从这里了解印度人对中国的看法

中国南水北调工程正式通水入北京

2014-12-14 10:29 67个评论 字号:

这项耗资480亿磅的工程或许可以减缓炎旱的北方的用水危机,但是被干旱困扰的南方地区以及那里的农民又为此付出了多少代价呢?在周五下午,中国悄然为一直以来最为重要的工程项目:南水北调揭幕。这项工程是一个耗资480亿英镑,全长2400公里的由运河与隧道组成的巨型网络,旨在从湿润的中国南方向炎热的、工业化的北方每年转移448亿立方米的水。在下午2:32,南水北调的中线工程正式通水:从中国湖北省的丹江口水库引水至北京--这相当于从Corcica到伦敦的距离。官方认为中国的用水危机会让它的发展倒退许多年,而这项工程就将解决这个危机。

译者:我是阿点
来源:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.com/wtfy/15173.html
外文:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/dec/12/china-water-diversion-project-beijing-displaced-farmers

China south-north water project

China’s water diversion project starts to flow to Beijing

中国南水北调工程通水进入北京

£48bnscheme may provide relief to the parched north, but at what cost to thedrought-ridden south and its displaced farmers?

这项耗资480亿磅的工程或许可以减缓炎旱的北方的用水危机,但是被干旱困扰的南方地区以及那里的农民又为此付出了多少代价呢?

OnFriday afternoon, China quietly inaugurated one of the biggest engineeringprojects of all time: the South-North Water Diversion, a £48bn, 2,400km networkof canals and tunnels, designed to divert 44.8bn cubic metres of water annuallyfrom China’s humid south to its parched, industrialised north.

在周五下午,中国悄然为一直以来最为重要的工程项目:南水北调揭幕。这项工程是一个耗资480亿英镑,全长2400公里的由运河与隧道组成的巨型网络,旨在从湿润的中国南方向炎热的、工业化的北方每年转移448亿立方米的水。

At2.32pm, the project’s “middle line” officially began carrying water from theDanjiangkou reservoir in central China’s Hubei province to Beijing – thedistance from Corsica to London. The project, officials say, will save Chinafrom a water crisis that could set its development back years.

在下午2:32,南水北调的中线工程正式通水:从中国湖北省的丹江口水库引水至北京--这相当于从Corcica到伦敦的距离。官方认为中国的用水危机会让它的发展倒退许多年,而这项工程就将解决这个危机。

It hasalso destroyed Wang Yanhe’s life. Wang was born near the Danjiangkou reservoirin 1979, married young and had two children – the family lived between a smallstream and a leafy hillside, and grew a variety of grains. In 2009, seven yearsafter the project was approved, officials informed him that the reservoir’swater levels were rising and that his village would be submerged. About 345,000villagers have been displaced by the project to date, and Wang soon became oneof them. The government gave him a home in the Heba New Migrant Village by adusty highway in rural Pingdingshan, a coal-rich municipality in neighbouringHenan province whose name translates to “flat mountain”.

但这毁了Wang Yanhe的生活。Wang在1979年出生在丹江口水库附近,年纪轻轻结了婚并有了两个小孩——一家人在青山绿水之中生活,并种植有许多庄稼。在2009年,也就是在南水北调工程被批准七年后,官员告知他丹江口水库的水位正在上升,他所生活的村庄会被淹没。到目前为止,已经有大约345,000名村民由于这项工程被重新安置,wang很快也成为他们中的一员。政府给了他位于heba移居新村的一处住处,它位于平顶山郊区里一条尘土飞扬的高速公路旁。平顶山是一座煤矿资源丰富的城市,位于邻近的河南省内,它字面上的意思是“平的山”。

Thencame the drought. This summer was Pingdingshan’s driest in 63 years – Wang’scorn crop only grew to knee-height, forcing him to abandon his harvest.“Nothing is as good as before,” he said, chain-smoking cigarettes in hisconcrete-floored living room. His roof leaks; he can’t speak the local dialect.Officials promised him 0.2 acres of land, but only gave him 0.15. “After wearrived, we realised that the land was all dry,” he said. “So it doesn’t evenmatter what they promised us.”

这之后他便遭遇了干旱。这个夏天是平顶山63年来最为干旱的一年,wang种植的玉米只长到膝盖那么高,这让他无法收获丰收。“没有一样东西是比以前好的”,他在铺着水泥地板的新起居室里不停地抽着烟说道。他的屋顶漏雨,他也无法说当地的方言。官员允诺会给他0.2英亩的土地,但是实际上只兑现了0.15英亩。“在我们到了那以后,我们才发现那里的土地全是干旱的”他说道“他们说要给我们土地说了等于没说”

TheHenan Daily newspaper announced the line’s inauguration in a pithy microblog postonFriday. “Being a peoples’ engineering project, in keeping with a frugal andpragmatic working style, celebratory activities will be kept as simple aspossible,” it said. “No officials will take part in the ceremonies.”

河南日报周五在一则简短的微博中对南水北调中线工程通水这一事件进行了的报导:“作为一项民生工程,将继续贯彻节俭务实作风,通水庆祝活动也将尽量简化,各级领导将不参加仪式”

China’sbooming economy over the past three decades, coupled with a long-held mandateto “grow first, clean up later”, has been cataclysmic for thecountry’s once-bountiful lakes, rivers and aquifers. Morethan half of China’s 50,000 rivers have vanished over the past two decades,according to China’s first national census of water,published last year. About 70% of its remaining fresh water is polluted. “If wecontinue with our business-as-usual model, China will basically run out ofwater,” said Feng Hu, a water analyst with the Hong Kong-based researchgroup China Water Risk. “Itwon’t have enough water to power its economy.”

中国过去45年的飞速发展一直秉承着长期以来“先发展后治理”的原则,这对曾经美丽的山川河流都造成了灾难性的破坏。根据去年发表的首份中国水资源普查公报显示,已有超过半数的河流在过去30年间干涸,大致70%的淡水被污染。“如果我们继续我们之前的发展模式,中国的水资源将会耗尽”一位来自香港研究小组“chinawater risk”的水资源分析师,feng hu说道,“短缺的水资源将无法推进国家的经济发展”

Theproject has roots in an offhand comment by Mao Zedong who, onan inspection tour in the early 1950s, said: “The south has plenty of water,but the north is dry. If we could borrow some, that would be good.” Theproject has three sections: a1,150km eastern line, which runs from the lower Yangtze River to Tianjin; themiddle line, from Danjiangkou to Beijing; and a western line, which could someday link the headwaters of the Yangtze and Yellow rivers across thehigh-altitude Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. The eastern line began delivering waterto coastal Shandong province last winter. The western line remains largelyconceptual, so grand in scale that it may ultimately prove impossible to build.

这项工程的启动源自毛泽东在50年代前期考察时临时发表地一次评论,他说:“南方有着充裕地水资源但是北方却很干旱。倘若我们能从南方借点水到北方,那就太好了。”这项工程分为三个部分:一条长达1150km,从扬子江至天津的东部线;从丹江口到北京的中部线;还有在将来某天能将扬子江与黄河的源头穿越青藏高原连接起来的西部线。东部线在去年冬天已经开始向山东省沿海地区输送水资源,而西部线还大大地停留在概念阶段,过于庞大的设计规模或许会让它最终无法被建造完成。

While the project could provide somemuch-needed relief, it “will never solve north China’s water problem”, saidJennifer Turner, director of the China Environment Forum at the Wilson Centerin Washington DC. She called the project a “Band-Aid” rather than a long-termsolution. “The challenge in the water sector, writ large, is that it is sohooked into supply-side management,” she said. “It’s like the engineers inChina have a special tattoo that says ‘nothing is too big’ – they’ll move watermassive distances rather than get deep and dirty into the mess of pushingeffective water conservation.”

“尽管这项工程能提供一些非常有用的帮助,但是它将永远也无法真正解决中国北部的水资源问题”中国环境论坛的主任Jenniferturner在华盛顿特区的wilson中心如此说道。她将这项工程称之为“创可贴式的补救”,并不能成为长远的解决方案。“水务部门的挑战很明显是在于其与供应方管理之间的联系过于密切”她说道,“这就像是中国的工程师在身上纹了一个写着‘没有什么大事是无法完成的’的特殊纹身,他们要跨越极长的距离去运输水,却不愿意去深入到像建造有效的水资源保护区这样的麻烦事中。”

In February,Qiu Baoxing, vice-minister of the Ministry of Housing and Urban-RuralDevelopment, called the project unsustainable. “As thescale of the project gets bigger and the distance gets longer, it is more andmore difficult to divert water,” he wrote. “Recycled water could replacediverted water. Most Chinese cities are capable of finding more water if wedevelop water desalination technology and collect more rain water.”

二月,住房与城乡建设部副部长qiu boxing称这项工程是不可行的。“随着这项工程的规模变得越来越大,输水距离越来越长,传送水资源也变得越来越困难。”他写道,“再循环水能替代传输水,倘若我们能发展水脱盐技术并且同时收集利用更多的雨水,大部分的中国城市都能够因此得到更多的水资源。

Experts saythe south may no longer have enough water to spare. They say the project coulddecimate the Han River, an important tributary of the Yangtze – about 40% ofthe river’s water will eventually be diverted north, despite acute watershortages that already plague the cities along its banks. In 2011, five monthsof drought in Hubei province left 315,000 people short of drinking water. TheDanjiangkou reservoir dropped to four metres below “dead water” level,rendering it unusable. Speculation that the South-North Water Diversion projectcaused this year’s drought grew so heated that state media issued a denial. “Henanprovince is the recipient of benefits from the [project],” Yang Biantong, aspokesman for Henan’s flood control and drought relief department, told thePeople’s Daily in late August. “Not only has it not had a negative effect, the[project] has also been extremely helpful.”

专家指出南方地区或将不再拥有足够的水资源。他们认为该项目会使汉水,一条扬子江的主要支流的储水量大幅减少——大约40%的降水将会被最终调往北方。而在此之前,严重的水资源短缺已经席卷了这条河流两岸的城市。在2011年,时长五个月的湖北旱灾造成315,000人缺少饮用水。丹江口水库的水位线掉落到“死水”线四米以下,这让它不能被使用。关于南水北调工程引起旱灾的猜测日益高涨,甚至引起官媒出面否认。“河南省是这项工程的受益者”,河南洪水控制与干旱救灾部发言人yangbiantong在八月份对人民日报的记者说道,“这项工程不仅不会带来任何危害,它还相当的有益。”

ChristineBoyle, founder of Blue Horizon Insight and an expert onChina’s water issues, said the issue boils down to how one defines a drought.In addition to crippling weather droughts – periods of little rainfall – Chinais also suffering from economic droughts, which occur when the demand for wateroutstrips supply. “You can’t say the South-North Water Diversion is causing aweather drought,” she said. “But you can say it’s intensifying an economicdrought.” Many Chinese farmers are already economically squeezed, andincreasingly erratic weather patterns, perhaps related to climate change –freezing winters, blistering summers, floods and droughts – are now pushingthem into a state of emergency.

Christineboyle是bluehorizon insight 的创始人,也是中国水资源问题的一名专家,他认为这个问题可以归结到如何去定义干旱。中国在经历严重的自然旱灾的同时,也在经受着经济上的干旱,而这发生在水资源供不应求的情况下。“你不能说南水北调造成了自然干旱”,她说,“但是你可以说它加剧了经济干旱”。许多中国农民已经在经济上受到挤压,而目前越来越阴晴不定的天气(这或许与气候变化有关)-极寒的冬天,灼热的夏天,洪水与干旱-正在把他们逼向紧迫的境地。

TheSouth-North Water Diversion project began sending emergency water supplies toPingdingshan in mid-August and, according to the official newswire Xinhua, the diversion was asuccess. The middle line delivered more than 50m cubic metres of water to thecity’s Baiguishan reservoir over a month and a half, it said, “effectivelyrelieving the scarce water supply of Pingdingshan city’s one million-plusresidents”.

根据新华网的报导,南水被调工程在八月中旬已开始向平顶山成功运输紧急供水。中部线在一个半月内向平顶山市的baiguishan水库运输水资源超过5000万立方米,新华网写道:“其有效缓解了平顶山市一百多万居民的水资源匮乏问题”。

分页: 1 2

友荐云推荐
    • 实际上CCTV是属于选择性报道,任何媒体都是有政治立场的(不管他标榜自己有多读利多公正)。相比较,CNN和BBC关于中国的一些捏造新闻,和大量转载几个门户网站上的假新闻。CCTV就显得相当不错了。

  1. 不但要有南水北调,应该也有北水南调工程,有时候北方的大水也是很吓人的。况且,本地的水资源的保护也应该加强,不能每个河流都成为臭水沟。

  2. A good article shouldtry to analyse the pros and cons about such a project,not just grab a fewunhappy guys on the streets and filter out all the positive comments一篇好文章应该试图去分析这个工程的优缺点而不是仅仅从街上抓来一些不开心的家伙进行采访然后把所有正面的评论都遮蔽掉。—————————————————————————————————————————-国安局的同志请把这个人暗杀了。。。。在此也对战忽局同志提出严厉批评!

  3. 英国佬还是蛮灵咣的,中国人口多,平均资源少,资源分布不平衡,南水北调工程应该利大于弊,然到不做这个工程河南就不会干旱。

  4. 相信任何政策都有受益者和受害者,问题是比例有多少,受害者是否得到补偿,文章举例了一个受害人,但是为什么没有受益人的报道呢?这种南水北调的大工程肯定事先有着大量的评估,不是一个普通的新闻人能完全理解的,当然最好每个人都能有知情权,不光知道好的一面,还应该知道差的一面,我想大多数人还是能理解的。唉,我可能太理想化了。

      • 我没有看过这部纪录片,我会找这个视频看一下,我相信这个纪录片是真实的。我不知道这部纪录片里面除了这些正面信息外是否告诉了大家这个工程的是否有负面的影响无法排除,也想知道当时决策时有哪些反对意见,反对理由是什么,对于这些反对意见的解决方案是什么。同时也想知道决策过程。

  5. 咱来看看大英帝国这些年都干了啥。。。哇哦。。。原来啥都没干。。。那居然还到处闹罢工。。。哎。。。宝贝你干成这样。。你让我咋夸你嗫。。。

  6. 哪天没人抨击你了 没人打击你了 没人遏制你了 说不定就散漫了 我看中国历史 这几千年来 中华民族是一个没有外敌就没有动力的民族啊 如果四海升平说不定自己就把自己玩瞎了

    • 没有外敌,选择自杀,这在中国是常有的事。郑和大船不也是出去溜达一圈,左右一看,前后几百年都没有对手。太孤独了,人家选择了自杀。

      • 现在应该不会像以前了。。以前那科技水平,能看到的世界就这么大。现在别说米国这个强敌不是这么容易对付,以后就是米国倒了,也还有其他国家站起来。眼光宽广了,没敌人,咱就给自己找敌人呗。

  7. 无耻的阴国人嫉妒去吧,死去吧,记得2008年北京奥运会期间,一位英国记者看到中国丰盛美食时,十分感慨的说;“与中国人的食物相比我们英国人吃的简直就是屎……“,不错他们吃的就是屎。

  8. 一篇典型的西方对中国的报道,充斥着羡慕嫉妒恨,不自觉的流露出白人那种丑陋的小人嘴脸,恶心!

  9. 她说道,“这就像是中国的工程师在身上纹了一个写着‘没有什么大事是无法完成的’的特殊纹身,他们要跨越极长的距离去运输水,却不愿意去深入到像建造有效的水资源保护区这样的麻烦事中。” 水源保护的前提是有水源

  10. MimirTheElfA good article shouldtry to analyse the pros and cons about such a project,not just grab a fewunhappy guys on the streets and filter out all the positive comments一篇好文章应该试图去分析这个工程的优缺点而不是仅仅从街上抓来一些不开心的家伙进行采访然后把所有正面的评论都遮蔽掉。笑尿

  11. 除了南北差异之外,贫富差距也是重要原因。北方很多地方缺水到令人触目惊心的地步,经济快速发展,尤其北方多重工业,人口过于集中的地区,超采地下水严重,可以说补充水资源有点刻不容缓的急迫感,其实南方也有不少地区缺水,南方经济也在高速增长,人口也十分庞大,但南方水资源总体还算充足,你们是没见过北方很多农民,有时候洗澡都有点舍不得,所以怎么说呢,南方的同胞还望体谅下,尤其有大武汉情结的湖北朋友,呵呵。

    • 嗯,确实,以前就听老爸说过过去大西北上山下乡的时期,那里的人真的一辈子就洗三次澡,出生一次,结婚一次,去世一次,那时期,那疙瘩,“洗澡”就是大勺子在背上干刮;最近陪老妈看了一个真人实景秀节目,是几个女明星去好像是甘肃贫困山区家庭住的,虽然没以前老爸下乡时期夸张,但那个穷人家小孩也是说出城的时候才洗一次。还有大学时期有个学妹的舍友也是夏天好几天不一定洗澡,虽然说不缺水,但这种习惯也说明了一些问题。相比起来……我们这种酷夏日子甚至早中晚一天洗三次澡的确实有点难以感受。

  12. 世界上哪有十全十美的事?那就什么别干了,搞工程破换了环保,建工厂占用了土地。他奶奶的,总从反面说,不知这些垃圾的神经是否正好接反了。

  13. 南水北调就是一个错误,一个拍领导马屁的经典错误,大错特错,地形被强制改变,地球自然行程的沟壑被强行改变,现在地质灾害那么多,南水北调有很大的原因存在!