从这里了解印度人对中国的看法

印度黑公交轮奸案未成年案犯被判管教3年

2013-09-02 13:15 56个评论 字号:

三泰虎9月2日译文,据《印度时报》报道,印度公交车轮奸案作出首个判决。一家少年司法局判决被控参与轮奸和谋杀23岁医药女生案的未成年被告进感化院管教3年。然而,这一意向判决还将交由司法局根据这名未成年人的表现进行复审。依照《少年法》的规定,强奸最多判三年管教。这名未成年人已经在感化院接受的8个月管教也是算在内的,也就是说,他在2年4个月后就可以重获自由了。这一判决距去年12月16日尼尔巴娅在公交车上被6人轮奸已经过去快9个月。

译文来源:三泰虎 http://bbs.santaihu.com
外文标题:Delhi gang rape: Juvenile to walk free in 27 months
外文地址:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Delhi-gang-rape-Juvenile-to-walk-free-in-27-months/articleshow/22196124.cms

dfgs

NEW DELHI: In its first verdict in the Nirbhaya case, a Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) on Saturday held that the minor accused was “involved” in the gang rape and murder of the paramedical 23-year-old student and sent him to three years in a “place of safety” at a reformatory home.

The dispositional order — equivalent to a sentencing order in an adult court — will, however, be “subject to review” by the Board, depending on the behaviour of the juvenile. The three-year sentence, maximum punishment prescribed under the Juvenile Justice (JJ) Act, is inclusive of the over eight months that the juvenile has already undergone in the reformatory home. This means he will walk free after two years and four months.

The verdict comes nearly nine months after Nirbhaya was gang-raped and brutally assaulted with an iron rod by six people in a moving bus on the night of December 16 last year. Nirbhaya died in a Singapore hospital on December 29, unable to recover from the severe injuries inflicted by her attackers.

周六,尼尔巴娅案作出首个判决,一家少年司法局判决被控参与轮奸和谋杀23岁医药女生案的未成年被告进感化院管教3年。

然而,这一意向判决还将交由司法局根据这名未成年人的表现进行复审。依照《少年法》的规定,强奸最多判三年管教。这名未成年人已经在感化院接受的8个月管教也是算在内的,也就是说,他在2年4个月后就可以重获自由了。

这一判决距去年12月16日尼尔巴娅在公交车上被6人轮已经过去快9个月,罪犯当时甚至残忍地把铁棍捅入女孩下体。12月29日,由于伤势无法恢复,尼尔巴娅在新加坡去世。

以下是《印度时报》读者的评论:

译文来源:三泰虎 http://bbs.santaihu.com/thread-7208-1-1.html

merabharat76 (Location)
Any persaon who is under 18 can kill this rapist and walk free as per same law…………..
Agree (8)Disagree (0)Recommend (3)

任何一位18岁以下的未成年人都可以去杀死这名强奸犯,然后同样逍遥法外……

Rajan Panicker (God”s City.)
The verdict is absolutely ridiculous .After all the laws and regulations are meant for human being , Such seriousless punishment will only help yo create more culprits
Agree (3)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

这个判决太荒谬了。毕竟法律本来是服务于人民的,如此不严肃的判罚只会催生更多罪犯。

Raja Samuel (Tamil Nadu, India)
Finally justice denied….that is India…
Agree (25)Disagree (1)Recommend (11)

正义最终被否决,这就是印度…..

Mohan Dolla (Bury St Edmunds)
Only one question finally. Why is his face hidden? Is there any way that his face is revealed through RTI? Who is working so seriously to protect these criminals?
Agree (40)Disagree (1)Recommend (12)

最后问一个问题:为什么要把他的脸蒙住?难道怕泄露出什么秘密?谁在如此处心积虑地保护这些罪犯?

Navin (USA)
I just can’t wait for the juvenile’s release……I want to do some good for the humanity and India.
Agree (5)Disagree (1)Recommend (2)

我迫不及待地等着这个未成年人从感化院里出来…..为了人道,为了印度,我觉得有必要做一些“善举”。

jeff.jobhunting ()
Once again Indian laws has shown that indian citizens are not protected but being played with again and again. I am not proud to be indian anymore. Pathetic.
Agree (8)Disagree (1)Recommend (2)

这再一次证明,印度法律不是用来保护人民的,而是一次又一次戏弄人民。从此以后,我不再为身为印度人感到自豪。

NAKH (USA)
How many more men will now see this as an encouragement to r@pe, as they get away with it.
Agree (12)Disagree (1)Recommend (4)

看到罪犯逍遥法外,有多少男人会受到鼓舞并效仿呢?

Sweta (Delhi)
Hang him!!! if a court can consider the marriage age below 18 in certain cases why not this juvenile criminal can be treated as adult. Hang him!!
Agree (16)Disagree (2)Recommend (5)

处死他!既然法院在某些案件中认可18岁以下的婚姻,为何这个未成年罪犯不能当做成年人来判罚呢!

Nairwita Dutta (Calcutta, India)
the person is no juvenile… the crime that he has committed itself proves that he is no juvenile. for god sake stop being so liberal to the criminals. after this verdict women will lose faith in the law of the country more…
Agree (10)Disagree (1)Recommend (4)

那人不是未成年人,他犯的罪行本身就证明他不是未成年人。看在上帝的份上,请别对罪犯如此宽大处理。否则,经此判决后,印度女性会对法律更加失去信心的。

namard (India)
India is full of girls.
Agree (2)Disagree (5)Recommend (0)

印度到处都是女孩。

Kiran Kumar R (USA) replies to namard
What the hell do you want to say?
Agree (1)Disagree (1)Recommend (0)

你到底想说什么?

anonymous (bangalore)
rapists deserve capital punishment; they should be castrated in public.
Agree (14)Disagree (0)Recommend (1)

强奸犯就该被判死刑。当然,还应该当众阉割。

Ketan Shah (Unknown)
What a injustice to Nirbhaya as her rapist will walk free in only 3 years…………..
Agree (4)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

对尼尔巴娅太不公平了,强奸犯在3年后就可以自由了…..

Ripu (G)
No worries, let him come out, i myself will chop him outside the jail. Common india. Let him live in jail for the next 3 years fearing for his life everyday…
Agree (4)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

别担心,等他出来后,我会在感化院外把他剁了。就让他在感化院里成天担惊受怕地再活3年吧…….

anonymous (India)
its like testing the patience of indians again and again. I hope riots break out in Delhi after this judgement
Agree (8)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

这像是在一次又一次地考验印度人的耐心。我希望经此判决后德里能爆发骚乱。

Syamprasadyenisetti (Andhrpradesh vijayawada)
In these cases don’t think whether he is minor or major the only solution is simply hanging.

就如此恶性的案件来看,根本就不用考虑他是否成年,唯有直接处死才是解决办法。

SharmaTheMAN MAN (USA)
It is a great calling of justice. Let him go free for 27 months and after 27 months someone or group of will catch him in a dark alley and serve a justice to him.
Agree (3)Disagree (0)Recommend (1)

正义在召唤!就让他再活27个月。一旦出来,某人或某组织就会在一个黑巷子里把他逮住,然后将其正法。

Mahesh Ved (Mumbai)
MOST UNFORTUNATE . BUT WHAT TO DO? MAY BE APPEAL IN SC IS THE ONLY OPTION.
Agree (1)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

太不幸了,但是能怎么办呢?也许唯有上诉最高法院了。

correia (goa)
What!!! Words fail me. I am simply astounded by this verdict. Unbelievable.
Agree (2)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

啥!无语了。这个判决让我震惊拉。难以置信。

kk (ncr)
What a sad day.. this pig should have been stoned to death
Agree (21)Disagree (0)Recommend (5)

多么悲哀的一天。这头猪应该被处以石刑。

Chin Lee (California)
lol… just lol. soon terrorists will use child soldiers….
Agree (4)Disagree (0)Recommend (1)

(大笑)…..恐怖分子很快会启用童兵的……

biplop (New Delhi)
Public will beat those man wherever he will go.
Agree (2)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

不管他走到哪,人人都会喊打。

Mahesh Jain (Delhi, India)
i am feeling ashamed to day that i m living in this country of zombies….totally hopeless
Agree (5)Disagree (1)Recommend (0)

今天,我为生活在这个僵尸国度感到羞耻…….彻底无希望了。

Raju (Kochi)
Excellent I feel very happy I will be double happy if he comes out and do it again againt any major politician or judges daughter. We will definitely celebrating such an event. The makers of the law must be dumbs stupids and rapists and murders by themselves that’s for sure.
Agree (5)Disagree (1)Recommend (1)

棒极了!我非常高兴!要是他出来后再去强奸政客或法官的女儿,那么我会快乐加倍。大家肯定也会欢呼雀跃表示庆祝。法律的制定者肯定本身都是一些傻蛋、强奸犯和杀人犯。

Raju (Kochi)
I urge my children to work hard for their career to migrate to some good country than spend time here in this country of filth corruption inefficiency dumb ministers and useless politicians
Agree (4)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

我要督促孩子努力工作,争取移民国外,千万别呆在这个受腐败政客控制的国家。

Hari (India)
Fellow citizens of India, our blood boils at this injustice. But control yourselves for now. After 2 years and 4 months when this fellow walks out of that reformatory home, he will be greeted by a reception committee which will then mete out the long delayed justice. He cannot escape the wrath of the people then.
Agree (11)Disagree (0)Recommend (4)

印度同胞,这个判决不公让我怒不可遏,大家还是控制一下愤怒。等2年4个月后这个家伙走出改造中心的那一刻,他会受到一个接待委员会的迎接,后者将会代为执行姗姗来迟的正义。到时候,他是无法在人民的愤怒中侥幸存活下来的。

ars1310 INDIAN ()
This is India……….Jai ho……
Agree (1)Disagree (0)Recommend (1)

这就是印度…..胜喽……

asimc1941 (Location)
A first generation criminal can’t attain this height.
Agree (1)Disagree (0)Recommend (0)

第一代罪犯是没法取得这个高度的。

Radha A (Navi Mumbai)
Welcome to my mother land which says all Indians are my brothers and sisters.
Agree (2)Disagree (0)Recommend (1)

欢迎来到我的祖国,这是所有印度人的一片乐土,大家都是兄弟姐妹。

友荐云推荐
    • 他这案件比天一的案件性质严重的多,女受害者死亡了。天一的案件女受害者起初想让对方拿钱私了被拒后才报的警。而且天一案的受害者是陪酒女,陪酒女陪酒后会经常做什么大家都清楚。强奸搭车的女医药生和强奸陪酒女在法律意义上没什么区别 ,而在社会影响上是远远不可比的

          • 离谱的是梦鸽认为只是孩子做错事。。。。。。。。
            梦鸽在庭审后的言论,总是在强调儿子“善良,忠义,热爱学习”,似乎乖儿子不可能违法乱纪。毫无疑问,母亲是最了解孩子的人,但是,梦鸽口中的李某某如何懂事、如何有特长,仅仅是儿子在她面前时给她留下的印象。而李某某不在她面前时,不到准驾年龄就拥有改装车,两年前就因寻衅滋事被判劳教。此次事发之夜酗酒、泡妞、打架,16岁的孩子有如此作为,说他胡天野地、劣迹斑斑,一点也不过分,母亲虽然没有亲眼目睹,事实仍然客观存在。梦鸽用儿子在自己眼前的表现,来替代和掩盖他在外面的行为,显然有她的用意。因为名人之子犯事,公众更会关注名人;未成年人涉嫌违法,当然会引起舆论对父母的追责。把儿子打扮成正人君子的同时,抛出受害人杨某某报假案、酒吧工作人员敲诈等已经呈堂的言论,是在为儿子推脱,更是在为自己卸责。不过,如此“护犊之心”,让公众对于“子不教,父母之过”的古训,有了更形象的理解,也不免使人对李某某今后的成长,又多了几许担心。

            幸亏啊。。。。。。习总没看上她。。。不然咱们都有的受了。。。 :mrgreen:

          • 这就是我说的:权利一旦落入不能控制权利的人之手,就会发生悲剧。
            明显梦鸽是在表演喜剧。。。我把她当小丑看。。。她当歌唱家屈才了。。。 :mrgreen:

          • 未成年人怎么了?未成年人犯罪,被“优惠”的刑、罚应该由其监护人承担。好吧,我一直是极法主义

          • 如果被上的女孩是梦哥,她肯定偷笑了。。。好爽。。。5对1真幸福啊。。。有钱都难买到。。。
            所以梦哥认为那女孩赚了便宜还卖乖。。。 :mrgreen:

    • 关键是李天一他妈太恶搞了,把孩子惯的不象话,还说什么她儿子是纯洁的要无罪辩护,恶心的把我隔夜饭都吐出来了。

    • 印度国家不现代,印度人思想不现代,但印度法律很“现代”,学欧洲尊重“人权”,只不过他们尊重的是罪犯的人权,守法公民就被扔一边了。

  1. 这是印度司法界快速进步的一个里程碑。以往审结一个案件要九百年,而这次只需九个月。印度万岁!

  2. 为什么印度的强奸犯罪率那么高呢?想要咋不去找个女盆友??或者妓女解决。
    还有东北的洪水泛滥,是不是该考虑治理那条河了??我看新闻那防洪提坝加高几米了,比其他地方都高,感觉就像头上有一盆水随时倒灌下了,还有下流能不能挖宽点,图们江口,跟俄罗斯和朝鲜协商清一下淤泥之类的!!!!

    • 在下就是黑龙江的,情况不是你想的那样~
      今年黑龙江和松花江的洪水是百年一遇的,政府的抗洪力度也够大~
      我想,如果换做其他的ZF(如GMD)或其他的国家,早就溃堤了~
      黑龙江和松花江在同江市三江口汇集后直奔下游俄罗斯而去,俄罗斯一样也承受洪水之灾~
      大量的军队、政府公务员、志愿者在同江抗洪已经坚持了一个多月,危险随时可能发生~
      政府、军队、老百姓齐心协力,目前看同江可保。很感人!

      • 我想的是三江平原是不是太平了???下游俄罗斯境内的河床是不是淤泥太多了
        如果是这样的话,那真是很难了。我怕是那年来个千年不遇那岂不是淹完。

        • 三江平原相当浩大,受灾的是局部地区。现在是力保同江。
          目前同江沿线八岔乡有部分决口,不过有第二道防线。
          有部分农田受灾是必然的,现在是重点保护同江市区等人口稠密的地方。
          估计再挺几天最高洪峰就过去了,让人担忧的是不知道水位何时能降下去。

  3. 任何一位18岁以下的未成年人都可以去杀死这名强奸犯,然后同样逍遥法外……
    ————————————————————————————————————
    这个把我想说的讲出来了。。。等丫出来了,找个未成年杀手把他JJ剃了,用铁棍给他爆个菊,然后穿过身体从嘴巴里出来,竖在他们家门口当旗子,这样游戏才算结束吧。。。。
    可惜事实总是相反的,这种人弄不好还会优哉游哉地过完下半生,说不定还娶妻生子白赚一大笔嫁妆呢。。。

  4. 一个已经知道用JJ去强奸的人,还能算未成年么!
    心智和肉体的成熟能用年龄来规定么,年龄就TMD是一个数字!

  5. India is full of girls.
    —————————–
    我觉得这句话应该翻译成“印度的女孩太多了”, 😆

  6. 这个小子应该是穆斯林里的什么人吧,围绕他本身打去年就没少做文章,这也就是为什么拖了1年才宣判的原因

  7. 据说这家伙是高种姓大人物家族里的,连那个上吊的都是为了保他被人安排去死的,从头到尾只有这个犯人的名字是“未知”,相貌从来没有公布过。
    估计过两年就出来当选国会议员了。

    • 恩,这家伙比天一背景大,那女孩之所以死很大程度上跟他也有关系,为了保他没少花心思

  8. 印度人,哦,应该叫印度雄性牲口好性福,强奸杀人如此轻判!
    刚刚看了2012各国幸福指数,印度排名115,中国125。
    现在我有点明白了~