Should India revisit the relevance of reservation?

印度是否应该重新考虑预留制的必要性？

Is it time for India to revisit the relevance of reservation? Is Quota holding India's healthcare service hostage? Is reservation killing merit and giving undue advantage to a selected few? Listen in to Palki Sharma.

印度现在是时候重新考虑预留制的必要性了吗？预留制是否“挟持了”印度的医疗部门？预留制会扼杀人才，并给予被选中的少数人不正当的好处吗?

以下是Youtube上印度网民的评论：

krishna sharma

She could speak any language but she chose to speak FACTS!!!

话虽难听，但说的是事实！！

mandar P

Good points raised by Wion Team. Media & parties do not discuss Reservation due to vote banks.

为了保住票仓，印度媒体和政党不会讨论预留制的

sreekar rdy

Reservation is absolutely killing the talent.

印度的预留制绝对会扼杀人才。

Vinayak Pandey

With folded hands and tears in my eyes, I just want to say thank you for saying it outloud.

双手合十，热泪盈眶，只想说声谢谢，谢谢你大声说出来。

Multibaggers' Point

Someone had to say this loud and clear, thanks WION for bringing this out.

必须有人大声地提出来。

Abhishek Garg

Second and in some cases third generation wards of senior government officers are taking benefits of reservation...I wonder till what generation these ppl remain backward...sick of this policy

印度的官二代和官三代正在享受预留制带来的好处。我想知道会传到哪一代…厌倦了这种政策

Hemanth kumar S H

IAS officer who belongs to sc and st their children  also get reservation quota..

属于SC和ST列表的印度官员，他们的孩子也能得到预留配额。

Dipankar Bera

Finally a Indian media raised the real problem in this country.Thank you WION

印度媒体终于提出了这个国家的真正问题。谢谢

Parth Mandaliya

Finally a media with a spine. Thank You, WION

终于有了一个有骨气的媒体，谢谢

Mayank Sinha

All entrance exam students feel this...absolutely agreed

绝对同意，所有参加入学考试的学生都有这种感觉……

Richa Singh

Thanks WION for speaking the facts..Not many channels has a spine to say that.

感谢说出事实，没有多少频道有骨气提出来。

Half Panda

Reservation should be based on economic basis...and should be updated every 5 years or so.

预留制应该看经济条件，应该每5年左右更新一次。

Counter Strike

Reservation is the only reason Indian talent goes to Western countries.

预留制是导致印度人才出走西方国家的唯一原因。

Naman Srivastava

Finally someone is bold enough to speak on this topic...

终于有人敢提这个话题了……

Viswanathan Subramanian

Only solution is to have reservations for economically socially backward people and not based on cast!

唯一的解决办法是对经济条件差的人提供预留名额，而不是看你什么种姓来提供预留名额

Amit

Hats off to say what so many general people can't say.

致敬，说出了很多普通人不敢说的话。

Rama Murti Paluri

Merit should always prevail, but politicians will not let it happen for votes.

任人唯贤，但印度政客们为了选票是不会同意的。

Jasnoor Arora(Noor)

Indian politics runs on reservation quota.  This is a bitter truth and many eligible candidates do not get jobs because of it.

印度政治是靠预留配额来选人的。这是一个痛苦的事实，许多合格的候选人因此没有获得工作。

Rohith Mohan

This will always be a sensitive matter

这永远是一个敏感的问题

Sanjib Ghosh

We all need a revulotionary approach  to abolish the cursed quota system.

我们需要一个革命性的方法来废除这该死的预留制。

Harsha Vardhan Valaboju

Is it possible to remove reservation system, along with caste system. India wins then.

有可能废除预留制和种姓制度吗？如果能，那印度赢了。

Apurvanand Sahay

That's a brave subject. No politician or political groups even dare to say anything against reservation.

这是一个需要有勇气才能说出来的话题。没有一个政客或政治团体敢说任何反对预留制的话。

Harpreet Singh

Reservation harming india not hel it - best line paliki Sharma

预留制并没有帮助印度，反而伤害了印度

Utkarsh Tiwari

I'm very happy atleast someone is raising this issue thank u for this.. we need to remove reservation...

我很高兴至少有人提出了这个问题，谢谢。我们应当废除预留制…

Techyon

Before Independence :

Caste system

After Independence :

Reservation System

独立之前：种姓制度

独立之后：预留制度

vaibhav deshpande

High time that people start talking and force the governments to take action against reservations.

人们真的应该逼印度政府取消预留制了。

Dr Vinay Prakash Sharma

Actions must be taken.

First unite then get organised against this.

我们必须采取行动。首先团结起来，一起反对预留制。

Shrikant Sawant

Reservation should be based on economic conditions of the person, not based on the caste, if he or she economically stable then their children should not get reservation, It's simple.

预留名额应该看个人的经济条件，而不是看种姓。如果他或她经济稳定，那么他们的孩子就不该获得预留名额，就这么简单。

Prabhanjan Telang

Reservation is the reason why I chose to leave India and pursue my masters abroad.

我选择离开印度去国外攻读硕士学位就是被预留制逼的。