competitors ?

话题:中国为何愿意把动力电池卖给正在崛起的印度竞争对手?

 

Mallikarjun_SE
Bhai, I own mahindra be6. Literally bought E-Vitara after Mahindra couldn't fix any issues because nothing inside is theirs and have zero control over everything.

我自己就开着马恒达BE6,后来实在受不了各种故障修不好,只好换了维特拉电动版。核心技术全都不是自己的,厂家对整车问题完全没有把控能力。

 

MP1991-r8n
Lol ,mark my words what India will do and our Tata/Mahindra shortcut ,they will develop in house if they are serious or may be buy some components atleast from Japan or Korea and set the tarrifs for Chinese companies to secure atleast India market..Thats their end game, Tesla also doing same for global competition they are buying BYD batteries to stay relevant in price sesitive but for their home market they are using Panasonic batteries which high in price but their also in US they get tax benefits or some benefits like our PLI scheme to reduce dependencies...India compaines also will do same nothing out of box thinking,I have huge respect for ola atleast they are investing in RnD for 2 wheeler batteries.

等着瞧,塔塔、马恒达这类印度车企一定会走捷径。真想做技术就自研,不然也会从日韩采购零部件,同时对中国企业加征关税,守住本土市场,这就是他们的最终算盘。特斯拉也是这么做的,为了价格竞争力采购比亚迪电池,本土市场却用松下电池,还能靠美国类似PLI的补贴政策降低对外依赖。印度车企也只会照搬这套套路,没什么创新思路。倒是真心佩服奥罗拉,起码人家肯投入研发两轮车电池技术。

此文由 三泰虎 编辑,未经允许不得转载!:首页 > 资讯 » 为何印度车企马鲁蒂与马恒达采用比亚迪电池

()
分享到: