德国之声：中国即将超越美国吗

Is China on the verge of overtaking the US? | The Dip Podcast

中国即将超越美国吗？

以下是各国网友的评论：

silafaupaulmeredith7251
China GDP in PPP which is more correct is now 1.4 times that of the US But China is 4 times US population so it still has some way left to grow. In terms of key tech for the future China already leads around 75% of these technologies.

按购买力平价（PPP）算，中国GDP更能反映真实情况，现在已经是美国的1.4倍。但中国人口是美国的4倍，所以还有不少增长空间。在未来关键技术领域，中国在约75%的技术上已经处于领先地位。

royj4359
it is only normal for China to be 4x as powerful as the US.

中国实力达到美国的4倍，这本来就是很正常的事。

Monkehrawrrr
@royj4359 After visiting China, I can tell you that China is much more powerful then the US, everything is so new and polished and beautiful while the US is stuck in the 1990s

去过中国之后，我可以肯定地说，中国比美国强多了。这里所有东西都崭新、精致又漂亮，而美国还停留在20世纪90年代的水平。

felixf.3392
Why don't you "experts" talk about the fact that Germany experienced the longest recession in its history between 2023 and 2024? We have serious problems in our country. German journalists should please address this.

你们这些“专家”怎么不提2023到2024年，德国遭遇了史上最长衰退期这件事？我们国家现在问题很严重。德国的记者真该好好关注一下这个情况。

horridohobbies
The US GDP is highly inflated by financial BS such as rent imputation and inflated prices. When you strip away the financial BS, you're left with "productive GDP." China's productive GDP is three times that of America's. Chew on that for a while.

美国的GDP被租金估算、价格虚高等金融泡沫严重拉高。把这些虚的剔除后，剩下的就是“生产性GDP”。中国的生产性GDP是美国的三倍，你好好想想这意味着什么。

josephnduaguibe
DW doesn't even report fact, the data of Americans is stored in the united states already

德国之声不报道事实，（tittok）美国用户的数据明明已经储存在美国本土了。

stephanielau1705
Exactly, its data stored in US-based Oracle cloud system

没错，这些数据就储存在美国甲骨文公司的云系统里。

adamharris1406
China is far ahead of the U.S. militarily and economically

中国的军事和经济实力都远远超过了美国。

chrishaven1489
Economically? That's difficult to discern considering China often fudge their economic data. Militarily? No. America's terrible at a lot of things. But their military is one of the things, if not THE thing, that they're the best at in the world

经济上？考虑到中国经常篡改经济数据，这很难说。军事上？根本没有。美国在很多事情上都做得很糟，但军事方面，美国是最强的

NoyeMetal444
Funniest thing I have heard all day!

这是我今天听到最可笑的事！

rollingdownfalling
China needs to watch out their holding of US debt, as currently US is trying to dilute that 37 trillion.

中国得留意持有的美国国债，现在美国正试图稀释那37万亿美元的债务。

horridohobbies
China's external debt to GDP is around 80%. America's external debt to GDP is around 130%. Let's not forget that America's national debt is a mind-numbing $37 trillion, which is growing by $1 trillion every 100 days. While China also has a massive domestic debt, so does the United States. But China's government controls capital, whereas capital controls the US government. China has more tools at its disposal to deal with the debt.

中国的外债占GDP比例约为80%，美国则约为130%。别忘了，美国国债高达37万亿美元，数额惊人，而且每100天就增加1万亿美元。虽然中国也有巨额内债，但美国同样如此。不过中国掌控资本，而美国是资本掌控政府，中国有更多可用的手段来处理债务问题。

lambertgiang
That is the Art of Deal.

这就是谈判的艺术。

cshan5424
My opinion chinese economy is 5-7 times bigger the united states. Because simply with 100rmb and 100USD purchase the same amount staffs in china and in the US . The USD/RMB exchange rate is 7.12

在我看来，中国经济规模是美国的5到7倍。因为很简单，在中美两国，用100元人民币和100美元能买到同样多的东西，而美元对人民币的汇率是7.12。

QiyanTang-sw8bw
I like the GDP per capital analysis. People always use that to illustrate how far behind China is. But can you help me to make a comparison of debt per capita between China and US and EU? the per capital analysis is so good, lets apply it further!

我喜欢人均GDP分析，人们总用这个来说明中国有多落后。但你能不能帮我对比一下中国、美国和欧盟的人均债务？人均分析这么好用，我们得进一步用起来！

chaomingli6428
If you look at energy consumption, China overtook US a while ago.

单看能源消耗量，中国早就超过美国了。

the0neObserver
What should be discussed is not about who control what, but the freedom to lie without moral principle and integrity. If the media only publish the truth that benefit every human being, then it doesn't matter who control what media.

我们该讨论的不是谁控制了什么，而是那种毫无道德原则和诚信的撒谎自由。如果媒体只发布对全人类有益的真相，那谁控制媒体都无所谓。

georgescar8256
some comments were way too harsh when criticizing the standing of DW. In my opinion, DW at least tried to be neutral most of the time, but of course, every news agency is biased.

有些人批评德国之声的立场时，语气也太苛刻了。在我看来，德国之声至少大多数时候都在努力保持中立，当然，每个新闻机构都有偏向性。

JosPoortvliet
Nice initiative to answer some questions. Maybe you can tell us what the real impact of ukraines strikes on russias refineries is. Some say 15% of production is down, others say 38%. But that difference is huge. With 16% people have to maybe ship vacation out to more by bike. At 38%, can you still transport food into the cities? So what is it really and where is it going? Same w about the flamingo rocket - you hear they produce dozens per month others say they go in production end of the year

主动回答一些问题，这个做法很好。或许你们能说说，乌克兰袭击俄罗斯炼油厂的实际影响到底有多大？有人说产量下降了15%，也有人说38%，这个差距太大了。如果下降16%，人们可能得更多地骑自行车去度假；要是下降38%，还能把食物运到城市里吗？所以实际情况到底是怎样的，后续又会如何发展？“火烈鸟”火箭的情况也一样——有人说每月能生产几十枚，也有人说年底才会投产。

windsong3wong828
When production of electricity , cars, steel, ships, fridge are much much higher in China than USA …..it doesnt make sense to say that USA economy is bigger. Get real. Use the ppp calculation for the economy.

中国的发电量、汽车产量、钢铁产量、造船量、冰箱产量都比美国高得多。说美国经济规模更大，根本没道理。现实一点吧，算经济得用购买力平价（PPP）。

user-gp9mk7wm1s
If China health care service is sold at US price then health care component alone of China GDP would worth $20 Trillion. Exorbitant health care service in US, exorbitant rents, transport cost ect. drive US GDP figure up

要是中国的医疗服务按美国的价格收费，单是医疗这一项占中国GDP的比重就会达到20万亿美元。美国的医疗收费过高，房租、交通费用等也都过高，这些都拉高了美国的GDP数值。

stephanielau1705
It's Trump's " proposal ", NOT a done deal yet .

这只是特朗普的“提议”，还不是已经敲定的协议。

TheRealFranklinDelanoRoosevelt
Trumps logic of MAGA = “America first.” Real logic: “America last.”

特朗普口中“让美国再次伟大”的逻辑是“美国优先”，但真实逻辑却是“美国垫底”。

WinkeyFace1
The China knows how GDP is calculated and yes, the West is wng. LMAO.

中国很清楚GDP是怎么算的，没错，西方正在赢。哈哈，太可笑了。

wallacekatini3424
By PPP,GDP terms, china already surpassed the US regime in Washington

按购买力平价（PPP）计算的GDP来看，中国已经超过了美国。

gregtolley3455
China has overstated GDP since at least 2015, and most likely longer, with real figures anywhere between 12%-20% below stated figures.

至少从2015年开始，中国就一直在虚报GDP，而且很可能更早之前就这样了。真实的GDP数据比公布的数值低12%到20%不等。

ss100-z4z
If a hot war in NATO /EU territory breaks out, all stocks and ETFs will probably crash. Will US-based stocks/ETFs be safer vs European ones, given that US is further away from the conflict?

要是北约或欧盟领土上爆发热战，所有股票和交易所交易基金（ETF）可能都会暴跌。考虑到美国离冲突地区更远，美国的股票和ETF会比欧洲的更安全吗？

rollingdownfalling
Honestly, I am not a big fan of China great, China No1 or whatever (this just sounds so stoogy). It’s that currently the overwhelming US related news are everywhere, even though I am someone who doesn’t really watch US related news started watching them, like MAGA, ICE, Oregan, Korea Upfront, 37 Trillion, Iran, Media Censorship, Trump this, Trump that etc. After-all I probably know more about Germany than the US.

说实话，我不怎么喜欢“中国很强大”“中国第一”这类说法（听着就很蠢）。问题是现在到处都是和美国相关的新闻，哪怕我本来不怎么关注美国新闻，现在也开始看了——比如“让美国再次伟大”、美国移民海关执法局、俄勒冈州、朝鲜问题、37万亿美元债务、伊朗、媒体审查，还有各种关于特朗普的事等等。说到底，我对德国的了解可能都比美国多。

cpy5172
China is not interested to overtake the US. Its strategy focus on raising living standards of its people, and contributing to the growth of Global South.

中国没兴趣超过美国。中国的战略重点是提高本国人民的生活水平，同时为“全球南方”的发展做贡献。

JLTK
Dream on. Haha

做梦吧。哈哈。