Education Budget

China - $900 Billion
USA - $1.2 Trillion

India - $17 Billion

中美印三国的教育经费对比：中国的教育经费是9000亿美元，美国的教育预算是1.2 万亿美元，印度的教育经费只有170亿美元

以下是印度网友的评论：

Pr44434403Abhay
Budget dal ke kya kar loge agar akhir me tumhe reservation ke basis pe student select karne hai merit ki jagah. i believe scholarship and free education should be given instead of reservation in studies.

就算往教育领域砸再多钱又有什么用？到头来招生不靠成绩择优录取，还是靠预留配额选人。我认为教育领域应该发放奖学金、推行免费就学，而不是搞预留名额制度。

 

Healer
Some khajar categories, if you educate them more, they turn woke.
In chadarmodon ko free education dena hi nahi chahiye after 10th grade.
Later they become a nuisance and liability for the administration.

有些群体，受教育程度越高，思想就越激进。

读完十年级以后，就不该再免费让这类人上学

往后他们会给政府制造各种麻烦，变成累赘。

 

Ketan Padsala
wait for 2047, we will be first (but from Last)

等到2047年看吧，我们会拿第一，不过是倒数第一。

 

kk
3 line main sahi se likh doh
सही आंकड़े (लगभग):चीन: कुल शिक्षा खर्च ≈ $900–1000 अरब
अमेरिका: कुल ≈ $1.2 ट्रिलियन
भारत: केंद्र ≈ $15 अरब, कुल (केंद्र+राज्य) ≈ $120–150 अरब

用三行写清楚真实的数据：

中国：教育总开支约9000‑10000亿美元

美国：总开支约1.2万亿美元

印度：中央约150亿美元，中央加各邦合计约1200‑1500亿美元

 

Kossireddi20328
Who is asking questions about castes and religions? Did you notice this in PM Modi’s rallies or in Rahul Ghandy’s speeches and interactions?
The day, we have UCC, no reservations& population control, we can also grow much better than others. Look at where we are now & pre 2014

是谁总揪着种姓、宗教说事？莫迪总理在集会上，还有拉胡尔·甘地的公开讲话里，你听过他们说这些话题吗？

哪天我们推行统一民法典、取消预留配额、管控人口规模，我们的发展就能远超别国。对比一下现在和2014年之前的处境就懂了。

 

Blaze
If these is the condition of CA's in india, we're doomed

如果印度注册会计师都是这种认知水平，那我们国家没救了。

 

Akash
45 billion dollars worth of freebees

各类免费福利开支高达450亿美元。

 

SimplyMe
Tabhi to badhega india nahi balki NETA

照这样下去，印度是发展不起来的，只有政客的腰包会鼓起来。

 

SambujD
Failure of every other institution in this country

这个国家各类公共机构全都运转失灵。

 

Kiran Kumar
India spends 4.1% of GDP ( centre+state)
USA 5.8 % GDP (Federal+state+local)
China 3.4 % Of GDP

印度教育开支占国内生产总值4.1%（中央加各邦）

美国占5.8%（联邦、州、地方全部算入）

中国占3.4%

 

Druva Kumar S
Also check how much income tax people pay in those countries. In india barely 3% of the earning population pay income tax.

再看看这些国家缴纳个人所得税的人口占比。印度有收入的人群里，缴纳个税的比例只有3%。

 

Mr.k
Govt taking gst in every thing andh bakth.. So dnt so foolish while talking.. If 220000 free subsidise given, how india willl change man

到处发放巨额补贴，印度要怎么真正改变？

 

Ajendra Singh Yadav
USA spend 1.2 trillion on education but every year spelling bee compilation won by indian students

美国教育预算1.2万亿美元，可美国每年拼字比赛拿冠军的都是印度裔学生。

AMI KKR
But the student studies in USA

可这些学生是在美国本土接受教育的啊。

 

varunarora9993
Hindustan mein yahi problem kutte ki tarah har gaadi pe bhonkna , baat Hindustan ke 100 crore bachho ki ho rhi 2‑4 amirzadon ki nhi , itni bhi samjh nhi hai tabhi 2 lac crore MANREGA, 4 LAC CRORE KISSAN , 2 LAC CRORE FREE RAASHAN 10 LAC CRORE NETAON KI FIZOOL KHARCH , 100 PUBLIC

印度就有这个毛病，逮到什么就乱喷。我们讨论的是印度上亿普通孩子，不是两三个富家子弟。这点道理都看不懂。曼雷加就业计划花2万亿，农民补贴4万亿，免费粮食2万亿，政客挥霍的经费更是高达10万亿。普通民众处境艰难。

 

Ajendra_Singh29
Sahi baat hai meri gaadi pr bhi kutta bhok raha hai abhi US wale india me kuch accha kar dete to bhi kutte bhokte

说得对，现在就有狗对着我的车乱叫。就算美国人来印度做善事，照样会有人乱喷。

 

DOGLAMON
Abbe bilkul jahil hai kya be..
India mein education state subject hai..
Ye central budget hai state budget jod mc
Education toh sabse ghatiya hai iss desh ka usko deny nhi kar rha hun but facts sahi rakh chew tiye

你完全不懂是吧。在印度，教育属于地方管辖事务。

你说的这个数字，这只是印度中央预算，还要把各邦教育经费一起加上才行啊。

我不否认我们国家的教育水平很差，但要尊重客观事实。

 

moonshot
With due respect with level of numeracy pls remove CA

恕我直言，就这算数水平，别顶着注册会计师的头衔了。

 

Ratnadip Banerjee
Most of the budget goes for freebies. You are always crying for tax exemption, no gst, no income tax. Promoting how to evade tax. Do not have proper figures and knowledge about education system. Hindu muslim kaha se agaya yeha. Don't make everything religious drama.

大部分预算都拿去发各种福利补贴。人们还总吵着要免税，免商品税、免个税，想方设法教别人逃税。很多人对教育体系没有正确的认知。这件事怎么又扯到宗教问题上？不要什么事都演成宗教矛盾问题。

 

 

varunarora9993
Pehle apne desh me jo crores of bachhe gande sarkari school mein ro rhe hain unki baat karo, doosron ka rona bahut dikhai deta hai kutte kamine

先关心本国数百万孩子的上学问题吧，他们在破旧脏乱的公立学校苦苦求学。总盯着别国说事，实在不像话。

 

MR_X_media_
But still USA have all indian CEO because usa have 1.2 Trillion dollars education budget  Now tell me who got good education..??? USA or india ..??

可美国好多大企业CEO都是印度裔，难道是靠着美国那1.2万亿教育预算吗。那你说说，到底哪边教育更好？美国还是印度？

 

Adarsh Nataraj
Central funds is $17 B.. State funds tere baap count karega kya?

170亿只是印度中央政府拨出的教育经费，还要加上各邦的经费

 

varunarora9993
Haraamzade indian villages ki ya kissee bhi govt school ki halat tujhe nahi pata , kitna bhi budget kyon na ho baaki sabse to door door tak door hai

你根本不了解印度乡村和公立学校的真实处境。就算预算再高，现实差距依旧巨大。

 

Devil
So numbers you have given are true?? Who are you fooling?
Education budget of usa is 79 billion and China 27 billion, the number you have given are total spending on education and we spent upto 130 billion. While i agree our numbers are lower but show the real numbers

你给出的数据是真的吗？你在糊弄谁？有人说美国教育预算790亿、中国270亿，你贴出来的是两国全部教育总支出。我们印度总支出最高可以达到1300亿美元。我承认我们投入偏少，但是我们的真实教育经费不止这么一点的啊。

 

Varun
Most education cost is covered in India by private family cost so it does not show up. May be this the reason.

印度大部分教育经费，是家庭自己掏钱，不会统计进政府预算，这也许就是数据差异的原因。

 

RIZU
Kothari commission 1964 ne bhi GDP ka 6% spend krne bola tha or aaj bhi NEP 2020 main bhi 6% spend krne ka bola hai ,itna dasak gujrne ke baad v yhi 6% pe atka hua hai

1964年科塔里委员会就建议教育开支占到GDP的6%。2020年国家新教育政策同样提出这个目标。几十年过去，我们始终达不到6%这个比例。

 

Elephant
That's central only , add state as well , the total is around 100‑120 billion usd

那只是中央预算，把各邦的教育经费算进去，我们印度总的教育经费大约是1000‑1200亿美元。

 

 

Sakamoto Yadav
Facts
USA ‑ $ 1 to 1.5 trillion ( 5.4% to 6% of gdp)
India ‑ $90 to 130 billion (4.1% to 4.6% of gdp)
China ‑ $ 800 to 900 billion (3.3 to 4.02% of gdp)

真实数据

美国教育经费：1‑1.5万亿美元，占GDP5.4%‑6%
印度教育经费：900‑1300亿美元，占GDP4.1%‑4.6%
中国教育经费：8000‑9000亿美元，占GDP3.3%‑4.02%

 

Shivanshu
Taxpayers
China ‑ 25% to 29% of total Populace
USA ‑ Tax Evasion Carries More punishment then Manslaughter.
India ‑ 2% of total Populace paying taxes.
100% demanding progress infra education and world class RandiRona everyday.
CA Kaise Ban jate hai Jhantu Sindhi Taxchor

纳税人口情况

中国：总人口的25%‑29%交税

美国：你要是敢逃税，处罚甚至比过失杀人还要重

印度：仅仅总人口2%交税。

大家天天吵着要发展、要基建、要优质教育，可是大家都不想交税。

也难怪会冒出一堆偷税的所谓注册会计师。

 

Vatsal
Jai Shree Modi Vishwaguru Modi. Waaah Anant Bhai Such a God person. Om Modisharay Namah. Modi Hi Bhagwaan. Just don’t make this Satan a God. Indian structure is ******

致敬莫迪，世界导师莫迪。简直如同圣人。膜拜莫迪，把莫迪当神。别把这个恶魔捧成神。印度体制已经烂透了。

 

trendz
Tax nahi bharega india... aap kr jaise CA tax bachana aur chori karna sikha denge ... tabhi to badhega india

印度人都不肯交税。还有注册会计师教人避税钻空子，印度要怎么发展。

 

anurag sharma
India’s Freebies Budget ‑ ₹15,10,518 Cr.
Our Education Budget ‑ ₹1,39,289 Cr.
Our R&D Budget ‑ ₹38,261 Cr.
Freebies Budget is 10X bigger than Education Budget. And 40X bigger than R&D Budget.
Need to change that ratio or else nothing will be left for development

印度各类福利补贴预算：151051.8亿卢比

教育预算：13928.9亿卢比

研发预算：3826.1亿卢比

福利补贴预算是教育预算的十倍，是研发预算的四十倍。

必须改变这个比例，不然国家没有钱搞发展。

 

 

Shubham mishra
Badk education is the state subject...this is only central budget...if u have guts then post the education budget of all the states of India...but u can't do this...kyuki roti k tukde bnd ho jaenge

教育归各邦负责，这仅仅是中央的教育预算。有种就把印度所有邦的教育经费全部列出来，可你做不到，因为会戳破很多人的利益。

 

Shashank Shekhar
China,USA ‑ only hard work matters
India ‑ Caste,Title, discrimination, superstition bootlicking judgmental mindset, external factors, all things which is null(void) all matters
Thinking doesn't matters but flexng degrees becoming anything through process resources matters

中国、美国只看实干努力。

在印度，种姓、头衔、歧视、迷信、阿谀奉承、主观偏见、外部无关因素，这些没用的东西反而最重要。

独立思考不重要，炫耀学历、靠人脉资源往上爬才是硬道理。

 

DG
Without reforming education system and curriculum increasing education budget is self destruction. Teaching others propaganda with our money is self destruction

教育体系和课程不改，单纯增加教育预算就是自取灭亡。

 

Shubham Jana
You know What you are doing, you know the term very clearly "% of GDP" , still posted absolute numbers. I can still tolerate who doesn't know all these but I can not tolerate the ones who understands everything still post absolute numbers to misguide those who doesn't know. shame

你心里很清楚GDP占比这个概念，却只贴绝对金额。不懂的人我可以理解，可明明全都懂，还拿绝对数字误导民众，实在可耻。

 

luvvic2k1
Agar paisa Education aur Heath pe spend hoga to BJP 7 star offices kaise banega

钱全都投给教育医疗的话，人民党要怎么修建七星级办公大楼。

 

Sandeep
Abe Andhedimag how much was it before 2014 and what about states education budget as most education departments come under state government in India

盲目跟风的人，问问你，2014年之前的教育预算是多少？印度教育大多归各邦政府管，各邦的教育预算你怎么不提？

 

 

SN
4th pass Jholachap head of the nation banega Tabhi to education ka budget decrease karega .... Padega India tabhi to Jumblebaaz Jholachap ki dukan band karega India

一个小学四年级水平的江湖混混当了国家一把手，教育预算自然会被削减。印度人好好读书，这类江湖骗子才会没有市场。

 

VG
What does CA in your handle stand for? Have you wondered what could be the % spend against their respective GDP? Look below, Don’t ever call yourself a CA if you are one.
United States: ~5.4% of GDP
China: ~4.0–4.02% of GDP
India: ~4.1% of GDP (combined)

你ID里注册会计师的头衔名副其实吗？你有没有看过各国教育开支占GDP的百分比？看下面的数据。

美国教育开支约占GDP的5.4%
中国教育开支约占GDP4.0‑4.02%
印度教育开支约占GDP4.1%

 

Arjun
Ye fir lodu argument leke aagya bhai yaar tu CA hai
$17 Billion is the national education budget , all states have their individual state education budget
All combined will be around $120 Billion
China's economy is 6X of india , So obviously their spending will also be higher

又来这套歪理。你可是注册会计师。170亿只是印度中央教育预算，各个邦还有自己的教育经费。全部加起来大约1200亿美元。中国经济体量是印度六倍，在教育领域投入高是理所当然。