三泰虎

印度正掀起一场摩天大楼建设热潮,在建高楼数量的增速已超过中国的特大城市

India is witnessing a skyscraper revolution outpacing Chinese megacities in under construction.

印度正掀起一场摩天大楼建设热潮,其在建高楼数量的增速已超越中国的特大城市。

以下是印度网友的评论:

Rajni Singh
But China is clean, by the way. Actually, we don't know how to properly maintain and develop things.

顺便说一句,中国很干净。我们印度其实根本不懂得如何妥善维护和建设。

 

Meh
They are a government. They maintain who comes and goes in each city so slums and homeless people who have no option other than to litter as they aren't learned much will stay in rural parts of China. They then just need to provide dustbins and hold ppl accountable.

他们有政府统一管理,城市里的人员流动都有管控。那些受教育程度不高、只能随手乱扔垃圾的贫民窟居民和无家可归者,都被安置在农村地区。他们只需要配备垃圾桶,再让人们负起责任就行。

 

Kushal Baral
Honestly cleanliness is more on people, even Vande Bharat got dirty so fast. The govt can create clean spaces, but only citizens can keep them that way.

说实话,环境干净与否更多靠民众。就连“致敬印度号”特快列车也脏得特别快。政府可以打造整洁的环境,但只有老百姓才能长久保持干净。

 

DUCK
also has way more skyscrapers today

而且中国现在的摩天大楼数量也要多得多。

 

AI_WORLD
Indian cities are not even come closer to Chinese B class cities

印度城市连中国的二线城市都远远比不上。

 

woro
Bro tbh I've seen chinese villages well maintained and more clean with better quality than 90% tier 1 indian cities

说实话,我见过中国的农村,维护得很好、非常干净,环境保护得比印度90%的一线城市都要好。

 

AI_WORLD
True Be wise to accept the reality.

没错,理智一点,接受现实吧。

 

sagar kumar
You are Pakistani.

你是巴基斯坦人吧。

 

Krishna Sankara
Envy is the acknowledgment of having lost a secret race

嫉妒,其实就是承认自己在暗中的较量里输了。

 

Alpha kilo
Yaa fine except but India cities are far better then Pakistani cities and I can say bcos u have seen 100 of videos by Pakistani friends who showed me true videos

行吧,但印度城市可比巴基斯坦好太多了。我看过巴基斯坦朋友发的很多视频,才敢这么说。

 

Ak
India should be none of your concern Pakistani. India villages are still a better place to live compared to the shithole of pakistan

巴基斯坦人,印度怎么样跟你没关系。就算是印度的农村,也比巴基斯坦那糟糕的地方好住得多。

 

Shashank Kumar
The reason is madarsa graduates with low iq due to inbreeding among cousins

原因就是宗教学校出来的人,近亲通婚导致智商偏低。

 

Stockprok
How much height is needed to call it a skyscraper?

到底多高才能算摩天大楼?

Telugodu Returns
150 meters or above 40 floors

150米以上,或者楼层达到40层及以上。

 

ICONSIndiaIN
The biggest flex in this list isn't Mumbai at No.1... it's Thane at (5) beating Shenzhen (6)! When a satellite city in India is constructing more skyscrapers than China's 'Tech Capital', you know the narrative has completely flipped.

这份榜单最厉害的不是孟买排第一,而是塔那排第五,超过了排第六的深圳。当印度一座卫星城的在建摩天大楼数量,都超过中国的科技之都时,就说明中印局面已经完全反转了。

Insomniac
The narrative still remains my friend. Those cities are already abundant in skyscrapers. Why do you need to add more when you already have plenty of them?

朋友,局面其实并没有变。中国城市本来就已经到处是摩天大楼,既然已经足够多了,为什么还要继续建呢?

 

MaverickBlu3
This data is just an illusion of this conclusion. We are nowhere in skyscrapers. This FSI rule will never give Indian cities a chance to build actual skyscrapers that we see in other countries

这个数据只是表面假象,我们摩天大楼不多。容积率的相关规定,让印度城市永远建不出其他国家那种真正的摩天大楼。

 

Navadeep Bitra
People will trust nothing when it comes to india. If the data is shown up as CHINA , every body believes it

只要是关于印度的数据,大家什么都不信;可一旦数据换成是中国的,所有人都会选择相信。

 

MaverickBlu3
Bro, it’s not about trust in India. I can’t trust govt organisation anymore. Even if govt intentions are good, it doesn’t matter since RTO, road contractors, FSSAI are killing people everyday due to standards and corrupt protocol they have setup in our daily life.

兄弟,这不是信不信任印度的问题,我是再也不信任政府机构了。就算政府的初衷是好的也没用,交通局、修路承包商、食品监管部门,每天都因为标准混乱和内部腐败在坑害老百姓。

 

MaverickBlu3
Bro, I visit Mumbai often. It is best in India no doubt but due to FSI it will not reach it’s true potential

我经常去孟买,它无疑是印度最好的城市,但受限于容积率,它完全发挥不出真正的潜力。

 

Kaybe
there's no need for ugly supertalls that are purely for vanity and serve no real purpose

没必要建那些难看的超高层建筑,纯粹是为了面子工程,没有实际用处。

 

MaverickBlu3
There is a need atleast in few cities as per capita income grows and we shift closer to developed economies. You can always move to tier 2 cities or outer of tier 1 cities if you don't like the arrangement.

随着人均收入提高,我们的经济越来越接近发达国家水平,至少有几个城市是需要建的。你要是不喜欢,大可以去二线城市或者一线城市的郊区。

 

Aryan Singh1
This means that the skyline of Indian megacities will look like this in the next decade.

这意味着十年之后,印度大城市的城市天际线就会变成这个样子。

 

beingishaan
never! Even I support bjp but i know either congress or bjp both can never do this type of development never

不可能!就算我支持人民党,我也清楚,无论是国大党还是人民党,都绝对做不出这样的发展成果。

Ram P.
Hope so, but we lack the vision and planning.

希望能如此吧,只可惜我们缺乏远见和规划。

Mach dunes
is this suppose to be sarcastic

你这话是在讽刺吗?

Alpha kilo
No not possible

不,不可能的。

 

 

Secular Chad
Navi mumbai has more skyscrapers than New Delhi

新孟买的摩天大楼数量比新德里还要多。

 

Sumit Kukreti
Because New Delhi is a national capital territory & there are restrictions around it. Learn basic concepts first.

因为新德里是国家首都辖区,周边建筑是有限高规定的,你先去了解一下基本知识再说。

 

Himanshu Lamba
New Delhi was built in 1900's by British and there is no space left in New Delhi for building new Skyscrapers, New Delhi was built up by 1970's. But Satelite cities of Delhi like Gurugaon and Noida are rising fast

新德里是英国人在20世纪初建的,到1970年代就已经开发饱和,没有多余空间再建摩天大楼了。但德里的卫星城,比如古尔冈和诺伊达,正在快速崛起。

 

imprasath
3 cities in Maharashtra alone & not even one city in TN ? Strange

马哈拉施特拉邦就占了三个城市,泰米尔纳德邦却一个都没有,太奇怪了。

 

EasyAsPie372040
Hyderabad is Doing best ... & NO Language non sense

海德拉巴发展得最好,大家别再搞语言对立那套没用的东西。

 

Manu
I keep visiting Gurugram, where are these Sky scrappers

High-rise: 35–100 meters (≈ 12–39 floors)
Skyscraper: 150 meters+ (≈ 40+ floors)
Supertall skyscraper: 300 meters+
Megatall: 600 meters+

above 40 floors, I think it will very handful building.

我经常去古尔冈,我怎么没看到摩天大楼?

高层建筑:35-100米,约12-39层

摩天大楼:150米以上,约40层以上

超高层摩天楼:300米以上

巨型摩天楼:600米以上

真正达到40层以上的建筑,屈指可数啊。

 

Himansh54682552
The Dwarka Expy area has relaxed FSI and Height limits + upcoming global with plans of 100 floor+ buildings. And this list is of under construction

德瓦卡快速路区域的容积率和限高都已经放宽,还规划了100层以上的建筑。而且这份榜单统计的是在建项目。

 

Manu
Plans ... still in plan. They have only high rise of 20 to 30 floors residential society.. They are not sky scrappers..

规划而已,还只是停留在图纸上。那里只有20到30层的普通居民楼,根本算不上摩天大楼。

 

IDKMaybe
79 in Thane 27 in Mumbai. Jagah kidhr haiii?

塔那79栋,孟买27栋,这么多楼到底建在哪啊?

 

memumbaikar2018
I can't see names of world class cities of bimaruland..Begusarai, Madhubani, patna, chhapra

怎么没看到比哈尔邦那些所谓的世界级城市,比如贝古萨赖、马杜巴尼、巴特那、恰普拉。

 

Yusuf Shaikh
Skyscrapers going up doesn't mean housing problems going down. It mostly signals that real estate is now an asset class for the elite, not shelter for the masses.

摩天大楼越来越多,不代表住房问题就能解决。这更多只是说明,房地产现在已经成为富人的投资品,而不是普通百姓的安身之所。

 

kanth_mayur
Another Bullshit. If u scroll down that list, Indian cities end there only while there are many Chinese cities.

又是在胡说八道。你往下翻翻看,印度城市就那么几个,后面全是中国的城市。

 

Indianinfolead
India isn't just growing; it's growing vertically! To see Mumbai, Hyderabad, and Gurgaon leading the global charts for under-construction skyscrapers is a testament to the New India’s ambition.

印度不只是在发展,更是在向上发展。孟买、海德拉巴、古尔冈的在建摩天大楼数量领跑全球,这就是新印度雄心的最好证明。

 

Samarth Saxena
Point is all these Chinese megacities are already skyscraper saturated 70%-80% and hence comparison is irrelevant

关键是,中国这些大城市的摩天大楼已经饱和了70%到80%,所以这样的对比根本没有意义。

 

Tejan Shrivastava
Compare the quality of life here in Indian cities with those Chinese tech cities.

你可以拿印度城市的生活质量,和中国那些科技城市好好对比一下。

 

Blaze Tang
I'll be honest. No comparison. Also, most Chinese cities are already built up, you can't build skyscrapers forever, once everybody is already housed, right?

说实话,根本没法比。而且中国大多数城市已经建设完成,大家都有房子住了,总不能一直无休止地建楼吧。

 

Sumit Kukreti
Only some gobar bhakts and chamcha's will define this as a development. Whereas having skyscrapers doesn't mean your city is rich in high class infrastructure.

只有一些无脑拥护者才会把这叫作发展。有摩天大楼,不代表城市就拥有完善的高端配套设施。

 

arupghoshal73
Name calling and abusing on SM platforms demeans yourself. Stop doing that. The Infra development currently on in Mumbai will lead to a world class city in the next ~10 years. We need to swallow this bitter pill of air pollution now for a better future.

在社交平台上骂人侮辱人,只会拉低自己的档次,别再这么做了。孟买目前的基建发展,再过十年左右就能打造出世界级城市。为了更好的未来,我们现在必须先忍受空气污染这个难题。

 

Naveen Chauhan
Mumbai sustain 2250-2500mm rain annually. Dubai couldn’t even able to afford 150mm rain in a single day and collapsed in 2024.

孟买每年都能承受2250到2500毫米的降雨量。2024年迪拜仅仅一天下了150毫米雨就直接瘫痪了。

 

Kshitij
China ko copy bolne wale samajh lein — India late starter tha, slow learner nahi. Ab jab scale dikha raha hai, toh narrative change karna pad raha hai.

那些说印度模仿中国的人听着,印度只是起步晚,并不是学得慢。现在我们拿出规模实力,他们就不得不改口了。

 

Vaibhav
A skyscraper is a building with atleast 150 meter height. I am doubtful if there are more than 170+ such buildings are under construction in Hyderabad and gurgaon

摩天大楼的标准至少是150米高,我很怀疑海德拉巴和古尔冈,在建的这类高楼能超过170栋。

 

Eggsy2
Probably because China is already done building a lot of them?

可能是因为中国已经建完一大批了吧?



 

Anmol nayak
Yes , last decade chinese skyscrapers dominated the charts in under construction. This year , india is the one

没错,过去十年在建摩天大楼榜单一直是中国领跑,今年轮到印度了。

 

Mayank Pandey
India isn’t copying skylines anymore, it’s speed-running them. While others admire finished towers, India is busy turning cranes into a national symbol. From chai stalls to skylines under construction, unapologetically.

印度不再模仿别人的城市天际线,而是在加速打造自己的。当别人还在欣赏建好的高楼时,印度正忙着把塔吊变成国家的象征。从街边茶摊到在建的天际线,我们理直气壮。

 

AI Revolt
This "skyscraper revolution" could add 500+ new towers by 2030, boosting GDP through construction jobs while challenging narratives of China's unchallenged urban dominance.

这场摩天大楼革命,到2030年有望新增500多栋高楼。既能带动建筑行业就业、拉动GDP,还能打破中国城市一家独大的固有印象。

 

Rakesh3
Upcoming projects are like Modi's promise here is fact , twist the fact on to your own propaganda.

这些待建项目就跟莫迪的承诺一样,说是事实,其实是扭曲事实用来宣传。



 

John Zumbro
Its just the "being constructed" numbers. I'm pretty sure Chinese most cities are quite saturated with sky scrappers. So they kinda stopped.

这只是在建数量而已。我敢肯定,中国大多数城市的摩天大楼已经饱和,所以差不多停止新建了。

 

DROID
At end they will make something like that mira road flyovera

最后造出来的东西,只会跟米拉路立交桥一样质量堪忧。

 

Kshitij
Jo log abhi bhi India poor hai mantra jap rahe hain, unke liye bad news: construction cranes ab skyline define kar rahe hain

那些还在不停念叨印度很穷的人,给你们一个坏消息:塔吊正在定义我们的城市天际线。

 

curiousmind618
That's good but , india need to build some unique building. We have currently zero unique building.

是不错,但印度需要建一些有特色的标志性建筑,我们现在一栋都没有。

 

Swaastik H Devgan
Scale is impressive. Now the real test is infrastructure, livability, and long-term urban planning catching up with vertical growth.

规模确实很震撼,但真正的考验是,城市基建、居住品质和长远规划,能不能跟得上高楼建设的速度。

 

Priyanka
Skyscrapers are a proxy for talent density. Moving from horizontal sprawl to vertical hubs is the only way to sustain high GDP growth. High-density zones mean faster networking and better urban efficiency.

摩天大楼是人才密度的体现,从摊大饼式的横向扩张转向垂直中心发展,才是维持GDP高增长的唯一途径。高密度区域意味着交流更高效,城市运转也更顺畅。

 

Kshitij
China ke ghost cities pe lectures dene wale dhyaan se dekhein — India mein skyscrapers rehne ke liye ban rahe hain, propaganda shoot karne ke liye nahi. Reality thodi chubhegi, par data yahi bolta hai.

那些天天指责中国鬼城的人看好了,印度的摩天大楼是用来居住的,不是用来搞宣传的。现实可能有点刺耳,但数据就是这样。

 

BuildShipRepeat
India's building boom is unreal Mumbai alone outpacing entire Chinese megacities right now. Skyscraper era unlocked

印度的建筑热潮太惊人了,如今光孟买一个城市的在建量就超过中国整个特大城市,我们印度正式开启摩天大楼时代。

此文由 三泰虎 编辑,未经允许不得转载!:首页 > 印度看中国 » 印度正掀起一场摩天大楼建设热潮,在建高楼数量的增速已超过中国的特大城市

()
分享到: