Indian vs Chinese Civic Sense - One Exsts, One Doesn't

印度人与中国人的公民意识——一个有，一个无

India’s civic sense crisis is a glaring issue impacting millions daily. the harsh reality of urban Indian streets—overflowing garbage piles, clogged drains, stray dogs scavenging through waste, and the pervasive presence of betel juice stains. Despite public campaigns urging cleanliness, a deeply ingrained culture of neglect persists, affecting even major tourist and business areas. Comparing India’s situation with neighboring China’s disciplined public behavior, this video challenges viewers to reflect on respect for shared spaces and the urgent need for change. Experience gritty, handheld visuals capturing the raw atmosphere of India’s streets, highlighting a civic dilemma that’s been ignored for decades. Like and share to spread awareness.

印度的公民意识危机是一个显而易见的问题，每天都在影响着数百万人。

印度城市街道的残酷现实——堆积如山的垃圾、堵塞的排水沟、在垃圾中觅食的流浪狗，以及随处可见的槟榔汁污渍。尽管有公共宣传活动倡导清洁，但根深蒂固的忽视文化依然存在，甚至影响到了主要的旅游和商业区。

以下是各国网友的评论：

KienPhung-h3k
A correction, garbage piled everywhere in India is not a decade event, but a century event.

纠正一下，印度到处堆垃圾这事儿不是几十年的问题，是上百年的了。

andrewlin6136
British time was better than this

英国殖民时期的印度都比现在的印度强。

Kur01T3nh1
Because in China discipline is a real thing

因为在中国，纪律是来真格的。

factfrontiertales
China has set the standards for whole world.

中国给全世界立了榜样。

WilliamOCarroll-z9q
I doubt that I'm a kiwi and our country is clean

我不太信。我是新西兰人，我们国家就很干净。

JohnDoe-ig1yw
Caste system is biggest problem in India which will never go away

种姓制度是印度最大的问题，压根儿解决不了。

geoff9858
stop blaming the system

别老怪种姓制度。

peterg7120
Selfishness and ultra big ego is the root of the problem

自私和太把自己当回事儿，才是印度的根本问题

jackyjackso
I once traveled to China in late 80s... They were quite poor at that time, but still their places were never as messy and dirty as what i saw in this video

我80年代末去过中国，那时候他们挺穷，但地方从来没像印度这么脏乱。

Klentung8989
Very very very poor then...those who had a bicycle was considered super rich

那时候的中国是真穷啊，有辆自行车都算超级有钱了。

sing2010
India: The greatest de ocracy in the whole world. That is the problem!

印度号称“全世界最伟大的皿煮国家”，问题就出在这儿！

Jim-nt7xy
In India, everyone expects someone from a lower caste to clean up their mess.

在印度，所有人都等着低种姓的人来收拾他们的烂摊子。

bobbyh4957
True, Indian mindset tells them that cleaning is somebody else job

可不是嘛，印度人就觉得打扫卫生是别人的活儿。

linduEndiaPagan
cleanliness in India is illegal

在印度，讲卫生跟犯法似的。

peterg7120
The people has a huge part of the blame too

老百姓也有很大责任。

pravav776cvg
Many people blame things on caste system, but this disrespect for environment and society rules are prevalent across all strata, people are selfish

很多人把问题怪到种姓制度上，但这种不尊重环境、不守规矩的毛病，各个阶层都有，人都太自私了。

Change-xp2ts
Hey, India is a superpower! Its diplomats go round telling the world!

嘿，印度可是超级大国呢！他们的外交官到处跟全世界吹呢！

sensei2203
Selfishness disguise as freedom

把自私说成是自由。

I am from india, i will swallow this

我是印度人，这话我认。

mrnancy1114
I disagree with the statement that gov't can't do anything about trash behavior , Rwanda was once dirty and impoverished but the govt took a very proactive stance against trash behavior and within 20yrs changed the culture , Rwanda is now among the cleanest well ordered city in the world, while not having nowhere near the same GDP as India, and recently Burkina Faso is following in that footstep, leadership made all the difference.

我不认同“政府管不了乱扔垃圾”这种说法。卢旺达以前又脏又穷，但政府主动整治乱扔垃圾，20年就改了风气。现在卢旺达是世界上最干净、最有秩序的地方之一，GDP还远不如印度。最近布基纳法索也学着做，领导人的问题，差别大了去了。

The_Imbiters
You force someone to become dalit, he'll become dalit.

你逼谁当贱民，谁就只能当贱民。

Hacktivist12
The caste system is a major factor in India's sense of cleanliness; only members of lower castes are expected to keep things tidy

种姓制度特别影响印度人的卫生意识，就觉得只有低种姓的人才该搞干净。

picandvideo
Some SEA countries are still stuck with that behavior not just India.

不光印度，一些东南亚国家也这毛病。

teoh3564
You need a leader like Ibrahim Traore

得有个像易卜拉欣·特拉奥雷那样的领导人。

wymmyw8744
this was also china 20 years ago.. china have the courage to change

20年前的中国也这样，但中国有勇气改变。

heTraveler2222
There is no such term as "Civic Sense" in Hindi

印地语里压根儿没有“公民意识”这个词。

edalert199
Every country is better than Slumdia when even the poojeets don't want to settle there

每个国家都比“贫民窟印度”强，连他们自己人都不想待在印度。

Klentung8989
There are caste too in China..based on economy scales

中国也有种姓，是按经济水平分的。

ShaunKheng
What does the Hindu religion teach Indians about behaviours, relationships, respect, and honour?

印度教教印度人怎么做人、怎么处关系、怎么尊重人、怎么讲体面？

armchairwarrior963
You should see British Cities that look just like their home in India!

你该去看看英国的一些城市，跟印度老家一个样！

orkbelly872
When Google Street view was launched in India there was this challenge on X/Twitter to drop a pin at a location anywhere in India, spin 360 degrees and not find any garbage.

谷歌街景在印度上线时，推特上有个挑战：在印度随便找个地方插个标记，转360度看不到垃圾就算赢。

Suffice to say the challenge is at a hard core difficulty level.

说白了，这挑战的难度逆天。

nishurathore8620
You won't believe more then 1000 people died in stemped in India from 2024. Till now

你都不敢信，2024年到现在，印度踩踏事件死了1000多人了。

stephentan7881
India has not effectively united the people. the British put together regions and formed India: a political formation, not a gradual social development from small regions to form the whole country.

印度没把民众真正团结起来。英国把一些地区拼在一起组成了印度：这是个政治拼凑体，不是从小地区慢慢发展成的统一国家。

hawkkim1974
I'm astonished by the striking similarities between India and South Korea.

印度和韩国居然这么像，我惊了。

hmedbehbehani911
South Korea is a beautiful & developed country

韩国是个漂亮又发达的国家。

eugenec7130
It is true that the trash problem is not caused by poverty.

垃圾问题真不是贫困造成的。

It doesn't take a rupee to throw trash into the trash bins.

把垃圾扔进垃圾桶，一分钱不用花。

If everybody does this and the city councils dispose of trash appropriately, it will cost the country much less than having to clean up if everybody just throws trash indiscriminately.

要是人人都这么做，市政部门再好好处理垃圾，国家花的钱比到处乱堆垃圾再清理要少多了。

chotiaulim8677
When you don't respect yourself, don't expect others to respect you, a disgrace to their country!

自己都不尊重自己，别指望别人尊重你，丢国家的脸！

thiritung5331
It is not relevant to compare an educated people with an uneducated people

拿有文化的人和没文化的人比，没意义。

System-m3s
Australian, British, Canadian governments are often blamed for bringing Indian immigrants criminality to their countries but Indian immigrants are also at fault.

澳大利亚、英国、加拿大政府总被指责，说他们让印度移民把犯罪带到了自己国家，但印度移民也有问题。

They know the gravity of certain of their crimes in Canada but they want to take it lightly.

他们知道在加拿大犯某些罪的严重性，却想轻描淡写。

They want to take advantage of it. Many of their crimes in Canada are also illegal in India.

他们想钻空子。他们在加拿大犯的很多罪，在印度也是违法的。

indsong3wong828
I am scarred after hols in India.

去印度度假后，我留下阴影了。

I had to shit in the open because I couldn’t find a toilet ( it was locked ) at a tourist site.

在一个景点，找不到厕所，我只能在野外拉屎。

I got a viral fever that lasted 40 days.

我得了病毒性发烧，烧了40天。

No strong antibiotic could kill it.

再强的抗生素都不管用。

I had to endure it as my body learn to fight it over time.

只能硬扛，靠身体慢慢扛过去。

Baby_Dole_007
It doesn't matter if india has the world biggest GDP.

印度就算GDP世界最高也没用。

No country will look up to india nor follow it's lead while it looks like this.

就这模样，没哪个国家会看得起它，更不会学它。

The whole world has more respect and admiration of Singapore, a country with the 39th largest GDP than the #4 in the world.

全世界更尊重、更佩服新加坡——一个GDP排第39的国家，胜过GDP排第四的印度。

peerajak
No. China was not colonized by European country.

不对。中国没被欧洲国家殖民过。

Only Macao, Hong Kong, and some blocks on some cities of China that were colonizied.

只有澳门、香港，还有一些城市的小块地方被殖民过。

Which, when you divided by the land mass of China, is less than 1%.

按中国的国土面积算，还不到1%。

If your sentence are wrong for 99% we can safely say this sentence is wrong.

要是一句话99%都错了，那这话说得就是错的。

caneestudio
Even their govt. has same value system.Opportunist,India join Quad to contain China since India can't compete fairly.Yet they are in BRICS.

连他们的政府都一个德行。 机会主义，印度因为没法公平竞争，就加入四方机制遏制中国。可他们还在金砖国家里。

继续阅读：中国人   印度人   公民意识

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 印度看中国 » 印度人与中国人的公民意识，一个有，一个无