从这里了解印度人对中国的看法

德里:无家可归成千死去,教训没有汲取

2014-12-18 19:36 86个评论 字号:

预料在2009年1月至今的官方记录中,德里市“无名尸首”人数多达18,769具。内政部根据”片区综合警网’的数据更新编集显示,仅今年10月12日为止,就已经发现了2,600多具无名尸首。由’整体发展非政府组织中心’编撰的记录显示,在夏季最热几个月里找到 的尸首较多,这暗示着赤贫者可能因中暑或脱水而死。2010年发现的无名尸最多,数目为3,498。6年来, 可以看到6月份是最糟糕的月份,无名死者总数为2,332人。

译者:ken
来源:三泰虎论坛 http://www.santaihu.cn
外文:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/Thousands-of-homeless-die-but-no-lesson-learnt/articleshow/44819672.cms#write

0023ae7798320ede62461f

资料图

Thousands of homeless die but no lesson learnt

德里:无家可归成千死去,教训没有汲取

NEW DELHI: As many as 18,769 people figure on the official record of “unidentified dead bodies” in Delhi from January 2009 till date. A compilation of the data updates from Zonal Integrated Police Network of the union ministry of home affairs shows that in this year alone over 2,600 unidentified bodies were found till Oct 12.

新德里:预料在2009年1月至今的官方记录中,德里市“无名尸首”人数多达18,769具。内政部根据”片区综合警网’的数据更新编集显示,仅今年10月12日为止,就已经发现了2,600多具无名尸首。

The records, compiled by NGO Centre for Holistic Development, show more bodies being found in peak summer months hinting at the possibility of destitute persons dying due to heat stroke and dehydration. The maximum number of unidentified bodies was found in 2010 when the count was 3,498. Over six years, it was seen that June was the worst month with a total of 2,332 unidentified dead persons. July followed at 1,864 bodies while 1,748 corpses were recovered in August and 1,685 in May. In 2014, the maximum number of bodies was found in June (485), July (364) and August (322).

由’整体发展非政府组织中心’编撰的记录显示,在夏季最热几个月里找到的尸首较多,这暗示着赤贫者可能因中暑或脱水而死。2010年发现的无名尸最多,数目为3,498。6年来, 可以看到6月份是最糟糕的月份,无名死者总数为2,332人。跟着是7月份,1,864具尸体,而8月份找到1,748具,5月份1,685具。2014年,6月份发现的尸体最多(485),7月份(364),8月份(322)。

The data on dead bodies found in winter months remained high but lower than the numbers recorded in summer. For instance, between 2009 and October 2013, bodies found in December numbered at 1,293. From 2009 to 2014, the corresponding number for January was 1,511 and it was 1,201 for February.

冬季几个月内发现的尸体数据依旧很高,但低于夏季的记录数目。例如, 2009至2013年10月间,12月份发现的尸体数为1,293。从2009至2014年,1月份相应数目为1,511,而2月份为1,201。

While NGOs claim that most of these unidentified persons are homeless, so far there has been no study by the Centre or the state to decipher the data and categorize these deaths as destitute, homeless or cases of murder or accidents. This lack of an assessment is a cause for concern, say activists. “The data reflects operations to safeguard those on the streets cannot be restricted to just winter months but must focus on months when the scorching heat can be dangerous. Year-round efforts are critical,” said activist Indu Prakash Singh from Shahri Adhikar Manch- Begharon Ke Saath.

在非政府组织宣称无名尸中大多数为无家可归者的同时,至今中央或州政府都没有开展调查对这些数据进行辨别、将这些死亡分类为赤贫、无家可归或是谋杀、事故案件。活动分子说,这种鉴定的缺失令人关切。“数据反映,对那些流落街头的人员,保护行动不能仅局限于冬季月份,而必须着重于灼热能成为危险的月份。’城市权利论坛 – 与无家可归者在一起’ 的活动家I.P.辛格说“全年不断的努力至关重要。”

NGOs have repeatedly demanded post mortem exam of all homeless found dead on the streets in order to establish cause. In peak summer and winter months every year, homeless deaths are not uncommon and bodies are recovered and labelled as unidentified. In most cases it is seen that the homeless person’s body was found hours or a day after the death indicating the lack of a system to rescue ailing and dying among destitutes on the streets. There are over 185 night shelters in the city but there is no long term plan to deal with the socio-economic factors that trigger homelessness, say activists.

非政府组织一再要求,对发现的所有横尸街头的无家可归者作尸检,以确定死因。在每年夏季和冬季最热最冷的月份,无家可归者的死亡並非不常见,而且,发现了尸体就归为无名尸。在大多数案例中看到,无家可归者死亡后数小时或几天后尸首才被发现,表明对街头赤贫人群中衰弱和垂死人员缺乏救援系统。该市有185个晚间收容所,但对引发无家可归的社会经济因素,沒有应对的长期规划,活动家们说。

以下为评论:

译者:ken
来源:三泰虎论坛 http://www.santaihu.cn/thread-9113-1-1.html

Metta Pillar (State College, Pennsylva)

This is such a horrible story, the extreme lack of any kind of social services and assistance is incredible. How do they even know these people are homeless and not murder victims? What is Modi going to do to bring the country into modern times? There is not even anything said about what is done with the bodies if anyone is even notified, who the people are. I guess I must be naive, but don’t people have any kind of identification? What if this person has a family who is missing them? This is shocking to me, even though this problem exists everywhere to some extent.

这是个如此骇人的故事,任何形式社会服务和扶助的极度缺乏,令人难以置信。他们怎么知道这些人是无家可归而不是杀人受害者?穆迪会做什么把这个国家带入当今时代?发现尸首后,对他们做了什么、是否通知了谁,他们是什么人,连一句都沒提。我猜我肯定是天真了,但人们什么身份证明都没有?要是这人还有挂念他的家人呢?这让我太吃惊了,尽管这个问题或多或少到处存在。

 

Vorpal (New Delhi)

The “lesson” is to be learned by people like Ms Maneka Gandhi; and the lesson is that “stray” people are more in need of help than dogs..

象Maneka Gandhi 女士(人民党北方邦现任议员、动物权利活动份子)这样的人要汲取这个教训;教训就是“流浪”人比狗更需要帮助…

 

Appa (coimbatore)

Very unfortunate. We find people like Ajit Singh trying to grab government buildings in the city where thousands die without shelter

非常不幸。我们发现象Ajit Singh(印度政客)这样的人试图攫取这城里的政府楼,而这城里露毙者数以千计

 

lala hari (Unknown)

Pl. find how these dead bodies are disposed off finally & their source ? If successful I will see people honor you?

请弄清这些尸首最后是怎么处理的,他们来自哪里?要是办成了,我会看到人们尊重你

 

Shree Kumar Singh (Unknown)

Homelessness is due to socio-economic reasons.

无家可归是由于社会经济原因。

友荐云推荐
    • 眼角膜是说那个挖小孩眼那个案子?结论早出来了,是亲戚泄愤作案,从一开始我就不相信是偷眼角膜,这很不专业,人类不是机器人,随便什么地方,随便那么一挖就能拿出来用的,何况用的还是树枝。

  1. 俺们是世界上最大的皿煮国家,无论是饿死还是冻死病死俺们都是皿煮自愿的,屎坑是俺们的最爱,嘴炮是俺们的最强项,俺们跟别人最大的不同就是俺们比别人多了一根贱筋

  2. 三泰虎好坏啊。。。这是往死了黑三哥啊。。。那几个精英咋现身啊。。。好吧。。。为了三泰虎的原生态。。。俺豁出去了。。。 [泪]

    精英们别走。。。北京死的更多。。。真滴。。。据统计北京地区今年夏天到现在死了30万多呢。。。真滴。。。要有信心啊。。。不要被虎子骗了。。。皿煮得定期服用啊。。。不能断。。。 [可怜]

    • 印度的水能喝?据说连花洒水溅到嘴里都会拉肚子,连印度人都敢自己说,印度人没有饿死的(虽然我深表怀疑),都是喝水死的(这个我信)。何况又不是非得说几天不喝水才会中暑脱水,夏天学生军训、站操场都会有那么几个人中暑,印度又是热带,别说非家可归的流浪汉,就是在街头卖劳力的也没地方躲啊。

      • 还是觉得不可思议,夏天热不能去公共场所有空调的地方?大商场门口附近都比较凉快吧,更何况不可能人人都白痴吧,热了渴了不能找水喝避暑??喝水拉死也不现实吧,印度人在这地呆了也几千年了吧,早进化适应了这么恶劣的环境了吧!

        • 有空调的地方?你真心想太多,十来年前人家的所谓空调大巴车还是汽车上面顶了个大水箱的概念,现在这种车不知道还有没有,但空调绝对还是高端大气上档次的东西,有中央空调的场所,比如大商城,门口都有保安,你以为像中国人一样人人都能进去?商场对面可能就是一堆垃圾堆和睡在旁边的人,这就是印度。
          对一般印度人来说,避暑圣地就是地铁、火车站还有挂着地铁牌子实际是过街用的地下通道。但这当然不可能解决全部问题,如果说因为热就能一天在那“避暑”,这简直就是“何不食肉糜”。
          喝水拉死的是外国人,印度人没那么娇贵,但不代表他们就万毒不侵,饮水就卫生。何况平民连自来水系统都没完善,流浪汉去哪里喝水?臭水沟?瓶装水?别说流浪汉,一般平民都未必愿意总那么“奢侈”。我们觉得饮水很简单只不过是对我们自己的环境太过理所当然,伊拉克战争那段时期,我看过一个人写的回忆分享,当时他们城市所在地区被封锁,水电无人管理被切断,就一两周的时间,整个城市就变成地狱,水、面包、武器,这就是真实能活下去的东西,你相信吗?才不到半个月,平时触手可及的东西就变成了奢侈品。干净的水并不是那么理所当然的东西。

  3. 真是很可怜啊。脆弱的生命,希望有更多的人能关心第三世界的穷人们。穷富差距过大真心不好。中国目前好像也有这种趋势。