Outrage as Indian judge calls alleged rape victim 'unbecoming'
An Indian judge has deleted comments from a court order that questioned the behaviour of a woman who alleged she was raped after days of prests from citizens and activists.
Granting bail to the rape accused last week, Justice Krishna S Dit of the Karnataka High Court said he found the woman's statement "a bit difficult to believe".
Justice Dit went on to ask why the woman had gone "to her office at night - at 11pm"; why had she "not objected to consuming drinks with him"; and why she had allowed him "to stay with her till morning".
"The explanation offered by her that after the perpetration of the act she was tired and fell asleep is unbecoming of an Indian woman," the judge said, adding that it was "not the way our women react when they are ravished".
His remarks set off a storm of prest. Outraged Indians asked if there was a "rulebook" or a "guide" to being a rape victim. An illustration was widely shared online which, drawing on several recent court rulings, mocked up "An Indian judge's guide to being the ideal rape survivor".
Aparna Bhat, a senior Delhi-based lawyer, wre an open letter to the chief justice of India and the three female judges of the Supreme Court in response to the ruling.
"Is there a protocol for rape victims to follow post the in dent which is written in the law that I am not aware of?" she wre. "Are 'Indian women' an exclusive class who have unmatched standards post being violated?"
Appealing to the Supreme Court judges to intervene, Ms Bhat said the judge's remarks showed "misogyny at its worst", adding that not condemning them would "amount to condoning".
Madhu Bhushan, a women's s activist in Bangalore, where the Karnataka high court is located, described the language used by the judge as "shocking" and "absolutely uncalled for".
"His comments are objectionable at several levels," she told the BBC. "What does he mean by 'our women'? And 'ravished'? It's so Victorian, so outdated, it takes away from the seriousness of the issue, which is violence ag inst women."
Ms Bhushan said she was not questioning the order itself, but asked "why did he have to pass these comments on her conduct?"
"It's preposterous to say women don't behave like this. It has nothing to do with law, it's judging her behaviour," she said.
Ms Bhushan is among dozens of civil liberties activists, writers, actors, singers and journalists who wre an open letter to Justice Dit saying his ruling had "deeply disturbed and disappointed" activists and demanding that he expunge the comments.
"Women who make decisions to live independently and make choices regarding their own lives, including their intimate/ sexual lives are still viewed as women with loose morals and character," the letter said.
Rape and sexual crimes have been in the spotlight in India since December 2012, when the brutal gang rape - and the subsequent death - of a young woman on a bus in Delhi sparked days of prests and made global headlines.
According to go nment data, thousands of rapes take place every year in the country and the numbers have been rising over the years.
Latest figures from the National Crime Records Bureau show police registered 33,977 cases of rape in 2018 - an average of a rape every 15 minutes.
And campaigners say the actual number is much higher, because cases of sexual violence are grossly under reported.
译文来源：三泰虎 http://www.santaihu.com/p/50246.html 译者：Jessica.Wu
I hope justice is served and this woman is able to heal someday.
"the judge said it was 'not the way our women react when they are ravished.'"
He's talking as if he has a lot of firsthand experience!
Would he give the same verdict if it was his daughter?
Just because they are a judge doesn't mean they are intelligent.
It is time to arm Indian women with handguns and self-defense training.
I think he was indicating that evidence suggests that the sex was consensual. Evidence!!
India, such a cess pool. If this is how their justice sy em works, they have no justice sy em.
Indian judges reflect the thinking of the Indian male.
"Not the way our women react when they are ravished". How are women supposed to act when they are being ravished?
India....is anyone really surprised?
To preserve the judicial sy em, the judge should be asked to step down and retire from the bench!
The judge is a high caste while poor victim is low caste woman hence this will always be there in de ratic India specially under high caste BJP/RSS rule.
Only FEMALES should JUDGE PROSECUTE AND CONVICT RAPISTS
How did the Judege gave bail to the Accused. He should have kept in police custody and judge should have ordered police should to invesrtigate.
Where oh where are the American prester they are need in that country more than here. Please go over there and save live women lives they matter just as much as George life did.
Women Life Matters, BOYCOTT MADE IN CHINA
Nothing good happens after dark. Stay home young ladies. Don't put self in these dangerous situations.
Another example why India is called rape capital. No respect for women whatsoever. That is the reason parents in India terminate pregnancy once they find out the baby would be a girl.
Judge sounds a lot like Trump.
India is the top recipient of USA economic aid.